1973 Supreme(All) 85
Allahbad High Court
T.S.MISRA
Abdul Majid - Appellant
Versus
Harbansh Chaube - Respondent
Decided On : 03/29/1973
Important Points
Subject
Tort Law - Malicious Prosecution
Act Referred
Headnote
MALICIOUS PROSECUTION - SECTION 412, INDIAN PENAL CODE - SECTION 80, CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE - SECTION 42, POLICE ACT - LIMITATION ACT - SUIT FOR DAMAGES - ELEMENTS OF MALICIOUS PROSECUTION - WANT OF REASONABLE AND PROBABLE CAUSE - MALICE - ACQUITTAL - EVIDENCE - ADMISSIBILITY - LIMITATION.
Fact of the Case:
Plaintiff was prosecuted for being in possession of stolen property under Section 412, Indian Penal Code. He was acquitted. He then filed a suit for damages for malicious prosecution against the police officer who had prosecuted him and the search witnesses.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the police officer had acted without reasonable and probable cause and with malice in prosecuting the plaintiff. It also found that the search witnesses had conspired with the police officer to falsely implicate the plaintiff.
Issues: 1. Whether the police officer had acted without reasonable and probable cause and with malice in prosecuting the plaintiff? 2. Whether the search witnesses had conspired with the police officer to falsely implicate the plaintiff? 3. Whether the suit was barred by limitation?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. In order to succeed in an action for malicious prosecution, the plaintiff has to prove (1) that there was want of reasonable and probable cause for the prosecution, (2) that the proceedings were initiated in a malicious spirit and (3) that the plaintiff was acquitted. 2. Malice is said to mean any wrong or indirect motive. If the proceedings were initiated from an indirect or wrong motive and not in furtherance of justice it would be said that the defendant was malicious; there need not necessarily be a feeling 01 enmity, spite or ill-will. 3. Want of reasonable cause owing to the defendant's want of belief in the truth of his charge would be evidence of malice. 4. Article 23 of the Limitation Act 1908 applies to suits for compensation for malicious prosecution.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the appeals of the police officer and the search witnesses. The plaintiff was awarded damages.
Mohammad, for Appellant; Sripat Narain Singh, for Respondents.
JUDGMENT :- This is an appeal by the defendant. It arises in the following circumstances.
2. A dacoity took place at the house of Ali Raza in village Bankata, P.S. Raunapar in the night of July 21/22, 1949. The plaintiff was prosecuted in that case under Section 412, Indian Penal Code for being found in possession of a 'hansuli' alleged to be belonging to Ali Raza on the charge-sheet submitted by the defendant No. 1 against him. The defendant No. 1 submitted a search memo in the capacity of Station Officer, P.S. Raunapar. The defendants Nos. 2 and 3 were search witnesses. The plaintiff was ultimately acquitted by the Court of Session on 9th October, 1950 Thereafter the plaintiff gave a notice to the defendant No. 1 under Section 80 Civil Procedure Code, which was, however, returned refused by the defendant No. 1. The plaintiff thereupon filed a suit for damages on the ground of malicious prosecution claiming a sum of Rs. 1000.00 from the defendants Nos. 1, 2 and 3. It was alleged by the plaintiff that one Amir Singh and the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 were his enemies and were plotting and conspiring to cause harm to him by various ways. With that end in view and taking unlawful advantage of the dacoity which took place at the house of Ali Raza, the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 conspired together to falsely implicate him as an accused under Section 412, Indian Penal Code in the said dacoity case. The defendant No. 1 also joined hands with the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 to secure that object. The plaintiff alleged that he neither participated in the said dacoity nor received any stolen property but he was maliciously and without any reasonable and probable cause, prosecuted by the defendants. He alleged that the defendant No. 1 who was then the Station. Officer P.S. Raunapar, kept him illegally detained in lock up for a day and then challaned him as an accused in the aforesaid dacoity case. As none could identify the plaintiff in the identification parade, the defendants and Amir Singh cooked up another case to keep the plaintiff entangled in the dacoity case by falsely implicating him in the case under Section 412, Indian Penal Code. The plaintiff further alleged that the defendant No. 1 prepared a false and totally wrong sketch map of the plaintiff's house. He never made any search of the house of the plaintiff and the alleged "hansuli" was not recovered from his house. The suit was contested by the defendants.
The defendant No. 1 contended that he started a case under Section 412, Indian Penal Code against the plaintiff in a bona fide manner and pleaded that the plaintiff was prosecuted on the strength of the investigation made by him. He further alleged that he had made a search of the house of the plaintiff in connection with the dacoity which had taken place at the house of Ali Raza and had recovered a 'hansuli". The allegations of the plaintiff to the contrary were denied by him. The defendant No. 1 denied the receipt of the notice under Section 80, Civil Procedure Code and pleaded bar of section 42 of Police Act and Limitation Act. The defendants Nos. 2 and 3 supported the case of the defendant No. 1 and alleged that a search of the plaintiffs home did take place in their presence and they were not liable for any damages. The trial Court repelled all the contentions raised by the defendants and held that the plaintiff was 'maliciously prosecuted by the defendants without any reasonable and probable cause. It accordingly decreed the suit for damages to the tune of Rs. 1000.00. The defendants preferred an appeal from the said decree. The Appellate Court below on a consideration of the evidence on the record and surrounding circumstances affirmed the findings recorded by the trial Court and dismissed the appeal. Aggrieved, the defendant No. 1 preferred the second appeal No. 293 of 1965 whereas the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 filed a Second Appeal No. 3633 of 1964. Both the appeals were ordered to be connected and to be heard togeth