( 1 ) THIS is a plaintiffs second appeal arising out of a suit for restraining the defendant by means of a permanent injunction from alienating the properties detailed at the foot of the plaint.

( 2 ) ACCORDING to the plaintiffs case one Narottam Gir had half share in plots Nos. 24l measuring 3 bighas 5 Biswas and 599 measuring 5 Biswas situate in Sikandrabad, district Bulandshahr. The aforesaid Narottam Gir had four sons, namely, Dharampal Gir, Parmeshwari Dayal Gir, the two plaintiffs, Madan Gir, the deceased husband of defendant-respondent, Smt. Angoori Devi, and pooran Gir. Madan Gir husband of defendant-respondent Smt. Angoori Devi, pre-deceased his father Narottam Gir and after his death Smt. Angoori Devi, defendant-respondent, went away to her parents place. Defendant-respondent, Smt. Angoori Devi however, came again to the plaintiffs house after the death of Narottam Gir, The name of the defendant-respondent was got mutated in village record for her consolation even though she had no share in the property and the defendant-respondent in turn agreed that she would not transfer the property in her lifetime for which she executed a deed on 26-12-1968. The plai