SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2021 Supreme(All) 54

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD (LUCKNOW BENCH)
BACHCHOO LAL, SUBHASH CHANDER SHARMA, JJ.
Ashok Kumar and ors. - Appellant
Versus
State of U.P. - Respondent
Criminal Appeal No.5629 of 2010
Decided on : 25-01-2021

Headnote:(A) Indian Penal Code, 1860 - Sections 25, 74, and 132; The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - Section 239 - Criminal charges - The trial court upheld significantly the convictions under the IPC, establishing no substance in the defense; reliance on witness credibility highlighted. (Paras 1, 25, 34)

(B) Evidence Act, 1872 - Sections 134 and 6 - The principles governing evidence evaluation emphasized that not the quantity but quality is paramount, underscoring the importance of corroborating testimony in cases of direct eyewitness accounts. (Paras 22, 24)

Facts of the case:
The appellant faced charges hinging on multiple incidents involving allegations of violent conduct, with compelling witness accounts framing the narrative against him. Also criticized was the absence of a substantial motive scenario.

Findings of Court:
The court determined that despite the lack of a clear motive, the direct evidence presented warranted conviction, dismissing defense arguments as baseless.

Issues: Main issues revolved around the credibility of witnesses, their motives, and the substantiation of evidence presented during the trial.

Ratio Decidendi: The conviction was primarily supported by direct evidence from eyewitnesses, emphasizing the legal precedent that motive absence doesn’t negate trustworthy eyewitness testimony. The quality of evidence must remain the focal point of legal scrutiny.

Result: Conviction upheld, appeal dismissed.

JUDGMENT :

1- ;g nkf.Md vihy] vihykFkhZx.k v'kksd dqekj] lUrks"k dksjh ,oa ohjsUnz dqekj pekj dh vksj ls l= ijh{k.k la[;k 84 o"kZ 2006 mRrj izns'k jkT; izfr v'kksd dqekj ,oa vU; rFkk l= ijh{k.k la[;k 269 o"kZ 2006 mRrj izns'k jkT; izfr lUrks"k dksjh] eqdnek vijk/k la[;k 74 o"kZ 2005 vUrxZr /kkjk 302 Hkk0na0la0] Fkkuk pjok] ftyk dkS'kkEch ,oa l= ijh{k.k la[;k 82 o"kZ 2006 mRrj izns'k jkT; izfr v'kksd dqekj eqdnek vijk/k la[;k 132 o"kZ 2005 vUrxZr /kkjk 25 vk;q/k vf/kfu;e] Fkkuk pjok ftyk dkS'kkEch esa fo}ku vij l= U;k;k/kh'k@,Q0Vh0lh0] f}rh;] dkS'kkEch }kjk ikfjr fu.kZ; ,oa vkns'k fnukad 20&8&2010 ds fo:} ;ksftr dh x;h gS ftlds }kjk vihykFkhZx.k dks /kkjk 302 Hkk0na0la0 ds vUrxZr nks"kh ikrs gq, vkthou dkjkokl ,oa ik¡p&ik¡p gtkj :i;s ds vFkZn.M ls rFkk vFkZn.M vnk u djus dh fLFkfr esa izR;sd dks ,d&,d o"kZ ds vfrfjDr lk/kkj.k dkjkokl rFkk vihykFkhZ v'kksd dqekj dks /kkjk 25 vk;q/k vf/kfu;e ds vUrxZr rhu o"kZ ds lk/kkj.k dkjkokl ,oa ,d gtkj :i;s ds vFkZn.M ls rFkk vFkZn.M vnk u djus dh n'kk esa rhu ekg ds vfrfjDr dkjkokl ls nf.Mr fd;k x;k gSA ;g Hkh vknsf'kr fd;k x;k fd vfHk;qDrksa }kjk iwoZ esa bl ekeys esa fcrkbZ xbZ tsy vof/k bl ltk esa lek;ksftr dh tk;sxh rFkk lHkh ltk;sa lkFk lkFk pysxhA

2- vihy ds fuLrkj.k gsrq vko';d rF; la{ksi esa bl izdkj gS fd oknh eqdnek tXxh yky iq= Lo0 jke [ksykou dksjh us ,d rgjhj jke cnu iq= f'ko izlkn dksjh ls fy[kokdj Fkkuk pjok ftyk dkS'kkEch esa bl vk'k; ds lkFk nkf[ky fd;k fd mldh o mlds xk¡o ds lUrks"k dksjh dh tehu dk eqdnek py jgk Fkk ftlls lUrks"k dksjh jaft'k ekurk gSA dy fnukad 20&6&2005 dks mldk HkkbZ gjh yky mez djhc 40 o"kZ o xk¡o dk eksguyky iq= jke/kuh xk¡o esa jk/ks';ke dksjh ds edku ds pcwrjs ij cSBs ckrphr dj jgs Fks djhc lkढs N% cts 'kke dks xk¡o ds lUrks"k dksjh o mldk HkkbZ v'kksd dqekj iq=x.k jkefgr dksjh gkFkksa esa reUps fy, rFkk ohjsUnz dqekj pekj iq= I;kjs yky fuoklh jk;Hkku dk iqjok etjk pjok Fkkuk pjok ftyk dkS'kkEch pkdw fy, gq, vk;s tku ls ekjus dh fu;r ls bu yksxksa us reUpksa ls gjh yky ds Åij Qk;j dj fn;kA gjh yky 'kksj epkrk o fpYykrk gqvk esokyky ds ?kj esa ?kql x;kA ;s yksx ihNk djrs gq, esokyky ds ?kj esa ?kqldj reUpksa o pkdw ls ekjdj xkyh nsrs gq, okil vius ?kj dh vksj Hkkx x;sA og o mldk cMk HkkbZ jke lqesj 'kksjxqy lqudj ekSds ij vk x;s Fks ftUgksusa ?kVuk ns[khA ;s yksx Hkkxrs le; Qk;j djrs gq, reaps ygjkrs gq, xkyh xykSt ns jgs Fks ftlls xk¡o esa Hk; o ng'kr dk ekgkSy iSnk gks x;k gSA e`rd gjh yky dh yk'k ekSds ij iMh gSA Mj dh otg ls og jkr esa fjiksVZ fy[kkus Fkkus ugha vk ldkA vkt vk;k gw¡ mldh fjiksVZ fy[kdj dkuwuh dk;Zokgh dh tk,A

3- oknh dh mDr rgjhj izn'kZ d&1 ds vk/kkj ij Fkkuk ij vihykFkhZx.k ds fo:} eqdnek vijk/k la[;k 74 o"kZ 2005 /kkjk 302 Hkk0na0la0 ds vUrxZr eqdnek iathd`r fd;k x;kA fpd izFke lwpuk fjiksVZ izn'kZ d&2 gS rFkk eqdnek dk;eh ls lEcfU/kr th0 Mh0 dh izfr izn'kZ d&3 gSA

4- ekeys dh foospuk vfHk;kstu lk{kh la[;k 9 jke Hkjksls dq'kokgk] Fkkuk/;{k ds lqiqnZ dh x;hA mUgksusa vius c;ku esa ;g dgk gS fd fnukad 21&6&2005 dks og Fkkuk pjok esa Fkkuk/;{k ds in ij dk;Zjr FkkA mDr frfFk dks eqdnek vijk/k la[;k 74 o"kZ 2005 /kkjk 302 Hkk0na0la0 e`rd gjhyky dh foospuk mlds }kjk xzg.k dh x;hA fnukad 21&6&2005 dks bl eqdnes dh udy fpd] udy jiV ysdj e; ftYn iapk;rukek ,oa t:jh dkxtkr ds lkFk e; gejkgh ?kVukLFky xzke cjxnh jokuk gqvk FkkA Fkkus ij udy fpd] udy jiV djds ys[kd ,Q0vkbZ0vkj0 dk c;ku fy;k x;k FkkA ?kVukLFky ij e`rd dh yk'k dk iapk;rukek eqjRrc fd;k x;k FkkA yk'k dks okLrs iksLVekVZe 'ko foPNsnu x`g bykgkckn Hksth x;h FkhA ekSds ij oknh dk c;ku fy;k x;k FkkA oknh dh fu'kkunsgh ij fujh{k.k ?kVukLFky djds uD'kk utjh rS;kj fd;k x;k FkkA bl lk{kh us uD'kk utjh dks izn'kZ Ø&7 ds :i esa lkfcr fd;k gSA ;g Hkh dgk gS fd ekSds ij ekStwn vkse izdk'k o 'kQhd vgen dk lebZ lk{; vafdr fd;k x;kA ?kVukLFky ij ,d dkjrwl 315 cksj ¼[kks[kk½ cjken gqvk FkkA ekSds ls mlus feV~Vh lknh ,oa [kwu vkywn ysdj loZeksgj djds uewuk lhy rS;kj fd;k FkkA ekSds ij QnZ eqjkRrc dh x;h FkhA QnZ ij xokgku jke vkSrkj ,oa jke cnu flag ds gLrk{kj djk;s FksA bl lk{kh us QnZ feV~Vh

        Click Here to Read the rest of this document
        1
        2
        3
        4
        5
        6
        7
        8
        9
        10
        11
        SupremeToday Portrait Ad
        supreme today icon
        logo-black

        An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

        Please visit our Training & Support
        Center or Contact Us for assistance

        qr

        Scan Me!

        India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

        For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

        whatsapp-icon Back to top