SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2017 Supreme(All) 2802

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD AT LUCKNOW BENCH
D.K. Upadhyay, J.
Jokhu - Appellant
Vs.
Deputy Director Consolidation, Pratapgarh & Ors. - Respondents
Consolidation No. 789 of 2015
Decided On : 19-12-2017

Important Points

Mutation orders do not decide right or title and cannot be upset by consolidation courts. A sale deed obtained through fraudulent misrepresentation is void and can be challenged in a civil court.

Subject

Land Dispute - Consolidation Operations

Act Referred

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.226
TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT : S.52
UTTAR PRADESH CONSOLIDATION OF HOLDINGS ACT : S.9(a)(2), S.4, S.48
UTTAR PRADESH LAND REVENUE ACT : S.34, S.35

Headnote

Impersonation - Land Dispute - U.P. Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953, Section 9-A(2) - 34/35 of U.P. Land Revenue Act - The court discussed the validity of the sale deed executed through impersonation, the jurisdiction of consolidation courts, and the effect of mutation orders on revenue records. The court held that mutation orders do not decide right or title and cannot be upset by consolidation courts. It also emphasized that a sale deed obtained through fraudulent misrepresentation is void and can be challenged in a civil court.

Fact of the Case:

The case involved a dispute over land in a village brought under consolidation operations. The petitioner challenged the validity of orders passed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation, Pratapgarh, regarding the maintenance of basic year entry in the revenue records.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the mutation orders do not decide right or title and cannot be upset by consolidation courts. It also held that a sale deed obtained through fraudulent misrepresentation is void and can be challenged in a civil court.

Issues: The issues included the jurisdiction of consolidation courts, the effect of mutation orders, and the validity of the sale deed executed through impersonation.

Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that mutation orders do not decide right or title and cannot be upset by consolidation courts. It also highlighted that a sale deed obtained through fraudulent misrepresentation is void and can be challenged in a civil court.

Final Decision: The writ petition was allowed, and the impugned order passed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation, Pratapgarh, was quashed. The orders passed by the Settlement Officer Consolidation and the Consolidation Officer were given effect to.

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
For the Appellant : Ramsurat Pande, Arun Kumar Tripathi
For the Respondents: Anurag Srivastva, Ram Ashish

ORDER :

D.K. Upadhyay, J.

1. Heard Sri R.S. Pandey, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Anurag Srivastava, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos. 2 and 3.

2. This petition has arisen out of the proceedings drawn by the consolidation authorities in respect of dispute between the parties relating to land of khata No. 10, situate in village Pure Ram Sahai, Pargana Patti, Tehsil Raniganj, District Pratapgarh. The petitioner has challenged the validity of the orders dated 25.02.2015 and 03.07.2013 passed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation, Pratapgarh whereby the orders dated 12.06.2013 and 07.03.2011 passed by the Settlement Officer Consolidation and Consolidation Officer, respectively have been set-aside and an order has been passed to maintain the basic year entry in the revenue records.

3. The basic year entry in respect of the land in dispute was in the names of Chhedi Lal and Jokhulal, both sons of Rangayee. At the time of verification of khatauni, one Smt. Dhiraji claimed her possession over the land in dispute and accordingly she filed objection under Section 9-A (2) of U.P. Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953 (hereinafter referred to as 'Act') stating therein that the land in dispute devolved on her on the basis of sale deed and that she is bhumidhar of the land in question. It was further stated by Dhiraji in her objection that in the month of December, 1967, she was hospitalized for an eye operation in a nursing home at Allahabad wherefrom she was discharged on 09.01.1968 and during the period she was admitted in hospital at Allahabad i.e. between 26.12.1967 to 09.01.1968, Chhedi Lal and Jokhulal had obtained her thumb impression on plain paper on the pretext that certain levy has been imposed by the Tahsildar and for getting the said levy of food grains removed, she needed to give papers with her thumb impression.

4. The case put forth by Dhiraji was that Chhedi Lal and Jokhulal got a sale deed executed on 06.01.1968 on the said papers through their mother, who impersonated Dhiraji and that no sale consideration was paid to her in respect of the transaction which was the subject matter of the sale deed dated 06.01.1968.

5. Smt. Dhiraji accordingly filed Regular Suit No. 255 of 1969 for cancellation of the sale deed dated 06.01.1968, which was abated on account of the village, in which the land in question is situated, having brought under consolidation operations on issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Act, which was issued on 06.12.1970. Objection under Section 9-A(2) of the Act was filed by Dhiraji before the Consolidation Officer. The Consolidation Officer allowed the objection filed by Dhiraji vide his order dated 03.10.1971 and ordered that her name be recorded. Against the order dated 03.10.1971 passed by the Consolidation Officer, an appeal was preferred by Chhedi Lal and Jokhulal before the Settlement Officer Consolidation, which was allowed and the matter was remanded by him vide judgment and order dated 04.12.1971 to the Consolidation Officer concerned for decision of the issue afresh after providing opportunity of adducing evidence. On remand, Dhiraji moved an application before the Consolidation Officer for getting her thumb impression examined through an expert and accordingly report of the expert was filed in the court of Consolidation Officer, however the Consolidation Officer rejected the claim of Dhiraji and ordered for maintenance of basic year entry in the revenue records. Smt. Dhiraji, in the meantime, executed an adoption deed on 26.11.1978 whereby she adopted the petitioner and got the adoption deed registered on 27.01.1979. Against the order of Consolidation Officer dated 06.10.1978 whereby claim of Dhiraji was not conceded to, an appeal was filed by her before the Settlement Officer Consolidation, which too was dismissed on 09.05.1979. Thereafter challenging the said order passed by Settlement Officer Consolidation, a revision petition was filed by Dhiraji before the Deputy




































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top