CUSTOMS, EXCISE & SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL

NEW DELHI

PRINCIPAL BENCH

ANTI-DUMPING APPEAL NO. 50322 OF 2021

(Arising out of Final Findings No. 6/15/2019-DGTR dated 20.08.2020)

M/s. Xinyi Energy Smart

…. Appellant

(Malaysia) SDN BHD

Plot No. 23A & B, Elkay Industrial Park,

Lipat Kajang, 77000 Jasin, Malaka

versus

1.

The Union of India

Through the Secretary,

Ministry of Finance,

Department of Revenue,

North Block, New Delhi-110001

2.

Designated Authority, Directorate

General of Trade Remedies

Department of Commerce & Industry

Parliament Street, Jeevan Tara

Building, 4^th Floor, New Delhi-110001

3.

The Government of Malaysia,

Kementarian Perdagangan

Antarabangsa Dan Industri,

Ministry of International Trade and Industry

Menara Perdagangan Antarabangsa Dan Industri,

No. 7, Jalan Sultan Haji Ahmad Shah,

50480, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

4.

M/s. Sisecam Flat Glass India Ltd.

2, Red Cross Place,

Kolkata- 700001

5.

M/s Saint Gobain India Pvt. Ltd.

Plot No. A-1,

SIPCOT Industrial Park,

Sriperumbudur-602106

Kanchipuram District,

Tamil Nadu

6.

M/s. Gold Plus Glass Industry Ltd.

Gold Plus House,

G-192, Prashant Vihar,

Delhi 11085

7.

M/s. Asahi India Glass Limited

38, Okhla Industrial Area,

Phase –III, New Delhi- 110020

8.

M/s. Kibing Group (M) Sdn. Bhd.

Lot No. 635 & 660,

Kawasan Perindustrian Tuanku Jaafar,

71450, Sungal Gadut,

Negari Sembilan, Malaysia.

2

AD/50322/2022 & Others

9.

Float Glass Centre

23/55, Devarajan Street,

Park, Town, Chennai- 600003.

10.

Golden Glass Traders

Survey No. 37/4/2/1,

Mohan Marble Lane,

Pisoli, Pune-411048

11.

Global Glass

1-2, 10^th Floor, Everest,

156, Tardeo Road, Mumbai-400034

12.

Bagrecha Enterprises Ltd.

850/5, MTP Road,

Opp. Flower Market Bus Stop,

Coimbatore-02

13.

CVS Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. …… Respondents

3, Gujrat Industrial Estate, Off Area Road,

Goregaon (E), Mumbai- 400063

WITH

ANTI-DUMPING APPEAL NUMBERS

50412 of 2021, 50413 of 2021, 50414 of 2021 and 50418 of 2021

APPEARANCE:

Ms. Reena Khair, Ms. Shreya Dahiya, Shri. Anmol Jain and Shri Subham

Jaiswal, Advocates for Xinyi Energy Smart

Shri Ramesh Singh, Sr. Advocate, Shri Jitendra Singh, Shri Akshay Soni, Shri

Anshuman Sahni, Shri Sharad Bhausali, Advocates and Shri Jinendra Singhvi,

Consultant for the Domestic Industry

Shri Ameet Singh and Shri Mohit Yadav, Advocates for the Designated

Authority

Shri Rakesh Kumar, Authorized Representative for the Government of India

CORAM:

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DILIP GUPTA, PRESIDENT

HON’BLE MR. P.V. SUBBA RAO, MEMBER (TECHNICAL)

HON’BLE MS. RACHNA GUPTA MEMBER (JUDICIAL)

Date of Hearing: 14.11.2022

Date of Decision: 20.01.2023

FINAL ORDER NO’s. _50053-50057/2023_

3

AD/50322/2022 & Others

JUSTICE DILIP GUPTA:

Anti-Dumping Appeal No. 50322 of 2021 has been filed by

M/s. Xinyi Energy Smart (Malaysia), Sdn Bhd¹ for setting aside the

imposition of anti-dumping duty so far as the exports by Xinyi Energy

are concerned by customs notification dated 11.11.2020 read with the

final findings dated 20.08.2020. The submission is that its exports to

India by Xinyi Energy are not at dumped prices, and the determination

of the dumping margin by the designated authority in the final findings

is erroneous for the reason that it is based on a faulty determination of

the normal value and export price.

2.

Anti-Dumping Appeal Numbers 50412 of 2021, 50413 of

2021, 50414 of 2021 and 50418 of 2021 have been filed by M/s.

Asahi India Glass Ltd, M/s. Gold Plus Glass Industry Ltd., M/s. Saint

Gobain India Pvt Ltd. and M/s. Sisecam Flat Glass India Pvt. Ltd.²,

respectively, as domestic industry, with a prayer that Xinyi Energy

should have been treated as a non-co-operating exporter by the

designated authority and/or relegate Xi