2013 Supreme(All) 950
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Rameshsinha, J.
Abhishek Agarwal and others -Appellant
Versus
State of U.P. and another -Respondent
Cr. Misc. Application No. 955 of 2012
Decided On : 01-04-2013
Act Referred
DOWRY PROHIBITION ACT : S.4, S.3
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.498(a)
Headnote
Section 482 Cr.P.C. - Quashing of Criminal Proceedings - Section 498-A I.P.C. and 3/4 D.P. Act - [Section 498-A I.P.C., Section 3/4 D.P. Act] - The court refused to quash the complaint and summoning order against the husband but directed that his bail application shall be considered. The court quashed the proceedings against the family members of the husband based on the principle that vague and bald allegations in matrimonial disputes do not justify taking cognizance against family members without active involvement.
Fact of the Case:
The application was filed to quash the criminal proceedings under Section 498-A I.P.C. and 3/4 D.P. Act, and the summoning order passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate.
Finding of the Court:
The court refused to quash the complaint and summoning order against the husband but directed that his bail application shall be considered. The court quashed the proceedings against the family members of the husband based on the principle that vague and bald allegations in matrimonial disputes do not justify taking cognizance against family members without active involvement.
Issues: Quashing of criminal proceedings under Section 498-A I.P.C. and 3/4 D.P. Act, and summoning order.
Ratio Decidendi: Vague and bald allegations in matrimonial disputes do not justify taking cognizance against family members without active involvement.
Final Decision: The application stands partly allowed, refusing to quash the complaint and summoning order against the husband, but quashing the proceedings against the family members of the husband.
For the Petitioner: Vinay Kumar Singh, Dharm Prakash Mishra, Nishant Mehrotra and Sanjay K. Singh.
For the Respondent:Govt. Advocate, Uma Nath Pandey.
Sri Uma Nath Pandey, learned counsel for opp. party No.2 has filed a supplementary affidavit today, which is taken on record.
2. Heard Sri Sanjay Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the applicants, Sri Uma Nath Pandey, learned counsel for the opposite party no.2 and learned A.G.A. for the State.
3. This application under Section 482 Cr.P.C. has been filed for quashing the entire criminal proceedings of Complaint Case No.1905 of 2011 (Kamal Kumar Garg Vs. Abhishek Agarwal and others), under Section 498-A I.P.C. and 3/4 D.P. Act, police station Kotwali Nagar, District Bulandshahr as well as summoning order dated 31.3.2011 passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bulandshahr.
4. Learned counsel for the opposite party no.2 submits that the dispute being matrimonial in nature was referred to Mediation and Conciliation Centre of this Court vide order dated 10.1.2012 but the mediation process has failed as is evident from the report of Mediation Centre of this Court dated 6.5.2012 and there is no chance for mediation.
5. Learned counsel for the applicants submits that the marriage between the applicant no.1 and daughter of opposite party no.2 was solemnized in the year 2009.
6. After having very carefully examined, the submissions made by the learned counsel for the applicants and perused the material brought on record, I find that so far as applicant no.1 namely Abhishek Agarwal (husband) is concerned, there is no justification for quashing the complaint as well as summoning order in the aforementioned case.
7. The prayer to that extent on behalf of applicant no.1 is hereby refused.
8. However, it is directed that if the applicant no.1 namely Abhishek Agarwal (husband) appears and surrenders before the court below within 30 days from today and applies for bail, his prayer for bail shall be considered and decided in view of the settled law laid by this Court in the case of Amrawati and another Vs. State of U.P. reported in 2004 (57) ALR 290 as well as judgement passed by Hon'ble Apex Court reported in 2009 (3) ADJ 322 (SC) Lal Kamlendra Pratap Singh Vs. State of U.P.
9. It is made clear that the applicant no.1 will not be granted any further time by this Court for surrendering before the Court below as directed above.
10. So far as applicant nos.2 to 4, namely, Anupam Agarwal, Anurag Agarwal and Smt. Sharda Devi are concerned, it has been contended by learned counsel for the applicants that they are family members of applicant no.1 and the allegation levelled against them are wholly vague and no specific allegation has been levelled against them. Learned counsel for the applicant has placed reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Geeta Mehrotra vs. State of U.P. and others reported in 2012 (10) ADJ 464 and has drawn the attention of the Court towards paragraphs 17, 19, 20, 21 and 24 of the following judgments. The said paragraphs are quoted hereinbelow:-
"17. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court in this matter had been pleased to hold that the bald allegations made against the sister in law by the complainant appeared to suggest the anxiety of the informant to rope in as many of the husband's relatives as possible. It was held that neither the FIR nor the charge sheet furnished the legal basis for the Magistrate to take cognizance of the offences alleged against the appellants. The learned Judges were pleased to hold that looking to the allegations in the FIR and the contents of the charge sheet, none of the alleged offences under Section 498 A, 406 and Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act were made against the married sister of the complainant's husband who was undisputedly not living with the family of the complainant's husband. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court were pleased to hold that the High Court ought not to have relegated the sister in law to the ordeal of trial. Accordingly, the proceedings against the appellants were quashed and the appeal was allowed.
19. Coming to the facts of this case, when the