2007 Supreme(All) 2699
[2007(10) ADJ 68]
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
BEFORE : SHISHIR KUMAR, J.
VIJAY SOREN .............Petitioner
Versus
STATE OF U.P. AND OTHERS .....Respondents
(Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 11336 of 2006, decided on 2nd November, 2007)
Headnote:Admission—M.B.B.S. Course—Petition praying quashing of order of Principal B.R.D. Medical College, Gorakhpur, cancelling petitioner’s admission to that Course—Allegation of petitioner that he was a son of a person, who originally belonged to Santhal Tribe, which was recognised as a Scheduled Tribe under Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950 and Constitution (Scheduled Tribe) Order, 1959 (as amended by Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Amendment) Order, 1976—Petitioner alleges that his father was a Central Government employee and entered in service as Medical Officer in year, 1981 as a reserved category candidate on instant of his being a member of Scheduled Tribe—Father of petitioner, as alleged by him, was given benefit of reservation and presently posted as C.M.O., Central Government Health Scheme at Lucknow—Held, as petitioner’s father was C.M.O. and Central Government employee, therefore, it was legally presumed that petitioner was also entitled to benefit of category of Scheduled Tribe—And after verification of petitioner's certificate, it was found that said certificate of Scheduled Tribe was being issued on basis of earlier certificate, dated 23.7.2007, and that said certificate of 1997 has been verified by concerned authority—And as certificate submitted by petitioner was not forged, or fictitious document, impugned order passed by Principal was liable to be quashed—Hence, Court directed respondents to permit petitioner to continue his studies and also to permit him to appear in Semester as well as in written examination and permit him to complete his M.B.B.S. Course—Also Court directed to declare his result of examination. [Paras 1, 2, 4, 12, 15, 16 and 17]
Hon’ble Shishir Kumar, J.—By means of the present writ petition the petitioner has approached this Court for quashing the order dated 7.2.2006 passed by the Principal B.R.D. Medical College, Gorakhpur cancelling the petitioners admission to the MBBS Course (Annexure 11 to the writ petition). Further a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to allow the petitioner to pursue his studies in the MBBS Programme at B.R.D. Medical College, Gorakhpur.
2. The facts arising out of the present writ petition are that the petitioner is a son of one Sri Smanta Rai Soren who originally belongs from village Deo Kundi, District Mayurbhanj, Orissa. Petitioner belong to Santhal tribe which is recognised as a scheduled tribe under the Constitution (Scheduled Caste) Order, 1950, the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1959 as amended by Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Amendment) Order, 1976. Petitioners father is a Central Government employee and was entered in service as medical officer in the year1981 as a reserved category candidate on the instant of his being a member of scheduled tribe. The father of the petitioner was given benefit of reservation and presently posted as Chief Medical Officer Central Government Health Scheme at Lucknow.
3. The petitioner appeared in combined Pre Medical Test in 2002 as a Scheduled Tribe candidate claiming benefit of reservation. The result was declared in October, 2002 and the name of the petitioner appeared in the list of successful candidates. The Counselling taken place at King George Medical College Lucknow on 25th October, 2002. At the time of Counselling the petitioner submitted a scheduled tribe certificate dated 23.7.1997 issued by Tehsildar Bahalda District Mayurbhanj Orissa and another certificate dated 12.6.2001 issued by the Additional City Magistrate (IIIrd) Lucknow. It has been mentioned in the said certificate that the aforesaid certificate is being issued on the basis of certificate dated 23.7.1997. An objection was taken by the authorities at the time of Counselling that the certificate dated 12.6.2001 not being as per prescribed proforma, as such, the petitioner was required to submit a fresh certificate in the prescribed format. Under these circumstances, the father of the petitioner approached the authority and petitioner furnishes a fresh certificate dated 25.10.2002 in a prescribed format issued under a sealed and signature of Prabhandh Adhikari on behalf of the District Magistrate, Lucknow. The petitioner was allocated B.R.D. Medical College, Gorakhpur and was admitted to the MBBS Course on 31.10.2002. The petitioner was pursuing his studies and was presently studying in Fourth year in MBBS examination (i.e. the penultimate year of the course).
4. The petitioner was served with a show cause notice dated 19.11.2005, with an allegation that the certificate of scheduled tribe submitted by the petitioner had been sent to the District Magistrate, Lucknow for verification whereupon the District Magistrate had replied stating therein that the said certificate had not been issued by the office and as such, the same was not being confirmed. The show cause notice further states that as on the alleged refusal on the part of the office of the District Magistrate, Lucknow regarding confirming the petitioners certificate, the petitioner was directed to show cause by 7.12.2005 that as to why the admission be not cancelled. The petitioner was not furnished with a copy of the alleged letter of the District Magistrate, Lucknow dated 10.6.2005 nor the letter of the Director General dated 9.10.2002. There was no whisper in the said show cause notice that which certificate furnished by the petitioner had been sent to the District Magistrate office for verification. As the show cause notice was served upon the petitioner on 1.12.2005 therefore, a request was made by the petitioner to the Principal of the College vide request letter dated 3.12.2005 for granting one month ti