2024 Supreme(BD)(SC) 12718
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH
HIGH COURT DIVISION
(CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
Present:
Mr. Justice Zafar Ahmed
Civil Revision No. 250 of 1997 Ramshinath Gowala
Petitioner
-Versus-
Bangladesh, represented by the Deputy Commissioner, Sylhet and others
Opposite parties
Mr. Jyotirmoy Narayan Deb, Advocate
...For the petitioner Ms. Shahida Khatoon, with
Mr. Sovan Mahmud and
Ms. Khandaker Asma Hamid, AAGs
... For the opposite parties
Heard on 05.11.2024 and 26.11.2024 Judgment on: 03.12.2024
Plaintiff No. 3 is the petitioner of the instant civil revision. Present petitioner and others filed Title Suit No. 09 of 1978 impleading the government and Additional Deputy Commissioner (revenue), Sylhet as defendants in the Court of 1st Additional Sub- ordinate Judge, Sylhet. The suit was decreed on contest, vide judgment and decree dated 15.05.1978 (decree signed on 12.08.1978).
1
The defendants filed Title Appeal No. 05 of 1979 which was allowed by the 3rd Court of Additional District Judge, Sylhet, vide judgment and decree dated 23.04.1995. Being aggrieved, the plaintiff No. 3 filed the instant revision and obtained Rule on 21.01.1997.
The plaintiffs filed the suit praying for declaration that the lands described in the schedule to the plaint and no share or part thereof are enemy, vested or non-resident property and that the defendants are not entitled to disturb the possession of the plaintiffs in the suit land with further prayer for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with the plaintiffs’ possession in the same.
The case of the plaintiffs, in short, is that the suit land measuring an area of 30.14 acres out of 90.43 acres recorded in Khatian Nos. 529 and 143 of Mouza-Dharan and Mominchara under P.S. Fenchuganj, District-Sylhet originally belonged to Sahadeb Gowala who died leaving three sons, namely- Sudhir Gowala and Adhir Gowala (plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2) and Mahendra Gowala as his sole heirs. They got the suit land in equal share and had been possessing the same since then. Settlement record of rights were accordingly prepared in their names. Mahendra Gowala was of wandering mind. He wanted to sell his share inherited by him and asked his two brothers (plaintiff Nos. 1-2) to purchase the same. At that time plaintiff No. 3 (son-in-law of plaintiff No. 1), who was residing at Fultala Tea Estate under P.S. Kulaura, wanted to purchase the share of Mahendra Gowala i.e. 30.14 acres of land and the price was fixed at Tk. 2,000. The plaintiff No. 3 paid Tk. 1,000/- to Mahendra on 28th Aswin, 1371 B.S. On the same date Mahendra executed a Shikritinama in favour of the plaintiff No. 3 and delivered possession of his share in favour of plaintiff No. 3. The parties agreed to execute and register the sale deed after obtaining necessary permission and acceptance of balance consideration money. After taking possession of the suit land the plaintiff No. 3 constructed a house on the said land and has been possessing and enjoying the same with the plaintiff Nos. 1-2. After applying for permission before the relevant authority for execution and registration of the sale deed Mahendra Gowala went to pilgrimage in Falgun 1371 B.S. and did not return. Subsequently, the plaintiff No. 3 got a notice on 26.06.76 from
the defendant No. 2 demanding surrender of the possession of share of the schedule land claiming the same as vested property, failing which the plaintiffs would be evicted therefrom. Specific case of the plaintiffs is that the suit land is not enemy or vested property and there is no reason to treat the same as such.
The defendant No. 1 contested the suit by filing written statement stating, inter alia, that the suit is not maintainable and the same is barred by limitation and is bad for defect of parties and as such, the plaintiffs are not entitled to any relief. The s