ASIA BRIGHT ENTERPRISES LTD AND OTHERS vs LIU CHEUK MAN AND OTHERS

Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation

LDCS 35000/2019

[2023] HKLdT 30

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

LAND COMPULSORY SALE MAIN APPLICATION NO 35000 OF 2019

__________________________

BETWEEN

	ASIA BRIGHT ENTERPRISES LIMITED (明耀企業有限公司)	1 ^st Applicant
	NEW FORTRESS INVESTMENT LIMITED (新誠投資有限公司)	2 ^nd Applicant
	DYNAMIC HERO LIMITED (恒雄有限公司)	3 ^rd Applicant
	GENTWAY LIMITED (雋偉有限公司)	4 ^th Applicant
	EVER PLANET LIMITED (偉宙有限公司)	5 ^th Applicant
	SUPREME HERO LIMITED (崇英有限公司)	6 ^th Applicant
	GLORY STAR DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (佳星發展有限公司)	7 ^th Applicant
	TRIPLE GLORY LIMITED (三耀有限公司)	8 ^th Applicant
	GROUP LEADER LIMITED (合英有限公司)	9 ^th Applicant
	and
	LIU CHEUK MAN (廖焯文) and CHAN LAI MUI (陳麗梅)	1 ^st Respondents
	SILVER TREASURE HOLDINGS LIMITED (銀寶控股有限公司)	2 ^nd Respondent
	LAW SIU PUN (羅紹彬)	3 ^rd Respondent (Discontinued)
	WONG CHI HUNG (王志鴻)	4 ^th Respondent
	HO WING KEI (何榮基) as ADMINISTRATOR and HO WING YAN (何詠恩) as ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF CHOW TSUI YU (周翠瑜), DECEASED	5 ^th Respondents (Discontinued)
	CHE CHI CLINIC OF CHINESE HERBAL MEDICINE LIMITED (佛教慈濟中醫診所有限公司)	6 ^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	YU KAM TAI (余金娣)	7 ^th Respondent
	YEUNG MAN WAI (楊雯蕙), THE PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF SO CHAI YAU (蘇齊有), DECEASED	8 ^th Respondent
	CAI XIUYANG (蔡秀鴦)	9 ^th Respondent
	AU-YEUNG LING (歐陽玲) as ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF SZE CHOI (OR CHOY) YING (史賽英), DECEASED	10 ^th Respondent (Discontinued)

__________________________

Before:

His Honour Judge M Wong, Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal and Mr Alex Ng, Member of the Lands Tribunal

Dates of Trial:	25 – 29 July and 21 October 2022
Date of Handing Down of Judgment:	21 April 2023

__________________

JUDGMENT

__________________

BACKGROUND

1. This is the applicants’ application for an order for sale, for the purposes of redevelopment under the Land (Compuls

Login now and unlock premium legal research