R.S.GARG
Jamuna Bai – Appellant
Versus
Surendra Kumar – Respondent
What is the validity of a will executed as per the directions of the testator's mother? What is the legal requirement for a will to be duly signed by two witnesses and the signature of the deceased to be proved? What is the effect of a propounder of a will not being a Hindu on the validity of a will executed by a Hindu?
Key Points: - A will is defined as a legal declaration of the intention of a testator with respect to his property after his death (!) . - A will executed as per the directions of the testator's mother is not invalid (!) . - A will duly signed by two witnesses, with the signature of the deceased proved, and read over in the presence of all and accepted by the testator before signing, is considered proved (!) . - The opinion of a handwriting expert who lacks education in the language and whose opinion is based on suggestive evidence is rightly not relied upon (!) . - A will duly attested by two witnesses after the signature of the testator, with attestation made as per Section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act, is considered properly and legally executed (!) . - The burden shifts to the objectors to prove that a will is not genuine and valid once its execution and attestation are validly proved (!) . - The testator dying after 45 days of execution does not automatically render the execution doubtful if the unfit condition of the testator is not proven (!) . - An interest in joint Hindu property can be disposed of by a will under Section 30 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (!) . - A will can be executed in favor of a person not professing the religion of the testator; there is no embargo on this power (!) . - Provisions under Section 279 of the Succession Act regarding prior proceedings are directory, not mandatory, and failure to mention them does not warrant dismissal of the petition (!) . - The provision for verification of pleadings under Section 281 of the Succession Act is directory, and the propounder of the will has no authority to compel an attesting witness to verify the pleading (!) . - The intention of the legislature behind Section 281 is to avoid initiation of proceedings on forged wills, and the attesting witness signing the petition for letter of administration is sufficient; the form is also directory (!) . - A propounder is required to clear suspicion with clear and satisfactory evidence, proving the will is genuine and executed by the deceased without circumstances creating a cloud on its genuineness (!) . - The freedom to bequeath property amongst Hindus is absolute, including to a stranger (!) . - The interest of a male Hindu in Mitakshara co-parcenary property is deemed capable of being disposed of by will (!) . - The appeal was dismissed, but there was no order as to costs (!) .
1. This miscellaneous appeal under S. 299 of the Indian Succession Act has been filed by some objectors against the order dated 4.7.1988 passed in Probate Case No.4 of 1983 by the learned Additional Judge, Mhow to the Court of District Judge, Indore, rejecting the objectings filed by the objectors and granting the probate certificate on the application of respondent No.1 filed under S. 276 of the Indian Succession Act.
2. The respondent No.1 filed an application under S. 276 of the Act alleging therein that deceased Dujain, who was the real elder brother of respondent No. 1, executed a will on 20th April, 1976 in favour of the respondent No. 1 whereunder the properties were bequesthed in favour of the respondent No. 1. It was further averred that Dujai having expired on 5.6.76, the respondent No.1 has succeeded to the property. According to the respondent No.1 the properties described in the will would be succeeded by him which include moveables and immoveables. The application was filed in the year 1977 and a public notice was issued in daily newspaper 'Swadesh'. As no objections were received, by order dated 12.8.77 granting the application of respondent No.1 a probate cert
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.