2011 Supreme(P&H) 1965
2011(3) RCR(Cri) 234
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
S.S. SARON
Balbir Singh -Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and another -Respondents
CRM No. M-24409 of 2010
Decided on: 10.11.2010
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Quashing of FIR
Act Referred
Headnote
Quashing of FIR - Civil Dispute - Indian Penal Code - Section 420, Section 120-B
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner sought quashing of FIR for offences under Section 420 and Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code. The dispute arose from a civil agreement for the purchase of land, which was later compromised between the parties.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the dispute was primarily civil in nature and related to a breach of agreement, making it not normally maintainable as a criminal prosecution. The court also considered precedents where similar disputes were held to be civil liabilities and not criminal offences.
Issues: The main issue was whether the FIR for offences under Section 420 and Section 120-B of the IPC should be quashed due to the compromise between the parties and the primarily civil nature of the dispute.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that a dispute arising from a mere breach of an agreement to sell is primarily civil in nature and not normally maintainable as a criminal prosecution. It also considered the compromise between the parties and the precedents where similar disputes were held to be civil liabilities.
Final Decision: The court allowed the petition and quashed the FIR and all subsequent proceedings for the offences under Section 420 and Section 120-B of the IPC.
Advocate Appeared:
Ms. Monika Goyal, Advocate for the petitioner. Mr. VPS Sidhu, AAG, Punjab. Mr. Vikas Gupta, Advocate for Mr. Anil Garg, Advocate with Rattan Singh (respondent No.2) in person.
S.S. SARON, J.
1. Rattan Singh (respondent No.2) is present in Court and is identified by his counsel. It is stated by him that he has no objection to the quashing of the FIR as he has compromised the matter with petitioner Balbir Singh.
Heard counsel for the parties.
2. The petitioner seeks quashing of FIR No.269 dated 27.12.2001 registered at Police Station City Moga for the offences 420 and 120-B Indian Penal Code (“IPC” – for short) and also the consequential proceedings in pursuance thereof.
3. The FIR in the case has been registered on the complaint of Rattan Singh (respondent No.2) against Balbir Singh (petitioner) and his brother Daljit Singh. According to the complainant, he had agreed to purchase 20 kanals 14 marlas of land situated in Lehara Bet, Tehsil Zira, Distrit Ferozepur from Balbir Singh (petitioner). An agreement for the purchase of the land was entered into on 19.7.1997 and the rate was settled at `1,50,000/-per kila (acre). The complainant paid `2,50,000/-as earnest money. The date for execution of the sale deed was fixed as 30.7.1998. Balbir Singh (petitioner) executed the agreement to sell in favour of the complainant on 19.9.1997. The complainant remained present in the Court complex for the whole day on 30.7.1998 for execution of the sale deed but the petitioner did not turn up. On request of the complainant and with the intervention of respectables, the petitioner extended the time for execution of the sale deed till 15.9.2001. The complainant from reliable sources, however, got to know that the brother of petitioner-Balbir Singh namely Daljit Singh had sold Khasra No.27/4 and 31/10 out of the above-mentioned land to some other persons. In this way petitioner Balbir Singh and his brother Daljit Singh both had cheated the complainant. It was requested that action be taken.
4. The challan in the case has been filed by the police on 26.2.2003 against Balbir Singh (petitioner) only. However, his brother Daljit Singh was not sent up for trial. The petitioner was declared a proclaimed offender in the case on 29.12.2002. Now the matter has been amicably settled between the parties in terms of the compromise dated 12.8.2010 (Annexure P1). It is recorded in the compromise that with the intervention of respectables and relations, the subject matter of the FIR has been compromised and both the parties have compromised all their disputes. As per the compromise, the petitioner has paid `2,50,000/-to the complainant, which have been received by him. The complainant has agreed that he would not pursue the FIR against the petitioner. The complainant has also agreed to withdraw the civil suit filed by him against the petitioner in the civil Courts at Zira, District Ferozepur. Both the parties have agreed that they would not initiate any action of civil or criminal nature against each other and they will withdraw all the cases pending against each other. The complainant-Rattan Singh (respondent No.2) has also deposed an affidavit dated 12.8.2010 which is taken on record wherein the terms of the compromise (Annexure P1) have been accepted and it has been agreed that the dispute stands settled. Besides, he has no objection if the FIR is quashed.
5. After giving my thoughtful consideration to the matter, it may be noticed that the offence under Section 420 IPC is compoundable with the permission of the Court. The dispute in the present case in fact is primarily civil in nature inasmuch as it relates to breach of the agreement dated 19.7.1997 entered into between the petitioner and the complainant. In respect of the dispute which relates to mere breach of an agreement to sell, a criminal prosecution is not normally maintainable.
6. In Ram Biraji Devi v. Umesh Kumar, 2006 (3) RCR (Crl.) 308 (SC) the appellants therein had represented to the complainant that they were badly in need of money and wanted to transfer the plot that had been allotted to them to some person interested to purchase the plot. The complainant e