2025:BHC-AS:570 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 1057 OF 2023 WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 18449 OF 2023

1. Shri Nitin Marutrao Kale )

Age: 50 Years, Occ: Business, R/o. Post: Sansar, ) Taluka: Indapur, Dist. Pune, Pin Code – 413104 )

2. Sou Rina Nitin Kale )

Age: 40 Years, Occ: Business, )

R/o. Sansar, Taluka: Indapur, Dist. Pune ) …Appellants Versus

1. Shri Manikrao Bajirao Malgunde )

Age: 71 Years, Occ: Agriculture, )

2. Shri Anil Manikrao Malgunde )

Age: 45 Years, Occ: Agriculture )

3. Shri Kashinath Manikrao Malgunde )

Age: 43 Years, Occ: Agriculture )

4. Shri Somnath Bajiroa Malgunde, )

Age: 65 Years, Occ: Agriculture )

5. Shri Sanjay Somnath Malgunde, )

Age: 42 Years, Occ: Agriculture )

6. Shri Rajendar Somnath Malgunde, )

Age: 33 Years, Occ: Agriculture, ) All R/o: Malgunde Vasti, Jalocchi, ) Taluka: Baramati, Dist: Pune )

7. Sou. Rajeshri Umesh Jankar, )

Age: Awareness, Occ: Housewife, ) R/o. Rahmatpur, Taluka: Koregao, Dist. Satara. )

8. Sou. Sharmila Rahul Shah, )

Age: 46 Years, Occ: Housewife/Agriculture, )

9. Shri Soham Rahul Shah, )

Age: 21 Years, Occ: Student )

10. Shri Om Rahul Shah )

Age: 19 Years, Occ: Business and ) Agriculture ) Respondent No. 8 to 10 ) R/o. Dhavalgiri, Cinema Road, ) Baramati, Dist. Pune, Pin Code: 413102 )

11. Kumari Sima Tulsiram Malgunde, )

Age: 25 Years, Occ: Housework, ) R/o. Post. Kothale, Taluka: Malshirsh ) Dist. Solapur )

12. Shri Sangram Jayvantrao Gade )

Age: 42 Years, Occ: Business ) R/o. Akansha Niwas, Amrai, Baramati, ) Dist. Pune, Pin Code: 413102 )

13. Shri Jitesh Rajendra Nigde )

Age: 25 years, Occ: Agriculture, ) R/o at: Rajale, Ta. Phaltan, ) Dist. Satara 415523 )

14. Shri Shailesh Jnardhan Kotmire )

Age 57 years, Occ: Service ) R/o at: Jankushum Banglo, ) Vijay Chok, Akaluj, Ta. Maharashtra, ) Dist. Solapur )

15. Shri Prashant Vinodkumar Shah )

Age: 54 years, Occ: Business )

16. Shri. Shrenik Prashant Shah )

Age: 27 years, Occ: Business, ) Resp. no. 15 & 16 both R/o. At:Station Road, )

Baramati, Ta. Baramati, Dist. Pune ) …Respondents WITH APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 99 OF 2024 WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1156 OF 2024 Shri Nitin Marutrao Kale ) Age. 50 years, Occ: Business, ) R/o. Post: Sansar, Taluka: Indapur, )

Dist. Pune, Pin Code- 413104 ) …Appellant Versus

1. Shri. Dilip Bajirao Malgunde )

Age: 64 Years, Occ: Agriculture, ) R/o. Kole Vasti, Jalocchi, ) Taluka: Baramanti, Dist. Pune )

2. Shri Rahul Javahar Shah )

Age: 45 Years, Occ: Agriculture and ) Business, R/o. Dhavalgiri, Cinema Road, ) Baramati, Dist. Pune, Pin Code 413102 )

3. Seema Tulshiram Malgunde )

Age: 25 years, Occ: Housewife, ) R/o. Post. Kothle, Taluka Malshirash, ) Dist. Solapur, Pin Code: 413107 )

4. Shri Sangram Javantrao Gade )

Age: 42 years, Occ: Business, ) R/o. Akansha Niwas, Amrai, Baramati, )

Dist. Pune, Pin Code 413102 ) …Respondents ******

In AO/1057/2023 Mr. Sushant Prabhune for Appellants.

Mr. Abhijit P. Kulkarni for Respondent Nos. 1 to 6.

Mr. Abhijit P. Kulkarni i/b. Ms. Sweta Shah & Mr. Abhishek Roy for Respondent Nos.8 to 10.

In AO/99/2024 Mr. Sushant Prabhune, for Appellant.

Mr. Abhijit P. Kulkarni for Respondent No. 1.

Mr. Abhijit P. Kulkarni i/b. Mr. Gourav Shahane & Mr. Shreyas Zarkar for Respondent No.2.

*****

CORAM : M. M. SATHAYE, J. DATED : 7^th JANUARY 2025 (In Chamber)

JUDGMENT

1. Learned Counsel for the parties were finally heard on 02/12/2024 and 16/12/2024 and the appeals are kept today for passing order.

BACKGROUND

2. These Appeals arise from two suits filed by plaintiff/s for similar reliefs against two different sets of Defendants. The Appellants are Plaintiffs and the Respondents are Defendants in both the suits. The parties are hereinafter referred to in their original capacity in suits.

3. Appeal from Order No. 1057 of 2023 (AO/1057/2023) is arising out of impugned order dated 02/11/2023 passed by the Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division, Baramati below Exhibit-5 in Special Civil Suit No. 192 of 2021 (SpCS/192/2021). This suit is filed by the Appellants and one Mr. Sangram