CARLUCCI – Appellant
Versus
DOE, (1988) – Respondent
After respondent, a cryptographic material control technician at the National Security Agency (NSA), disclosed to NSA officials that he had engaged in homosexual relationships with foreign nationals, his employment was terminated pursuant to NSA personnel regulations setting forth procedures for removal "for cause," which were promulgated under provisions of the National Security Agency Act of 1959 (1959 NSA Act) empowering the Secretary of Defense, or his designee, to appoint NSA employees. Claiming that the 1959 NSA Act does not authorize removals and that he could only be discharged under 5 U.S.C. 7532 - which provides that, "[n]otwithstanding other statutes," the head of an agency "may" suspend and then remove employees "in the interests of national security," so long as they have been given, inter alia, a preremoval hearing by the agency head or his designee - respondent requested a hearing before the Secretary. That request was denied on the ground that respondent had been removed under the NSA regulations, which do not include the right to such a hearing, and not pursuant to the Secretarys 7532 summary authority. Granting summary judgment for petitioners, the Secretary and the NSA Director, in respondents suit challenging his removal, the District Court held that, although NSA could have elected to proceed under either 7532 or 50 U.S.C. 833 - which is part of the NSA Personnel Security Procedures Act, and which provides that the Secretary "may" remove an NSA employee upon determining that the termination procedures set forth in other statutes "cannot be invoked consistently with national security" - NSA could also proceed under the authority provided by the 1959 NSA Act. The Court of Appeals reversed as to the optional application of 7532 and vacated the remainder of the District Courts decision, holding that removals for national security reasons must occur under either 7532 or 833, and that, because NSA disclaimed reliance on 833, resort to 7532 rather than NSAs for cause removal regulations was mandatory.
Held:
Neither 833 nor 7532 barred NSA from invoking its for-cause removal mechanism adopted by regulation pursuant to the 1959 NSA Act. Pp. 99-104.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.