SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2011 Supreme(MP) 135

IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
N.K. Agarwal, J.
Shyam Kathpal and Anr.
Vs.
Smt. Swarnakanta Sharma and Anr.
Writ Petition (227) No. 2490/2010
Decided On: 10.02.2011

Important Points

A time-barred relief should not be allowed to be incorporated by way of amendment, and such amendment cannot relate back to the date of filing of the suit to cure the defect of limitation.

Subject

Civil Law - Amendment of Pleadings

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.2 R.2, O.6 R.17
LIMITATION ACT : Art.54

Headnote

Amendment - Civil Suit - Code of Civil Procedure - Order 6 Rule 17 - [Order 6 Rule 17] - The court discussed the legality and propriety of an order allowing an amendment to the plaint seeking specific performance of a contract in a civil suit. The court referred to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Revajeetu Builders and Developers v. Narayanswamy and Sons and Van Vibhag Karamchari Griha Nirman Sahakari Sanstha Mary adit (Regd.) v. Ramesh Chander and Ors. to determine whether the amendment should be allowed. The court held that a time-barred relief should not be allowed to be incorporated by way of amendment, and such amendment cannot relate back to the date of filing of the suit to cure the defect of limitation.

Fact of the Case:

The Plaintiff instituted a suit for declaration of title based on adverse possession and sought injunction to restrain the Defendants from interfering with their possession over the suit property. The Plaintiff also sought to incorporate the relief of specific performance of contract through an amendment to the plaint.

Finding of the Court:

The court allowed the amendment in part, holding that the amendment seeking specific performance of a contract shall not relate back to the date of filing of the suit, and the plaint shall be deemed to be filed with the relief of specific performance of contract on the date of filing of the amendment application.

Issues: Legality and propriety of the order allowing the amendment to the plaint seeking specific performance of a contract.

Ratio Decidendi: The court relied on the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Revajeetu Builders and Developers v. Narayanswamy and Sons and Van Vibhag Karamchari Griha Nirman Sahakari Sanstha Mary adit (Regd.) v. Ramesh Chander and Ors. to determine whether the amendment seeking specific performance of a contract should be allowed. The court held that a time-barred relief should not be allowed to be incorporated by way of amendment, and such amendment cannot relate back to the date of filing of the suit to cure the defect of limitation.

Final Decision: The petition was allowed in part, and the order allowing the amendment to the plaint was modified to the extent that the relief of specific performance of contract shall not relate back to the date of filing of the suit.

ORDER

N.K. Agarwal, J.

1. Legality and propriety of the order dated 23-4-2010 passed by the first Civil Judge Class II, Raipur in Civil Suit No. 34-A/2010 whereby an application preferred by the Respondent No. 1/Plaintiff under Order 6 Rule 17 of Code of Civil Procedure has been allowed is under assail in the instant petition preferred by the Defendants.

Facts of the case in brief are as under:

2. On 20-12-2007 Plaintiff instituted a suit for declaration of title based on adverse possession, injunction to restrain Defendants from interfering his possession over the suit property inter alia on the following pleading:

3. The Plaintiff's mother Late Shantidevi Sharma entered into agreement of sale of the suit property with the Defendant No. 1 on 8-8-1987 for a consideration of Rs. 10,000/-. The entire sale consideration was paid by her till 4-5-2005. She also obtained its possession. Plaintiff is paying its municipal tax. Earlier Defendant No. 1 instituted a suit for eviction of Plaintiff's mother from the suit property bearing Civil Suit No. 441-A/2002. Later, on 4-5-2005 as per compromise the above suit was withdrawn and Defendant agreed to execute the sale deed regarding suit property in her favour. Smt. Shantidevi Sharma died on 11-10-2007. After her demise, the Defendant No. 1 assured Plaintiff for execution of sale deed but did not execute the same. On 4-12-2007, the Defendant No. 2 entered in the suit property for unauthorized construction. The matter was reported to Police Station, Pandri, Raipur. It appears, in connivance with Bhumafia, the Defendants want to dispossess Plaintiff in order to sell the same to Defendant No. 2. The Plaintiff is in possession of the suit property in pursuance of sale agreement dated 8-8-87 and also Defendant is bound to execute the sale deed based on compromise dated 4-5-2005. The Plaintiff is in continuous possession of the suit land for the last 20 year's and the Defendants have no right to dispossess her.

4. Vide application dated 8-4-2010, amendment was sought in the plaint to incorporate the relief of specific performance contract. Prayer was opposed. Learned Trial Court vide order impugned allowed the amendment.

5. As per Learned Counsel for the parties, the amendment had already been incorporated and Petitioner's application for consequential amendment is pending.

6. Shri Manoj Paranjpe; Learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner would submit, the agreement was executed on 8-8-1987 and after a period of 20 years from the date of execution of the agreement, the Plaintiff wants to incorporate the relief of specific performance of contract which is clearly barred by time. It is trite law that such time barred amendment cannot be allowed. He would further submit, the above amendment would change the nature and character of the suit. The relief of title based on adverse possession and relief of specific performance of contract are destructive to each other and therefore, the order impugned is patently illegal and deserves to be set aside. Reliance has been placed on the judgment of Supreme Court in the case of Van Vibhag Karamchari Griha Nirman Sahakari Sanstha Mary adit (Regd.) v. Ramesh Chander and Ors. reported in AIR 2010 SCW 6761.

7. On the other hand, Shri H.B. Agrawal, learned Sr. Counsel appearing for the Respondent No. 1 would submit, in essence the suit was based on agreement of sale dated 8-8-87. Looking to the fact that on 4-5-2005, the Defendant No. 1 agreed to execute the sale deed and cause of action arose only on 4-12-2007 when Defendant tried to dispossess the Plaintiff, therefore, the relief of specific performance of contract sought by way of amendment is neither time barred nor would change the nature and character of the suit. Learned Trial Court in its discretion has rightly allowed the same. It will not cause any prejudice to the Petitioner. The Petitioner's are well within their right to deny Plaintiff's claim. It was further contended, the plea of limitation in the facts
























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top