SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2011 Supreme(P&H) 1582

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
Before
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice A.N. Jindal
Crl. Rev No.230 of 2006 (O&M)
Rakesh Kumar
v.
Ravinder Kumar & Anr.
{Decided on 25/08/2011}

Important Points

Dishonour of Cheque--Legally Enforceable debt--Presumption is attached--Not necessary for the complainant to prove that there was some existing liability.

Subject

Cheque Dishonour - Dishonoured Cheque

Act Referred

NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT : S.139, S.138

Headnote

(A) Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, Ss.139 & 138--Dishonour of Cheque--Legally Enforceable debt--Burden of Proof--Presumption is attached to the fact that if the cheque is issued then it will be presumed that it was issued for consideration and in those circumstances it was not necessary for the complainant to prove that there was some existing liability. (Para 17)

       (B) Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, Ss.139 & 138--Dishonour of Cheque--Legally Enforceable debt--Burden of Proof--There was no specific requirement for the complainant to plead specifically in the compliant the details of the amount which he had paid to the petitioner against which the cheque was issued and the onus lay heavily upon the respondent to prove that the cheque was not issued against legally enforceable liability, which the petitioner has failed to establish. (Para 9)

Advocates:
For the Petitioner:Mr. S.K. Bawa, Advocate.,
Mr. Baljinder Singh Sra, Addl. A.G., Punjab.

JUDGMENT

Mr. A.N. Jindal, J.: - Vide judgment dated 12.04.2005 the accused/petitioner (herein referred as the petitioner) was slapped with one year and six months’ of imprisonment and a fine of Rs.5000/- for allowing the cheque worth Rs.65,400/- to be dishonoured. His appeal was also dismissed on 25.01.2006, thus both are now under challenge.

2. The petitioner in order to discharge the legally enforceable liability had issued a cheque for a sum of Rs.65,400/- in favour of the complainant with the assurance that the same would be encashed and honoured. On tendering of the said cheque it was returned with the remarks ‘Funds Insufficient’’. As such the respondent had to issue a notice Ex.C.1 dated 18.05.2004 but to no response; hence the complaint was filed by him against the petitioner on 15.06.2004.

3. After recording preliminary evidence, the petitioner was summoned and he faced trial. During trial the complainant examined three witnesses.

4. When examined under section 313 Cr.PC, the petitioner denied all the incriminating circumstances appearing against him and pleaded his false implication. However, he stated that he was running a lottery/committee scheme and the respondent obtained his signatures on the blank cheque and subsequently, created valuable security in his favour, however, no evidence was led in defence.

5. The petitioner failed to convince regarding his plea before the trial court as well as the appellate court; hence this revision petition.

6. Heard, the petitioner has not disputed his signatures over the cheque Ex.CW 2/4. He has also not disputed if notice was not issued to him. His simple plea is that the respondent committed cheating as he converted a blank cheque which was issued by him as security for his mother who was to make payment of the lottery which is commonly known as ‘Committee in the Mohalla’. Plea set up by the accused appears to be contradictory. On one side, he has stated that the cheque is the result of fraud but on the other hand he states that the cheque was received by him as a security of the Committee/lottery of his mother. As per contra the complainant while appearing as CW 3 has stated that the petitioner had received an amount of Rs.65,400/- on 1.04.2000 from him and after settling the accounts, the petitioner had issued the cheque. No evidence has been led in order to prove the plea as set up by the petitioner in his defence. No person was examined in order to prove that his mother was indulging in the lottery scheme or that he had issued the blank cheque.

7. I also do not find any merit in the contention raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the onus lay upon the complainant to prove that the cheque was issued for legally enforceable liability. As presumption is attached to the fact that if the cheque is issued then it will be presumed that it was issued for consideration and in those circumstances it was not necessary for the complainant to prove that there was some existing liability. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case M/s M.M.T.C. Ltd. & Anr. Vs. M/s Medchl Chemicals an Pharma P.Ltd. & Anr. 2002 (1) Civil Court Cases, 13, has observed as under:-

“ There is, therefore, no requirement that the complainant must specifically allege in the complaint that there was a subsisting liability. The burden of proving that there is no existing debt or liability, was on the respondents. Thus they have to discharge in the trial. At this stage, merely on the basis of averments in the petition filed by them the High Court could not have concluded that there was no existing debt or liability.”

8. Similarly, it was observed in case Chand Rattan Newar Vs. Shyam Rattan Newar 2000 (3) Civil Court Cases 642 as under:-

“3. However, I find no merit in this contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner in AIR 1998 SC 1057, M/s Modi Cements Ltd. Vs. Kuchil Kumar Nandi, it was held by their Lordships of Supreme Court that once a cheque is issued by the drawer presumption under section 139










1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top