IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION (L) NO. 13705 OF 2022

1. Farzin Ardeshir Adel, ) Adult, Indian inhabitant of Mumbai) Occupation : Business and having ) address at M/s. Minoo’s Shop No.8,) Ground Floor, H.M.Petit Widows ) Homes, Building No.225, Junction )

of JSS Road and Babasaheb Jayakar) Marg, Thakurdwar, Mumbai 400 002)

2. Mr.Shapur Rustom Phirozmand) Adult, Indian inhabitant of Mumbai) Occupation : Business and having ) address at )

M/s. Sun Shine Restaurant & Bakery,)

Shop No. 300 - 302, Ground Floor, ) H.M.Petit Widows Homes, ) Building No.225, Junction of ) JSS Road and Babasaheb Jaykar ) Marg, Thakurdwar, ) Mumbai – 400 002 )

3. Rameshchandra Bagatawarmal Jain)

Adult, Indian inhabitant of Mumbai) Occupation : Business and having ) address at ) M/s. Sunrise Metal Industry, ) Shop No.__, Ground Floor, ) H.M.Petit Widows Homes, ) Building No. 225, Junction of JSS )

Road and Babasaheb Jayakar Marg,)

Thakurdwar, Mumbai 400 002 ) 4. Saroj Ramkar Pandey, ) Adult, Indian inhabitant of Mumbai)

Occupation : Business and having ) address at ) M/s.R.K.Hair & Care, Shop No.5, ) Ground Floor, H.M.Petit Widows ) Home, Building No.225, Junction of) JSS Road and Babasaheb Jayakar )

Marg, Thakurdwar, Mumbai 400 002) ….. Petitioners VERSUS

1. Municipal Corporation of Greater)

Mumbai, a body constituted under ) the provisions of Mumbai Municipal)

Corporation Act, 1888, having its ) Head office at Mahapalika Bhavan,) Mahapalika Marg, Opp. C.S.T., ) Mumbai 400 001 ) 2. Assistant Engineer (B&F), ) Municipal Corporation of Greater ) Mumbai, ‘C’ Ward, Office Building,) 76, Shrikant Palekar Marg, )

Near Chandanwadi Electric Cemetery)

Mumbai 400 002 )

3. Assistant Municipal Commissioner,)

Municipal Corporation of Greater ) Mumbai, ‘C’ Ward, Office Building) 76, Shrikant Palekar Marg, )

Near Chandanwadi Electric Cemetery)

Mumbai 400 002 ) 4. Designated Officer and Executive) Engineer (B&F), ) Municipal Corporation of Greater ) Mumbai, ‘C’ Ward, Office Building) 76, Shrikant Palekar Marg, )

Near Chandanwadi Electric Cemetery)

Mumbai 400 002 )

5. The Nesserwanjee Manockjee ) Petit Charity Fund, ) A Public charitable Trust having its) office address at Uco Bank Building) 359, Dr. D.N.Road, Fort, )

Mumbai 400 001 ) ….. Respondents ALONGWITH WRIT PETITION (L) NO. 12803 OF 2022 Jatin Bhankharia ) Aged about 53 years, Occupation : ) Business, proprietor of ) M/s. Bhankharia Tea Co. having ) address at 302, Ground Floor, ) “H.M.Petit Widows Homes”, ) “Building No.225”, C.S.No.2179 of ) Bhuleshwar Division, Junction of ) JSS Road and Babasaheb Jaykar ) Marg, Bhuleshwar Division, )

Thakurdwar, Mumbai – 400 002 ) ….. Petitioner VERSUS

1. The Municipal Corporation of ) Greater Mumbai, )

a body Corporate, duly incorporated)

under the provisions of M.M.C.Act,) 1888, having its office at ) Mahanagar Palika Marg, Mumbai ) 400 001, through its Commissioner,) 2. Assistant Commissioner/ ) Executive Engineer (B&F)/ ) Designated Officer-II, C Ward )

Office Building, 76, Shrikant Palekar)

Marg, Near Chandanvadi Electric ) Cemetery, Mumbai – 400 002 )

3. The Chairperson of TAC, ) Dy.Ch.Engg. (Bldg. Proposal), City,) New Municipal Bldg., Bhagwan )

Walmiki Chowk, Vidyalankar Marg,) Opp. Hanuman Mandir, Antop Hill,) Wadala (E), Mumbai – 400 037 ) 4. The Nesserwanjee Manockjee ) Petit Charity Fund, Trust/Owner/ ) Landlord, ) “H.M.Petit Widows Homes”, ) “Building No.225”, C.S.No.2179 of ) Bhuleshwar Division, Junction of ) JSS Road and Babasaheb Jaykar ) Marg, Bhuleshwar Division, ) Thakurdwar, Mumbai – 400 002 )

5. M/s. Sunshine Restaurant & Bakery,) A partnership firm through its partner)

Mr.Shapur Rustom Phirozmand ) aged 73 yrs., Occupation : Business) at 300, Ground Floor, ) “H.M.Petit Widows Homes”, ) “Building No.225”, C.S.No.2179 of ) Bhuleshwar Division, Junction of ) JSS Road and Babasaheb Jaykar ) Marg, Bhuleshwar Division, )

Thakurdwar, Mumbai – 400 002 ) ….. Respondents Mr.Karl Tamboly, a/w. Mr.Anoshak Daver, Ms.Kausar Banatwala, Mr