2016 Supreme(All) 105
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
BEFORE : ARVIND KUMAR TRIPATHI AND ARVIND KUMAR MISHRA-I, JJ.
SHIV NATH SINGH AND ANOTHER ....Appellants
Versus
STATE OF U.P. ....Respondent
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 4061, 3898 and 4403 of 2006, decided on 22nd January, 2016)
Counsel :
Sheo Ram Singh, Ambrish Kumar, D.R. Azad, Dileep Kumar, Dilip Gupta, Himanshu, Lav Srivastava, M.K.Tiwari, Manish Tiwary, Rajeev Gupta, Rajeev Misra, Swadesh Kumar, Ram Raj Pandey, C.P. Pandey and V.P. Srivastava for the Appellants; A.G.A., B.P. Mishra, Kamal Krishna and V.P. Mishra for the Respondent.
Headnote:(Indian) Penal Code, 1860—Sections 147, 148, 302/149, 307/149—Murder—Conviction—Incident of assault being caused by appellants on complainant side is reasonably proved and it is also proved under circumstances that all appellants conjointly had common object of killing complainant side and in prosecution of their common object they not only caused injuries on complainant side but also caused death of three persons—Conviction upheld. [Paras 16, 21 to 25 and 26]
Result; Appeals Dismissed.
Hon’ble Arvind Kumar Mishra-I, J.—We have heard respective submissions of both the sides and perused the record.
2. The aforesaid criminal appeals have been filed by the appellants Shiv Nath Singh, Shamsher Singh, both sons of Baboo Singh, Amar Singh son of Siya Ram and Birendra Singh son of Rajjan Singh @ Dashrath Singh against the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 6.7.2006 passed by Additional Sessions Judge/Special Judge (E.C. Act), Farrukhabad in Sessions Trial No. 50 of 1986, State v. Shiv Nath Singh and others (arising out of Case Crime No. 320 of 1985) under Sections 147, 148, 302/149, 307/149 IPC, P.S. Mohammadabad, District Farrukhabad whereby the learned trial Judge has sentenced the appellants Shiv Nath Singh, Shamsher Singh and Amar Singh under Section 148 IPC with 1 1/2 years rigorous imprisonment with fine of Rs. 2,000/-, in default will have to suffer additional three months’ imprisonment, under Section 307 IPC read with Section 149 IPC each of the appellants will have to undergo 10 years rigorous imprisonment with fine of Rs. 5,000/-, in default, the concerned defaulting convict will have to suffer additional imprisonment for one year, under Section 302 IPC read with Section 149 IPC each of the appellants will have to undergo imprisonment for life with fine of Rs. 20,000/-, in default, the concerned defaulting convict will have to suffer additional imprisonment for two years, under Section 147 IPC appellant Birendra Singh will suffer one year rigorous imprisonment with fine of Rs. 1,000/-, in default, he will have to suffer additional imprisonment for three months, under Section 307 IPC read with Section 149 IPC appellant Birendra Singh has been sentenced with 10 years rigorous imprisonment with fine of Rs. 5,000/-, in default, he will have to undergo additional imprisonment for one year. He has been further sentenced under Section 302/149 IPC with life imprisonment and fine of Rs. 20,000/-, in case of default, he will have to suffer two years additional imprisonment. All the sentences of the aforesaid appellants have been directed to run concurrently.
3. Brief matrix of facts as emanates from perusal of record reflects that a First Information Report was lodged against the appellants at police station Mohammadabad, District Farrukhabad at Crime No. 320 of 1985, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 302, 307, 323 IPC on 27.12.1985 at 21.10 hours by first informant Ashok Kumar son of Jagdish Singh by alleging the incident to have taken place at about 7.30 p.m. in his village (Tajpur). At that point of time the first informant was coming out of house of Brijpal Singh of the same village after attending “Chhath Party”. As soon as he came out of house, he heard some noise coupled with abuses from the side of road, he rushed to the place of incident near the shop of Siya Ram on Pakka Road where he saw Shiv Nath Singh son of Baboo Singh, Siya Ram son of Hukum Singh possessing gun, Shamsher son of Baboo Singh and Amar Singh son of Siya Ram possessing country made pistol and Birendra Singh son of Rajjan Singh @ Dashrath Singh with Lathi. They had surrounded his father Jagdish and were saying to his father that “you are helping and protecting Harijans (members of scheduled caste community) whereupon informant’s father Jagdish insisted that he will keep on doing the same. In the meanwhile Surendra Singh son of Ram Nath, Veer Pal son of Surjan Singh, Deshraj son of Mullu Singh and Rajendra Singh son of Chhote Singh, Vijay Kumar son of Guljar Singh also arrived on the spot, when Shiv Nath Singh while abusing exhorted ‘Maro Sale ko ki sabhi Aaj.....................” whereupon accused persons started firing and Birendra Singh assaulted with Lathi blow due to which the fire hit informant’s father Jagdish Singh, Surendra Singh and Veer Pal and they died on the spot and Deshraj Singh sustained pellet injuries on his face, injured Vijay Kumar Singh and Rajendra Singh sustained injuries caused by Lathi blow. On