2018 Supreme(All) 646
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
BEFORE : SUDHIR AGARWAL AND IFAQAT ALI KHAN, JJ.
DHRUV BHUSHAN DUBEY ....Petitioner
Versus
STATE OF U.P. AND OTHERS ....Respondents
(Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 12708 of 2018, decided on 25th May, 2018)
Subject
Suspension - Police Officer
Act Referred
Headnote
Result; Petition Allowed.
Counsel :
Vijay Gautam, Atipriya Gautam and Devesh Mishra for the Petitioner; C.S.C. for the Respondents.
By the Court.—With the consent of learned counsel for parties, we proceed to decide this writ petition at this stage since parties stated that issue raised is purely legal and on the basis of record of writ petition it can be decided.
2. Heard Sri Vijay Gautam, learned counsel for petitioner and learned Standing Counsel for respondents.
3. The order of suspension dated 13.3.2018 passed by Senior Superintendent of Police, Ghaziabad (hereinafter referred to as “SSP”) in contemplation of departmental inquiry under Rule 17(1)(a) of U.P. Police Officers of Subordinate Ranks (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1991 (hereinafter referred to as “Rules, 1991”) has been challenged by petitioner mainly on two grounds.
4. Firstly, it is contended that the very allegation stated in suspension order does not constitute misconduct whatsoever hence, impugned order of suspension is patently illegal and shows a total non application of mind on the part of Competent Authority. Secondly, it is contended that though in impugned order of suspension it has been said that departmental inquiry is contemplated but simultaneously another order has been issued on 13.3.2018 directing Superintendent of Police (City), Ghaziabad to make a preliminary inquiry in the matter and submit report.
5. The order passed by SSP, Ghaziabad for preliminary inquiry reads as under:
^^d`i;k {ks=kf/kdkjh uxj r`rh; dh layXu vk[;k fnukafdr 13-03-2018 dk voyksdu djsa] tks Fkkuk{ks= [kksMk ds vUrxZr fnukad 12@13-03-2018 dh jkf= djhc 11-30 cts 04 O;fDr;ksa dh 'kjkc ihus ls e`R;q tSlh xEHkhj ?kVuk ?kfVr gks tkus esa ykijokgh cjrus okys iqfyl dfeZ;ksa ds fo:) izkjfEHkd tkap djk;s tkus ds laca/k esa gSA
vr% izdj.k ls lEcfU/kr i= ewy:i ls layXu dj bl funsZ'k ds lkFk Hksts tk jgs gSa] fd izdj.k esa izkjfEHkd tkWap 07 fnol esa iw.kZ dj vk[;k miyC/k djkuk lqfuf'pr djsaA**
“Please have a perusal of the report of Circle Officer (City) - III dated 13.3.2018, which is related to conducting a preliminary inquiry against the police personnel showing negligence leading to a serious incident like the death of 04 persons due to consumption of liquor at 11:30 p.m. on the night of 12/13.3.2018 under the P.S. - Khoda.
Hence, the papers, in original, relating to the occurrence are being sent annexed hereto, with an instruction to ensure to submit a report after completing preliminary inquiry in the matter in seven days. ” (English translation by Court)
6. This has been repeatedly held that an order of suspension can be passed when a departmental inquiry is contemplated or pending and this is the power conferred under Rule 17(1)(a) of Rules, 1991 but for the purpose of holding preliminary inquiry an order of suspension cannot be passed.
7. Under Rules, 1991, suspension is not one of the punishments prescribed therein. On the contrary, Rule 17 contemplates that suspension can be effected in a contemplated or pending departmental inquiry or during a criminal investigation, inquiry or trial or when an officer is in jail for a particular period of time. In the present case, none of these contingencies are available and, therefore, Rule 17 which authorises Competent Authority to place a police officer of subordinate rank under suspension, is not at all attracted.
8. Admittedly, from order dated 13.3.2018, it is evident that Superintendent of Police (City), Ghaziabad has been directed to hold a preliminary inquiry, meaning thereby, a preliminary inquiry has not been held so far which is now ordered and pending thereto, impugned order of suspension has been passed.
9. A Five Judges Bench of this Court in State of U.P. v. Jay Singh Dixit and others, 1975 ALR 64, has held that an order of suspension can be passed in a contemplated or pending departmental inquiry and it does not include contemplated or pending preliminary inquiry. Recently, a Full Bench of this Court in Rajveer Singh v. State of U.P. and others, 2010(10) ADJ 246, has also taken same view with some further clarification.
10. In the p