Back
1999 Supreme(All) 21
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
M. Katju and S. L. Saraf, JJ.
BINOD CHANDRA VARMA - Appellant
Versus
STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH - Respondents
C. M. W. P. 1088 Of 1999
Decided On : 01/11/1999
PRAVIN KUMAR SRIVASTAV
Municipal corporations have a duty to provide basic amenities such as cleanliness and infrastructure maintenance to citizens, and non-performing employees can be subjected to disciplinary action.
Headnote:
Public Interest Litigation - Municipal Corporation - Cleanliness and Maintenance of Infrastructure
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner filed a Public Interest Litigation seeking the direction for the municipal corporation to clean and repair the infrastructure in a specific area, citing filth, garbage, and health hazards in various localities of the city.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the municipal corporation was not effectively carrying out its duties, leading to filth and health hazards in the city. It directed the authorities to take disciplinary action against non-performing employees and to ensure cleanliness and infrastructure maintenance in the specified area and other parts of the city.
Issues: Inadequate performance of municipal corporation employees, lack of cleanliness and infrastructure maintenance, public health hazards
Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized the duty of the municipal corporation to provide basic amenities such as cleanliness and infrastructure maintenance to the citizens, highlighting the citizens' payment of taxes without corresponding benefits.
Final Decision: The court directed the municipal corporation to take disciplinary action against non-performing employees, ensure cleanliness and infrastructure maintenance in specified areas, and submit a compliance report to the court.
( 1 ) SRI S. D. Kautilya has appeared for the Nagar Nigam. Allahabad and may file counter-affidavit within three weeks. List this petition in the week commencing 8th February, 1999.
( 2 ) THIS petition has been filed as a Public interest litigation praying that the Nagar Nigam, allahabad be directed to keep the area of Mohalla Krishna Nagar (Kydganj), Allahabad clean and repair the sewer lines, etc. and stop the keeping and tying of animals on the street. It is indeed true that in several localities of Allahabad, there is filth and garbage which has piled up causing inconvenience to the passer-by and lot of diseases and health hazards. It is common knowledge that nowhere cleaning of the roads, garbage and sewer is done in Allahabad by the nagar Nigam, although there are about 1,800 permanent employees and 800 casual labourers working in the Nagar Nigam for this purpose, but they do not work and if they are told to work, they threaten to go on strike. For payment of salaries of these employees. Municipal taxes are imposed on the citizens, e. g. , house" tax and water tax. The citizens of Allahabad are paying these taxes without getting any corresponding benefits, e. g. , keeping the city of Allahabad clean and other basic amenities.
( 3 ) WE, therefore, direct the Nagar Nigam authorities to take strong disciplinary action against those Safai Karmacharies and other employees who are not working properly. We further direct that not only the mohalla Kydganj but also other parts of Allahabad city should be cleaned and sewer lines, water pipes, etc. repaired, otherwise action must be taken against the employees concerned promptly and compliance report be submitted to this Court by the next date.
.
