2018 Supreme(All) 1568
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
SUDHIR AGARWAL, OM PRAKASH-VII, JJ.
Vijay - Appellants
Versus
State of U.P. - Respondents
Jail Appeal No., 518 of 2015
Decided On : 13-08-2018
For the Appellant : Pradeep Kumar Mishra (A.C.)
The main legal point established in the judgment is the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt required for conviction, as well as the reliance on witness testimonies and medical evidence in criminal cases.
Headnote:
Jail Appeal - Conviction under Sections 376(2)(cha) and 304 IPC - [376, 304] - The court upheld the conviction of the accused appellant for the offences under Sections 376(2)(cha) and 304 IPC. The judgment discusses the facts of the case, the findings of the court, issues, ratio decidendi, and the final decision.
Fact of the Case:
The case involved the accused appellant Vijay being convicted for the offences under Sections 376(2)(cha) and 304 IPC for the rape and subsequent death of a 2 ½-year-old girl. The prosecution's case was based on witness testimonies and medical evidence.
Finding of the Court:
The trial court found the prosecution successful in proving the charges against the accused beyond reasonable doubt, leading to the conviction and sentencing of the accused appellant.
Issues: The issues revolved around the credibility of witness testimonies, the reliability of medical evidence, and the timing of the events, including the lodging of the First Information Report (F.I.R.).
Ratio Decidendi: The court analyzed the witness testimonies, medical evidence, and the timing of events to determine the guilt of the accused appellant. It found the prosecution's case to be fully supported by the evidence presented.
Final Decision: The court affirmed the conviction and sentence imposed upon the accused appellant, dismissing the jail appeal.
OM PRAKASH-VII, J.
1. This jail appeal has been preferred by accused appellant Vijay against judgment and order dated 25/26.9.2014 passed by Additional District & Sessions Judge, Court No.3, Bulandshahr in Session Trial Nos. 889 of 2008 and 106 of 2009 at crime no. 74 of 2008 convicting and sentencing appellant for the offence punishable under Sections 376 (2)(cha) and 304 IPC for imprisonment of life and a fine of Rs. 50,000/- for the offence under Section 376(2)(cha) IPC and also for the offence under Section 304 IPC for 10 years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 20,000/-. In default of payment of fine, appellant was also directed to undergo additional imprisonment of two years and one year respectively. All sentences were directed to run concurrently.
2. Facts of case, in nutshell, as unfolded by informant Bablu son of Harvansh Jatav, in First Information Report (in short 'F.I.R.'), are that on 26.4.2008 at about 2-2.30 p.m. appellant was playing with the daughter of informant aged about 2 ½ years' in his lap and when he began to proceed along with victim - deceased, informant's wife asked him as to where he was going with daughter, on this appellant told that he was going to provide her toffee. After sometime hearing weeping of a child from sugarcane field of Kale Ram witness Tejveer Singh and Shahid Siddiqui entered into the field and saw that accused appellant was committing rape with victim. Having seen those people, accused appellant ran away despite effort made by them to catch him. Leaving victim in field, both witnesses came to house of informant and told entire facts. Thereafter, informant along with Khoob Chandra, Tek Chandra and Raj Kumar proceeded to place of occurrence and witnessed that her daughter was lying in sugarcane field of Kale Ram and there were injuries on her private part as also on the body. Informant along with victim went to Police Station concerned for lodging F.I.R.. It was also mentioned that informant had heard that accused appellant due to fear of police had consumed poison to commit suicide and was lying in unconscious condition in the lane of mohalla Jatan.
3. On the basis of written report (Ext. ka-1), chik First Information Report (Ext. Ka-4) was registered at Police Station concerned on 26.4.2008 at 4.25 p.m. against accused appellant for the offence under Sections 376 and 309 IPC mentioning all details as had been described in Ext. Ka-.1. G.D. entry Ext. Ka-5 was also made at the same time. Since distance between place of occurrence and police station concerned was only one kilometer and sugarcane field was adjacent to the town concerned, police had also reached there. Informant on police vehicle took the victim immediately to B.B. Nagar C.H.C., Bulandshahr and after providing first aid, she was referred to District Hospital as is clear from reference slip, majroobi chitthi and statement of PW-5. She was also referred to Medical College, Meerut for better treatment. Police also took bloodstained and plain earth from place of occurrence and keeping same in sealed box prepared fard Ext. ka-8. One underwear of appellant was also taken into possession and was kept in a sealed cloth preparing memo Ext. ka-9. Medico legal examination of victim done at District Hospital, Bulandshahr is Ext. ka-2 wherein height of victim was found 31" (inch), weight 10.5 kilogram. It is also mentioned in the report that child was drowsy and face was soiled with blood. On internal examination blood was oozing from private part. Hymen was found torn. Vaginal tears on both sides also found damaged with muscle deep. On touch blood was oozing. Two smear slides were prepared for examination. She was also referred to Chief Medical Officer for age determination. Majrubi Chithi and reference slip of C.H.C. B.B. Nagar to District Hospital, Bulandshahr is on lower court record. Supplementary report prepared in regard to spermatozoa is Ext. ka-3. Bed head ticket of L.L.R.M. Medical College, where victim was a