PUNJAB & HARYANA HIGH COURT
S.S.Sodhi, Amarjeet Chaudhary and Ashok Bhan JJ.
Ruth Parveen John
Versus
Paul Crescent John
Matrimonial Reference No. 1 of 1989,
Decided On : AUGUST 20, 1993
Bigamy with Adultery - Dissolution of Marriage - The court confirmed the decree for dissolution of marriage in favor of the wife on the ground that the husband had been guilty of bigamy with adultery. The husband had married another woman during the subsistence of his marriage with the petitioner, and even according to his own case, the petitioner had disappeared, which could have provided him justification for raising the legal presumption that she was no longer alive. The court found that bigamy with adultery stood established against the respondents and confirmed the decree for dissolution of marriage.
Fact of the Case:
The wife filed a petition for divorce under Section 10 of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869, on the ground of bigamy with adultery, alleging that her husband had married another woman without her knowledge and consent during the subsistence of their marriage.
Finding of the Court:
The court confirmed the decree for dissolution of marriage in favor of the wife, finding that bigamy with adultery stood established against the respondents.
Issues: Confirmation of the decree for dissolution of marriage on the ground of bigamy with adultery.
Ratio Decidendi: The husband's marriage to another woman during the subsistence of his marriage with the petitioner, and the circumstances surrounding the disappearance of the petitioner, led to the establishment of bigamy with adultery, justifying the confirmation of the decree for dissolution of marriage.
Final Decision: The court confirmed the decree for dissolution of marriage in favor of the wife and against the respondents, with no order as to costs.
S.S.Sodhi, J.
1. The matter here concerns confirmation of the decree for dissolution of marriage made by the District Judge, Chandigarh in favour of the wife on the ground that the husband had been guilty of bigamy with adultery.
2. The petition for divorce here had been made by the wife under Section 10 of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869 , on the ground of bigamy with adultery, founded upon the allegation that during the subsistence of their marriage, her husband had without her knowledge and consent married respondent 2 Smt. Ruby.
3. A reference to the record shows that the marriage of respondent Paul Crescent John with the other respondent Smt. Ruby stands admitted by them, as also that this happened during the subsistence of marriage of Paul Crescent H. John with the petitioner Ruth Parveen John. The plea put forth in defence being that the petitioner was not traceable and had not been heard of for several years and it was in these circumstances that the respondents had married each other. Reference was made to various attempts made by the respondents particularly the husband to trace the petitioner.
4. Be that as it may, the fact remains that it was during the subsistence of his marriage with the petitioner Ruth Parveen John that respondent Paul Crescent John marrid Smt. Ruby. Further, even according to the husbands own case, the petitioner had disappeard on February 15, 1979 and the marriage that he had contracted with Smt. Ruby on May 3, 1985 was within less than a period of seven years, which could perhaps, in terms of Section 108 of the Evidence Act have provided him justification for raising the legal presumption that she was no longer alive.
5. Keeping these circumstances in view, in the context of other material on record, there can be no escape from the conclusion that bigamy with adultery stands established against the respondents and we consequently hereby confirm the decree for dissolution of marriage passed in favour of the petitioner Smt. Ruth Parveen John and against the respondents Paul Crescent John and Smt. Ruby.
6. In the circumstances, however, there will be no order as to costs.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.