SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2005 Supreme(All) 2538

[2006(2) ADJ 275 (All)(DB)]
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
(Division Bench)
BEFORE : M.C. JAIN AND VINOD PRASAD, JJ.
SHEO PRASAD ....Appellant (In Jail)
Versus
STATE .......Respondent
(Criminal Appeal No. 475 of 1982,
decided on 23rd December, 2005)

Advocates:
Counsel :
V.K. Jaiswal and Brijesh Sahai for the Appellant; Amar Jeet Singh, A.G.A. for the Respondent.

Headnote:(A) (Indian) Penal Code, 1860—Section 302—Murder—Conviction and sentenced to imprisonment for life—Legality of—Appreciation of evidence—Delayed F.I.R.—Contention of—Place of incident 30 miles from the police station—No transport available on the way was mountainous forest—Distance covered on fort and with river in the way—No delay in lodging FIR—FIR scribed at the spot—Proved by the evidence of watchman—No embellishment or manipulation done—Spontaneity of FIR has corroborative value—Incident took place in the month of September, at about sunset at the spur of the moment and lasted in shortwhile—Presence of other independent witnesses could not be expected—Arrest and recovery of weapon at the instance of accused—Supported by witnesses—No room for doubt—Accused was 17 years of age—Lost his wife after few days of the taunt and curse given by the deceased and her husband—Assaulted the deceased overwhelmed by such sentimentality—Intention to punish severely—Not to commit murder—Provisions of Section 304 Part I, I.P.C. attracted—Imposition of 10 years' R.I. would meet the ends of justice—Appeal partly allowed. [Paras 18 to 23]

       (B) Criminal trial—Independent witnesses—Expectation of. [Para 20]

       (C) Criminal trial—F.I.R.—Lodged after travelling a distance of 30 miles on foot with river in the way—No delay in lodging. [Para 18]

       

JUDGMENT

Hon’ble Vinod Prasad, J.—Sheo Prasad appellant was prosecuted under Section 302 IPC before Sessions Judge, Mirzapur for committing the murder of Smt. Sukhni and was convicted and sentenced to imprisonment for life, vide judgment and order dated 19.12.1981 passed in S.T. No. 2 of 1981 State v. Sheo Prasad. Challenge has been made to the aforesaid conviction and sentence through the instant appeal.

2. The prosecution case as gleaned from the FIR was that on 30.9.1980 in the after noon Smt. Sukhni (deceased) who was the aunt (Barki Mai) of the informant Jamuna P.W. 1 had gone to Bichhi river for bathing accompanied by Smt. Sita Pati (P.W. 3), wife of the informant Jamuna Prasad as it was Jeutia festival. While they were returning to their house after bathing, at about sunset near Sidho tree the appellant, who bore enmity because of ghoulish suspicion encircled Sukhni (deceased) who yelled out for help. Informant Jamna Prasad, Chatur and servant Daya Shankar rushed who were in cattle shed and witnessed that Smt. Sukhni was being assaulted by the accused appellant with Balua while Smt. Sita Pati was shrieking. Informant and other witnesses challenged the accused, who took to his heels towards jungle and could not be apprehended. The deceased died on the spot because of the murderous assault. Later on, certain villagers gathered there. The informant Jamna Prasad scribed the FIR, accompanied by watchman Rama Pati P.W. 4 went to the Police Station, 30 miles north and lodged the FIR Ex. Ka-1 on the following day 1.10.1980, at 9.30 A.M. at Police Station Pipri, district Mirzapur.

3. Ram Awadh Singh P.W..5, prepared the chik FIR Ex. Ka 2 and GD entry Ex. Ka 3. Investigation was started by S.I. Mahendra Narain Misra P.W. 9, In-charge Renukoot Police Outpost who after copying FIR and GD accompanied by six constables proceeded for spot taking S.I. Dal Singar Yadav and constable Tej Narain as well. At 3 P.M. at Beena Ghat he met the informant and watchman waiting for the boat. He recorded their statements and proceeded further and at 5 P.M. reaching Rohwa Ghat at 11 P.M. and night halted there. Next morning at 4 A.M. he started for the place of incident and reached there at 8 A.M., where he found the dead body of the deceased in the keeping of the villagers. He conducted the inquest Ex. Ka 9 prepared other relevant papers Ex. Ka 10 to Ka 12 and after sealing the dead body dispatched it for post mortem through constables Ram Nayan and Sheo Murat Singh P.W. 8. He also recovered one dhoti and petticoat stained with blood and prepared its recovery memo Ex. Ka 13. He conducted the spot inspection, prepared site plan Ex. Ka 14, made recovery of the blood-stained cloth vide fard Ex. Ka-15 and then affected the arrest of the accused from his house wearing lungi and underwear. As the underwear was stained with blood spots, the same was also taken in custody vide fard Ex. Ka 16. At the instance of the accused he also recovered the weapon of assault (Balua) stained with blood and prepared its recovery memo Ex. Ka 6. The site plan of the place of recovery is Ex. Ka 17. Concluding the investigation, he filed charge sheet Ex. Ka 18.

4. Autopsy on the body of the deceased was conducted by Dr. Mahendra Kumar Singh P.W. 7 on 3.10.1980 at 10.30 A.M. The deceased was aged about 40 years and had died 2-1/2 days prior. He found the following ante mortem injuries on her body :

1. Incised wound 4 cm. x 1 cm. x bone depth on the nose cutting the nasal bone and nose.

2. Incised wound 4 cm. x 1 cm. x 1 cm. depth on the mouth cutting upper jaw and upper lip.

3. Incised wound 14 cm. x 1 cm. x 1 cm. depth on the neck front and left side cutting the hyoid bone and vessels.

4. Incised wound 10 cm. x 2 cm. x 1 cm. depth in front of left, shoulder joint.

5. Incised wound 8 cm. x 2 cm. x 1 cm. depth in front of right shoulder joint.

5. On internal examination, he found lungs to be congested, I and II molar teeth were missing. In his opinion, the cause of death was shock


























Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top