2024:BHC-AS:12524 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY Digitally signed by Amol A Dm ilio pl rao CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION DilipraoNawale Nawale Date:

2024.03.14 14:34:38 +0530 SECOND APPEAL NO.699 OF 2012

1. Maruti Janu Mhaskar age- 64 years, Occ- Agriculturist r/at Manjarli Village, Taluka Ambernath, District-Thane and more particularly at Mhaskar Bungalow, Jijai Mhaskar Nagar, Valivali road, Badlapur (West), Opp. Sonal Paradise CHS Ltd, Manjarli Village, Taluka – Ambernath, District-Thane.

(Through Deceased his Legal Heirs)

1A. Mrs. Sneha Sunil Misal age-38 years, Occ-Housewife, r/at Shreenathji Apartment, Matheran road, Neral, Taluka-Karjat, District Raigad.

1B. Mrs. Shilpa Datta Rasal age-33 years, Occ-Housewife, r/at Mukkam & post - Kohojgaon village.

Taluka - Ambernath, District – Thane.

1C. Mr. Amit Maruti Mhaskar age 25 years, Occ- service r/at Mhaskar Bungalow, Jijai Mhaskar Nagar, Valivali road, Badlapur (West), Opp. Sonal Paradise CHS Ltd, Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District - Thane

2. Vimal W/o Maruti Janu Mhaskar age- 54 years, Occ- Household r/at Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District Thane and more particularly at Mhaskar Bungalow, Jijai Mhaskar Nagar, Valivali road, Badlapur (West), Opp. Sonal Paradise CHS Ltd, Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District – Thane. … Appellant Versus

1. Muktabai Suryakant Bhoir age - 51 years, Occ- Household, r/at C-585/1170, section 25, Ulhasnagar no.4, District - Thane and more particularly at C-585/1170, Manera Village road, Krishna Nagar, section 25, Ulhasnagar no.4, District - Thane

2. Ganpat Janu Mhaskar age- 62 years, Occ- Agriculturist r/at Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District Thane and more particularly at Ganpat Mhaskar House, Jijai Mhaskar Nagar, Valivali road, Badlapur (West), Opp. Sonal Paradise CHS Ltd, Manjarli Village, Taluka Ambernath, District Thane

3. Gulab Jairam Mhatre age-60 years, Occ- Household r/at C/o Jairam Maruti Mhatre, Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District - Thane and more particularly at C/o Jairam Maruti Mhatre, Sharad Mhatre House, Badlapur (West)

Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District - Thane

4. Hirabai Sitaram Shelke age- 59 years, Occ- Household r/at C/O Nitin Shelke Village - Kasgoan, Taluka – Ambernath, District – Thane … Respondents ALONG WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 9801 OF 2022 IN SECOND APPEAL NO. 699 OF 2012

1. Muktabai Suryakant Bhoir age 51 years, Occ- Household, r/at C-585/1170, section 25, Ulhasnagar no.4, District-Thane

2. Ganpat Janu Mhaskar age-62 years, Occ- Agriculturist r/at Manjarli, Tal.-Ambernath, … Applicants I N THE MATTER BETWEEN 1. Maruti Janu Mhaskar, age- 64 years, Occ- Agriculturist, r/at Manjarli Village, Taluka Ambernath, District-Thane and more particularly at Mhaskar Bungalow, Jijai Mhaskar Nagar, Valivali road, Badlapur (West), Opp. Sonal Paradise CHS Ltd., Manjarli Village, Taluka – Ambernath, District-Thane.

(Through Deceased his Legal Heirs)

1A. Mrs. Sneha Sunil Misal, age-38 years, Occ-Housewife, r/at Shreenathji Apartment, Matheran road, Neral, Taluka-Karjat, District Raigad.

1B. Mrs. Shilpa Datta Rasal, age-33 years, Occ-Housewife, r/at Mukkam & post - Kohojgaon village.

Taluka - Ambernath, District – Thane.

1C. Mr. Amit Maruti Mhaskar, age 25 years, Occ- service, r/at Mhaskar Bungalow, Jijai Mhaskar Nagar, Valivali road, Badlapur (West), Opp. Sonal Paradise CHS Ltd., Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District - Thane

2. Vimal W/o Maruti Janu Mhaskar, age- 54 years, Occ- Household, r/at Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District Thane, and more particularly at Mhaskar Bungalow, Jijai Mhaskar Nagar, Valivali road, Badlapur (West), Opp. Sonal Paradise CHS Ltd, Manjarli Village, Taluka - Ambernath, District – Thane. … Appellant Versus

1. Muktabai Suryakant Bhoir, age - 51 years, Occ- Household, r/at C-585/1170, section 25, Ulhasnagar no.4, District - Thane, and more particularly at C-585/1170, Manera Village Road, Krishna Nagar, section 25, Ulhasnagar No.4, District