HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
S.K. KAUL, M.M. HUSAIN, JJ.
Guru Prasad - Appellant
Versus
State - Respondent
Cr. A. No. 845 of 1978
Decided on : Feb 07, 1978
MURDER - EXCEPTION 1 TO SECTION 300 IPC - GRAVE AND SUDDEN PROVOCATION - ADULTERY BY WIFE - HUSBAND'S MENTAL AGONY - CONVICTION UNDER SECTION 304 PART I IPC.
Fact of the Case:
The accused, Gur Prasad, was convicted of murdering his wife, Smt. Jasoda, under Section 302 IPC. The prosecution's case was that the accused had given sickle blows upon his wife, causing her death. The accused admitted to killing his wife but claimed that he had done so in the heat of the moment after she had run away several times and engaged in immoral conduct.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the accused was guilty of murder but that the circumstances of the case warranted a conviction under Section 304 Part I IPC, which provides for culpable homicide not amounting to murder. The court held that the accused had been provoked by his wife's adultery and that he had lost his self-control in the heat of the moment.
Issues: Whether the accused was guilty of murder under Section 302 IPC or culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part I IPC.
Ratio Decidendi: The court applied the tests laid down by the Supreme Court for the purpose of Exception 1 to Section 300 IPC, which provides for the defense of grave and sudden provocation. The court found that the accused had been provoked by his wife's adultery and that he had lost his self-control in the heat of the moment. The court also considered the cultural and social background of the accused, who belonged to a community where adultery by a wife is considered to be a serious offense.
Final Decision: The court convicted the accused of culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part I IPC and sentenced him to five years' rigorous imprisonment.
S. K. Kaul, J.
1. THIS unfortunate occurrence is connected with the accused- appellant who committed murder of his own wife Smt. Jasoda. Admittedly, Gur Prasad, son of Jangli, used to live in village Mawai Brahman along with his wife. Villagers used to patrol every night in village in between the night of 12th and 13th of December, 1972, Naththa, Matra, Babu Ram Pandit, Faruq, Kifayat and others were on patrol duty. They finished patrol duty at about 4 a. m. at the house of Sheo Nandan Pradhan. Most of them were armed with Torches When some of them went towards the east of the house of Sheo Nan- dan Pradhan towards their houses and when they reached near the door of Sheodin, whose house is situate to the east of the house of Gur Prasad, they heard some noise coming from the house of Gur Prasad. Hearing this noise, these four persons stood on the Chabutra of Sheodin and when they flashed the torches, they found Gur Prasad giving sickle blows upon his own wife. These persons rushed towards the house of Gur Prasad and on their persistent knocking, Jangli, father of Gur Prasad, opened the door. The witnesses went inside the house and found the accused having come out of the Kothri after having murdered his wife. He had a sickle in his hand. Sambhar Chaukidar took possession over the sickle. Witnesses found Smt. Jasoda lying dead inside the Kothri. The Kurta and the Langot of the accused were soaked in blood. Sambhar, accompanied by Matru, Babu Ram and Naththa as well as taking with him accused and sickle, went to Beni Ganj where Sambhar dictated FIR on 13th of December, 1972, at about 9 a. m. The distance between the village in question and the police station Beni Ganj is 8 miles. We may note specifically that apart from other details that were mentioned in the FIR, on enquiry from the accused as to why he had committed the murder of his own wife, Gur Prasad replied that she had become immoral. She was not listening to his advice. He had, therefore, finished the matter once for all. Mohammad Razi, ASI, took up investigation. He interrogated Sambhar at the police station, He also interrogated the accused. He then went to the scene of occurrence and found the dead body of Smt. Jasoda lying inside the Kothri. He prepared the inquest report relating to this dead body and sent it for autopsy. Autopsy upon the body of Smt. Jasoda was performed by Dr. C. L. Chaudhary, Medical Officer Incharge, Sandila, Hardoi, on 14th of December, 1972 at 3.30 p. m. The following ante-mortem injuries were found upon the dead body :-
2. THE internal examination revealed that carotid artery and vein on the left side were cut below injury No. 1 along with other vessels. He also found that this woman was carrying 4 to 5 months child. Cut injuries, according to Dr. Chaudhary, were caused by sharp-edged weapon like sickle. Death, according to Dr. Chaudhary, of Smt. Jasoda, was caused due to injury of the neck which, in his view, was sufficient in the ordinary course to cause death.
The Sub-Inspector took possession over blood-stained and nearby plain earth. He also took possession over blood-stained Kathri vide Ext. Ka- 9. He interrogated witnesses and prepared a site-plan with their help. After completing investigation, a charge-sheet was submitted against the accused and on that basis, he was asked to stand his trial under Section 392 IPC.
3. THE accused in his statement recorded before the Sessions Judge, admitted that Smt. Jasoda was his wife and she used to reside with him. He stated that he had given Hansiya blows upon his wife. Ultimately, his contention was that Smt. Jasoda had run away several times. He was extremely perturbed on that account. On account of bad character of his wife, he too had to face danger and was also beaten. He had kept patience, but his wife had again run away. She was absent throughout the night. In the early hours of the morning when she returned, he gave Hansiya blows upon her.
4. THE learned Sessions Judge, on an appr
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.