2019 Supreme(P&H) 124
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
Jaishree Thakur, J.
Kala Ram Siri Ram – Appellant
Vs.
Punjab State Civil Supply Cooperation Ltd. and Others – Respondents
First Appeal From Order No. 304 of 2003
Decided On : 06-02-2019
Important Points
Subject
Arbitration Law - Contract Dispute
Act Referred
CONTRACT ACT : S.5, S.6, S.7, S.73
Headnote
Arbitration - Contract - Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 - Section 34 - Indian Contract Act, 1872 - Section 5, 6, 7 - [OFFER AND ACCEPTANCE - ARBITRATION - CONTRACT - SECTION 34 OF THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996, INDIAN CONTRACT ACT, 1872]
Fact of the Case:
The appellant offered to purchase rejected wheat, but only a partial acceptance was made by the respondents. The appellant sought refund of earnest money, leading to arbitration proceedings. The Arbitrator dismissed the claim due to non-deposit of security within the stipulated period. The appellant filed an objection under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which was dismissed, leading to the present appeal.
Finding of the Court:
The Court found that there was no concluded contract between the parties as the acceptance was only a partial acceptance of the offer made. The Arbitrator's appointment and the question of forfeiting could not have been dealt with. The Arbitrator's award was set aside, and the appellant was allowed to avail available remedies to recover the earnest money along with interest and damages.
Issues: The main issue was whether the partial acceptance of the offer amounted to a concluded contract between the parties.
Ratio Decidendi: The Court relied on Section 7 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, which provides that for a proposal to be concluded into a contract, the acceptance must be absolute and unqualified. Partial acceptance can be considered a counter offer and does not culminate into a binding contract. The Court also cited precedents to support this interpretation.
Final Decision: The appeal was allowed, the Arbitrator's award was set aside, and the appellant was allowed to pursue remedies to recover the earnest money along with interest and damages.
Kanwaljit Singh, Adv., Payal, Adv., Anil Bansal, Adv.
Jaishree Thakur, J.
The instant appeal has been filed by the appellant M/s Kala Ram Siri Ram against the judgment dated 17.9.2002 passed by the Additional District Judge, Chandigarh, whereby the objection under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (henceforth called 'the Act' for short) filed by the appellant against the award of the Arbitrator dated 4.8.1998 were dismissed.
2. A few facts that need to be noticed for proper adjudication are that the respondents issued a tender notice for sale of rejected wheat crop. The tender notice was for the sale of rejected wheat crop for the year 1993- 1994, 1994-1995, 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 on gross weight basis and tender was to be opened in the Head Office of Punjab State Civil Supply Corporation Limited (hereinafter referred to as 'the PUNSUP') on 13.8.1997. The appellant gave his offer long with a demand draft of Rs.2,02,000/- as earnest money which was a pre-condition of the tender notice. Thereafter, negotiations took place on 14.8.1997 and the offer of rejected wheat lying at Rampuraphul of crop for the year 1994-1995 was accepted by vide letter of acceptance dated 8.10.1997, and the appellant was given time uptill 6.11.1997 to lift the stock and to deposit the full cost of stock. The appellant herein in fact had sent a Fax No. 601309 dated 5.9.1997, which is available on record as Annexure A/7, stating therein that he had not received any intimation for acceptance of his bid and because of heavy rain further deterioration is being caused to the stock lying in the open and, therefore, asked for refund of the earnest money. This was again followed by another letter dated 9.10.1997, which is available on the record as Annexure A/8 on similar grounds asking for refund of the earnest money. As the respondents did not refund the earnest money, the appellant sent a legal notice to the PUNSUP in this regard. The respondents on receipt of the legal notice, came to hold that there is an arbitration Clause 14 in the tender notice and on that basis arbitration proceedings were initiated by the Managing Director who was the competent person under the tender notice. The appellant herein filed his claim petition seeking refund of Rs.2,02,000/- along with 18% interest from the date of earnest money had been deposited till the date of payment along with Rs.50,000/- as damages. The Arbitrator proceeded with the arbitration proceedings. Reply was filed and thereafter the date was fixed before the Arbitrator for framing of issues. On the date issues were to be framed, the matter itself was disposed of rejecting the claim in the absence of the claimant or his counsel. While disposing of the matter, it came to be noted that the claimant/appellant had not deposited the security within the stipulated period as per Clause 10 of the tender document i.e. within 5 days of the acceptance of their offer so the earnest money deposited is liable to be forfeited. Aggrieved against the award, objection under Section 34 of the Act were filed, which came to be dismissed. Hence the present appeal.
3. Mr. Kanwaljit Singh, learned Senior Counsel, along with Ms. Payal, Advocate, appearing on behalf of the appellant herein contends that for a contract to be concluded there has to be an offer and acceptance and in the present case there is no acceptance by the appellant herein. In fact, the appellant by letter dated 14.8.1997 had applied for lifting rejected wheat for the year 1993-1994, 1994-1995, 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 which was available in various districts of Punjab State. In the offer dated 14.8.1997, it was clearly stated that the offer was being made for the following quantity of wheat:-
District
Centre
Complex
Quantity of bags
Rate P.O (figures & words)
Bathinda
Rampura Phool
Harbans Singh, Ajmer Singh, Platform No.1
20129
Rs. 271-65 (Rs. Two Hundred S