HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
BHASKAR SHANKAR PATIL – Appellant
Versus
BANSI KASHIRAM JADHAV – Respondent
SA 67/2011
1 SA 67.2011
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET NO.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
SECOND APPEAL NO. 67 OF 20
11
Office
Notes,Office
Memoranda
of
Coram,appearances,
Court's
orders
or
directions
and
Registrar's orders
Court's or Judge's orders
Mr.S.B.Talekar, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr.G.V.Wani, Advocate for the respondent.
..........................
CORAM : S.V. GANGAPURWALA, J.
DATE : 25/04/2011
PER COURT :
1.
This is the Appeal by the original defendant.
The plaintiff had filed Suit for specific performance
of contract on the basis of agreement of sale dated
22/5/1992. The trial Court dismissed the Suit
holding that the transaction in effect was not that
of agreement of sale. The plaintiff preferred
Appeal. The appellate Court allowed the Appeal
granting decree for specific performance.
Aggrieved thereby, the defendant has filed the
present Appeal.
2.
Mr. S.B.Talekar, the learned counsel for the
appellant submits that the lower appellate court
could not have reversed the finding of fact arrived
2 SA 67.2011
at by the trial Court, which was passed on
appreciation of evidence. It was also contended by
the learned counsel that the plaintiff had claimed
himself to be in possession of the property, but the
lower appellate Court had granted decree for
possession. The learned counsel further contends
that in fact against the order passed by the District
Court, the Appeal from Order was preferred to the
High Court and during the pendency of the same,
amendment was carried out by the plaintiff. When
the Appeal from Order was pending, the lower
appellate court should not have allowed the
amendment. For the said purpose, the learned
counsel relies on the Judgment of the learned
Single Judge of this Court in the case of Kishor
Bhikansingh Rajput V/s Preeti Kishor Rajput
reported in 2007 (3) Bom.C.R. - 279. The
learned counsel contends that there is no evidence
on record to prove the payment of Rs. 45,000/- by
the plaintiff to the defendant. There is
contradictory evidence in this regard, as such the
same could not have been relied. Twice the
plaintiff had made amendment about readyness
and willingness, which shows that the plaintiff was
not ready and willing to perform his part of the
contract. All these anomalies have not been taken
into consideration by the lower appellate Court.
3 SA 67.2011
3.
Per contra, Mr. Wani, the learned counsel
for the respondent submits that in fact the
amendment was made in the plaint seeking relief
of possession. The said amendment was allowed
on 15/2/2006, whereas in Appeal from Order the
stay was granted to the further proceeding on
26/2/2006. According to the learned counsel, the
defendant had deleted his defence of transaction
being the security transaction. As such, the finding
of the trial court about the nature of transaction
become redundant. According to the learned
counsel, the witnesses examined by the plaintiff
have substantiated the case and the Court has
discussed the evidence on record.
4.
With the assistance of the learned counsel
for the respective parties, I have gone through the
Judgments.
5.
The first appellate court is the last fact
finding court., which has got the power of re-
appreciation of evidence in light of Section 107 of
the Code of Civil Procedure. The District Court
has observed that the scribe of the document has
specifically deposed