Shephali REPORTABLE IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 11564 OF 2022 SUO MOTU WRIT PETITION NO. 2 OF 2023 WITH COURT RECEIVER’S REPORT NO. 23 OF 2023 IN SUO MOTU WRIT PETITION NO. 2 OF 2023 Monish Chintaman Patil, As per order dated Age 28 years, Adult, Occ. Service, 28/08/2023 an Residing at Village Ghansoli, Post Ghansoli, amendment carried Tal. & Dist. Thane out.

HIGH COURT ON ITS OWN MOTION, (As per Order dated 28/02/2023 passed in Civil Writ Petition No 11564/2022) …Petitioner SHEPHALI ~ versus ~

SANJAY MORMARE

1. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA, Digitally signed by SHEPHALI SANJAY MORMARE Through Principal Secretary, Date: 2024.03.26

15:51:43 +0530 Mantralaya, Mumbai.

2. THE COMMISSIONER, New Bombay Municipal Corporation, having office at NMMC Head Quarters, Plot No 1, Nr Kille Gaothan, Palm Beach Junction, Sector – 59, CBD Belapur, New Bombay 400 614

3. CITY AND INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION OF MAHARASHTRA LTD, Konkan Bhavan, CND Belapur, New Bombay.

4. SANJAY PANDURANG PATIL

5. VISHNU KANA PATIL

6. SANDESH BABULNATH PATIL

7. ISWAR PATEL Respondents Nos 4 to 7 residing at Village Ghansoli, Tal. And Dist. Thane

8. MAHARASHTRA ELECTRICITY DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LIMITED, Hongkong Bank Building, MG. Road, Fort, Mumbai 400 001.

As per Order dated 28/08/2023, Respondent No 8 is added.

9. SUBHASH DEORAO MORE, Flat No 001

10. SEEMA SANDIP BORGE & SANDIP YASHWANT BORGE, Flat No 101

11. RUSHIKESH NIVRUTTI GADHAVE, Flat No 102

12. SONALI KUNDAN NIKAM &

KUNDAN M NIKAM, Flat No 103

13. AKSHAY PANDURANG YADAV & PUSHPA PRAJAJPATI, Flat No 104

14. ARVIND PRAKASH MHETRE (TENANT), Flat No 105

15. RAJULAL NAINLAL KHATIK & KESAR DEVI, Flat No 106

16. SUBHASH CHANDRAKANT JADHAV & SHOBHA JAHDAV, Flat No 107

17. BHAGHASHREE SANDIP BENGADE, Flat No 201

18. BHARAT DEVAJI PAWAR &

SHANUKA BHARAT PAWAR, Flat No 202

19. SACHIN K DHUMAL &

POONAM SACHIN DHUMAL, Flat No 203

20. YASHWANT SHANKAR JUNGHARE & NANDINI YASHWANT JUNGHARE, Flat No 204

21. KRISHNA PANDIT KAMBLE & POOJA KRISHNA KAMBLE & TEJUBAI PANDIT KAMBLE, Flat No 205

22. VIKRAM R YADAV, RAMCHANDRA GUPAT &

SANDHYA R GUPTA, Flat No 206

23. CHNDRAKANT PUNDLIK KADAM, LEELA C KADAM &

SHUBHAM C KADAM, Flat No 207

24. VILAS SADASHIV JADHAV, LALITA V JADHAV, NISHA JADHAV, VISHAKHA JADHAV & ADITYA VILAS JADHAV, Flat No 301

25. DATTU GOVIND NAVADKAR (FATHER OF FLAT PURCHASER), Flat No 302

26. DIKSHA PRAFUL AUTADE, Flat No 303

27. PRAVIN KHANDU DHAGE &

SUSHMA PRAVIN DHAGE, Flat No 304

28. NITIN GOPINATH SALUNKHE & SUSHMA PRAVIN DHAGE, Flat No 307

29. RAJASHREE DILIP KOLI (TENANT), Flat No 403

30. ARJUN KUMAR PANDEY &

AARATI PANDEY, Flat No 404

31. SAVITRI MISHRA &

KRISHNA MISHRA (TENANT), Flat No 407 …Respondents Respondents Nos 9 to 31 are residing at Om Sai Apartments, ‘B’ Wing, House No GHA-1270-0007 and House No GHA-1109 and House No GHA-1235, Ghansoli Village, Navi Mumbai 400 701.

As per Order dated 11/09/2023, an Amendment is carried out adding 23 occupants as Respondents Nos 9 to 31 to the Petition.

APPEARANCES Amicus Mr Sharan Jagtiani, Senior Advocate, with Vishal Narichania, Sumeet Nankani, Surabhi Agrawal & Akshay Doctor.

for respondent no 2- Mr Tejesh Dande, with Bharat NMMC Gadhavi, Trushna Shah, Pratik Sabrad, Vikran Khare, Seema Patil & Mansi Dande.

for respondent no 3- Mr Rohit Sakhadeo CIDCO for respondents nos Mr Anil Anturkar, Senior

4 to 6 Advocate, with Akshay Jadhav.

for respondent no Ms Khushnood Akhtar, with Shivaji

7developer Nirmale.

for respondents nos Mr RD Soni, with Jayesh Gawade.

9 to 31 for respondent- Mr PP Kakade, GP, with MP State Thakur, AGP.

present in court Mr SK Dhekale, Court Receiver with Sameer Alekar, Section Officer.

CORAM : G.S. Patel &

Kamal Khata, JJ.

DATED : 8th & 11th March 2024 ORAL JUDGMENT ( Per GS Patel J) :-

1. The Petition began in the name of an individual, one Monish Chintaman Patil. He filed this Petition on 10th August 2022. He complained that on Gat No 316 of Village Ghansoli within the local limits of the Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation (“NMMC”) and