2017 Supreme(All) 317
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
(Lucknow Bench)
BEFORE : SUDHIR AGARWAL AND RAVINDRA NATH MISHRA-II, JJ.
STATE OF U.P. AND OTHERS ....Petitioners
Versus
CHUNNU KHAN ....Respondent
(Civil Misc. Writ Petition (S/B) No. 1977 of 1996, decided on 20th March, 2017)
Subject
Employment Law - Misconduct
Headnote
Result; Petition Dismissed.
Counsel :
C.S.C. and Mohd. Tabrez Iqbal for the Petitioners; G.K. Pandey, A.K. Srivastava, C.S.C., K.P. Singh, Mohd. Tabrez Iqbal, Nalini Jain and Sanjay Kumar for the Respondent.
By the Court.—Heard learned Standing Counsel, appearing on behalf of petitioner and perused the record.
2. This writ petition under Article 226 of Constitution of India has been filed by State of U.P. and its authorities assailing judgment and order dated 21.7.1995 passed by State Public Services Tribunal, Lucknow (hereinafter referred as “Tribunal”) in Claim Petition No. 368/F/III 1987.
3. Tribunal has allowed aforesaid claim petition filed by claimant-respondent and set aside punishment order dated 25.6.1981 and directed for reinstatement with all consequential benefits.
4. Claimant-respondent was Jeep driver and that vehicle was stolen on 23.6.1981. A report was also lodged about theft of aforesaid vehicle at P.S. Kotwali, Chowk, District Lucknow. Thereafter claimant-respondent was placed under suspension and departmental enquiry was conducted after serving a charge-sheet upon claimant-respondent that he was negligent in taking care of vehicle as a result whereof it was stolen. The entire charge contained in charge-sheet dated 26.11.1991 is reproduced as under :
**;g fd tc vki fodkl [k.M efygkckn dh thi la0 ;wvkj,y&8650 ds pkyd in ij dk;Zjr Fks mlh vof/k esa fnukad 24-6-1981 dks vkius eq[; fodkl vf/kdkjh] y[kuÅ ds dk;kZy; esa ,d fyf[kr lwpuk vius }kjk iqfyl esa fy[kk;h x;h fjiksVZ dh izfrfyfi ds lkFk bl vk'k; dh fn'kk fd thi la0 ;w0vkj0,y0&8650 fnukad 23-6-1981 dks jkr yxHkx 09%00 cts dks us'oj efUnj ds ikl pksjh pyh x;hA tc lwpuk vkius ?kVuk ds 12 ?k.Vs ckn eq[; fodkl vf/kdkjh dks nh tc fd vki mudk fuokl LFkku Hkyh&HkkWfr tkurs Fks D;ksafd muds lkFk M;wVh dj pqds FksA
[k.M fodkl vf/kdkjh] efygkckn us vkidks vkns'k ns j[kk Fkk fd xkM+h fnukWd 23-6-1981 dks ftyk ifj"kn y[kuÅ ds ifjlj esa [kM+h djsaxs vkSj fnukWd 24-6-1981 dks lfoZflax djkus ds ckn efygkckn ys tk;saxs ysfdu vkius vkns'kksa dh vogsyuk dj vuko';d :i ls LosPNk ls xkM+h dksus'oj ys x;s vkSj xkM+h pksjh pyh x;h tks vkidks LosPNkpkfjrk rFkk vkns'kksa dh vogsyuk ds dkj.k gqvkA
vki fnukad 23-06-1981 dks fjifCyd lfoZflax LVs'ku gjnksbZ jksM dkus'oj y[kuÅ x;s gh ugha u bl fnu vkius dksbZ Mhty fy;k] vkSj u iEi ij dksbZ dk;Z gh fd;kA Mz~kboj [kksus ds ukrs xkM+h ds j[k&j[kko rFkk lqj{kk dk nkf;Ro vkidk FkkA vkidh LosPNkpkfjrk vuqRrj nkf;Ro rFkk vkns'kksa dh vogsyuk ds dkj.k gh thi la[;k & ;w0vkj0,y0&8650 pksjh x;h] vkSj 'kklu dh bruh cM+h {kfr mBkuh iM+h ftuds fy, vki nks"kh gSA**
“That when you were posted as Driver of Jeep No. URL-8650 of Development Block-Malihabad, in that same period you had given a written information, alongwith a copy of report got lodged to police by you, in the office of Chief Development Officer, Lucknow mentioning that Jeep No. URL-8650 had been theft on 23.6.1981 at about 9.00 o’clock of the night from the place near to Koneshwar Mandir (Temple). You had given information to Chief Development Officer after 12 hours of incident while you were well aware of his residence because you had done duty with him.
The Block Development Officer, Malihabad had given you direction to park the vehicle in the premises of Zila Parishad Lucknow on 23.6.1981 and bring it to Malihabad after getting it serviced on 24.6.1981 but you disobeyed the orders and unnecessarily, arbitrarily took the vehicle to Koneshwar and the vehicle was theft which has happened due to your arbitrariness and disobedience of orders.
On 23.6.1981, even you had not visited Republic Servicing Station, Hardoi Road, Koneshwar, Lucknow nor you had taken diesel on this date nor done any work on the pump. Being the Driver of the vehicle you were liable for maintenance and security of the vehicle. Due to your arbitrariness, dereliction in duty and disobedience of orders, Jeep Number URL-8650 was theft and the Government suffered such huge loss for which you are responsible.” (English translation by Court)
5. There is no allegation that claimant-respondent was indulged himself or is instrumental in getting the vehicle stolen or he colluded with the person who has taken the vehi