SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2005 Supreme(UK) 246

2005 (2) U.D., 326
High Court of Uttaranchal
M.M. Ghildiyal, J.
Smt. Phoolwati and others
Versus
Additional District Judge/F.T.C. IV, Dehradun and another
Writ Petition no. 679 (M/S) of 2005
Decided on: 12-07-2005.

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is that the discretion to allow or reject an amendment under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC should be exercised judiciously, with the aim of minimizing litigation, and an amendment should not be rejected solely on the ground of delay.

Subject

Civil Law - Amendment of Pleadings

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.6 R.17

Headnote

Amendment - Civil Procedure - Order VI Rule 17 of CPC - 2004 (56) ALR 724, AIR 1984 Patna page 158, 2005 (59) ALR page 78 - The court discussed the amendment application under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC and emphasized that the discretion to allow or not allow an amendment should be exercised judiciously, considering the facts and circumstances of each case. The court highlighted that the dominant purpose of allowing the amendment application is to minimize litigation and that an amendment should not be rejected solely on the ground of delay. The judgment referenced key legal provisions and their interpretations, influencing the court's decision to dismiss the writ petition.

Fact of the Case:

The petitioners challenged the order rejecting their application for amendment in the written statement and ground of revision. The suit was filed for arrears of rent and ejectment on the ground of default in payment of rent. The defendants contested the suit, and the suit was decreed. The petitioners filed for amendment, which was rejected by the Revisional Court.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the amendment sought by the petitioners was not necessary for determining the real question in controversy between the parties and was moved just to delay the proceedings. The court upheld the rejection of the amendment application by the Revisional Court.

Issues: The issues revolved around the rejection of the amendment application under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC, the discretion of the court in allowing amendments, and the timing of the amendment application in relation to the commencement of the trial.

Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that the discretion to allow or reject an amendment should be exercised judiciously, considering the purpose of minimizing litigation. It highlighted that an amendment should not be rejected solely on the ground of delay and that each case depends on its factual background.

Final Decision: The writ petition was dismissed, and no order as to costs was given.

Advocates Appeared:
Sri S.K. Jain, Advocate for the petitioners.
Sri V.K. Kohli, Senior Advocate, assisted by Sri I.P. Kohli, Advocate for respondent the no.2.
Learned Standing Counsel for the respondent no. 1.

Judgment

Heard Sri S.K. Jain, learned counsel for the petitioners, Sri V.K. Kohli, learned Sr. Advocate assisted by Sri I.P. Kohli, learned counsel, who has accepted notice on behalf of respondent no.1.

2. Learned counsel for both the parties are agreed to decide the writ petition at Its admission stage Itself.

3. By means of this writ petition, petitioners have challenged the order dated 21-05-2005 passed by respondent no. 1 Additional District Judge/ FTC IV Dehradun, rejecting the application nos. 77 C and 75 C for amendment In written statement and ground of revision moved by defendant revisionist In SCCR No. 39 of 2001 pending before the respondent no. 1. The facts of the case are that on 12-06-1990, plaintiff filed a suit no. 3 of 1990 before Judge, Small Causes Court against the defendants / revisionists (petitioners) for arrears of rent and ejectment on the ground of default In payment of rent In respect of part of the property no. 32, Raja Road, Dehradun. One Sri Brahmanand was the tenant in part of the house No. 32 consisting of one room, kothari, one small verandah, latrine, bathroom and chabutra @ Rs. 12/- per month. The rent was enhanced later on from Rs. 12/- to Rs. 25 per month. After the death of Sri Brahmanand, his legal heirs became .the tenant In the said property @ Rs. 25/per month. According to learned counsel for the petitioners plaintiff / respondent gave wrong details of the property which Is In the tenancy of the defendants / petitioners, as the accommodation with the defendants, which has been mentioned in the plaint about two rooms Is neither In the tenancy of the defendants nor lying on the spot. The said suit was contested by the defendants by filing written statement and In the written statement the defendants denied the allegations made in the plaint. The said suit was decreed on 24-04-2001 by Civil Judge (Senior Division)/7th ADJ/FTC VIII, Dehradun.

4. Aggrieved by the order dated 24-04-2001, the petitioners defendants filed SCCR No. 39 of 2001 before the District Judge, Dehradun and the case Is still pending before respondent no.1. In the aforesaid revision, the defendants moved application Nos. 75 C and 77 C under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC for amendment in the written statement as well as in the grounds of revision. Plaintiff / respondent filed objection no. 79 C and 80 C. One application no. 70 C for inspection of the spot by the court was moved by the defendants and the same is still pending. However, respondent no.1 rejected the applications No. 75 and 77 vide order dated 21-05-2005.

5. Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that amendment sought by the petitioners will not change the nature of the case and in fact, there Is no finding of the Revisional Court that the amendment sought by the petitioners will change the nature of the case, still the respondent no.1 rejected the amendment application of the defendants petitioners. He has further submitted that Order VI Rule 17 of CPC provides that the Court may at any stage of the proceedings allow either party to alter or amend his pleadings in such a manner and on such terms as may be just and all such amendments shall be made as may be necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy between the parties. However, the learned lower court has Ignored the correct preposition of law while rejecting the amendment application. He has further submitted that amendment cannot be rejected on the ground of delay and amendment sought by the petitioners are simply explanatory In nature.

6. Learned counsel for the petitioners has placed reliance upon the following judgements reported in AIR 1984 Patna page 158 (Ram Prasad Mahton and others Vs. Babu Jagoo Mahton and others); 2005 (59) ALR page 78 (Murari Lal Vs. 5th Additional District Judge, Bulandshahar and others) and 2004 (56) ALR 724 (Pankaja and another Vs. Yellappa (D) by L. Rs and others).

7. The Authority "AIR 1984 Patna page 158" cited by the learned counsel fo



















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top