HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
RATILAL JIVANBHAI LALJI – Appellant
Versus
KUVARBEN WD/O. CHABILDAS PATEL AND ORS – Respondent
WP 7027/2008
dgm
gm
gm
IN
IN
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL
CIVIL
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT
WRIT
WRIT PETITION NO.7027 OF 2008
PETITION NO.7027 OF 2008
PETITION NO.7027 OF 2008
Ratilal son of Jivanbhai Lalji
...Petitioner
Vs.
1(a) Kuvarben wd/o. Chabildas Patel
& others.
...Respondents.
Shri M.P. Vashi for the Petitioner.
Shri Pratap N. Shukla for the Respondents.
CORAM
CORAM
CORAM : ANOOP V.MOHTA, J.
: ANOOP V.MOHTA, J.
: ANOOP V.MOHTA, J.
DATED
DATED
DATED : 10th November, 2008.
: 10th November, 2008.
: 10th November, 2008.
JUDGMENT:
JUDGMENT:
JUDGMENT:
Heard finally by consent.
2. The petitioner/tenant has challenged the exparte
judgment and decree dated 1.7.2003 passed in RAE & R
Suit No.1633/5893 of 1978 and the judgment and order
in Appeal No.104 of 2005 dated 29.08.2008. The
respondents are the legal heirs of deceased Chabildas
Patel, the owner of a chawl having about 27 rooms,
known as Chabildas Chawl, Teli Galli Cross Lane,
Andheri (East), Mumbai-69. The suit room is a single
room tenement admeasuring about 10’x10’ and the rent
of the premises is Rs.19/- exclusive of the permitted
increases.
( 2 )
3. A notice of demand dated 26.09.1978 was issued as
the petitioner was in arrears of rent for more than
112 months. Therefore a Suit in question was filed
for eviction in the Small Causes Court at Mumbai. The
original plaintiff and the defendants expired during
the proceedings. Therefore, the respective heirs are
proceeding with the matter. A written statement, as
well as, an additional written statement are filed.
On 10.11.1995 issues are framed.
4. The petitioner was operated because of eye
infection in the year 1999. His health was also
deteriorating and could not attend the court and
contact his Advocate. He was not aware of the
progress of the Suit. The petitioner has no telephone
at his residence. There was no contact during this
period even with his Advocate. He also could not go
and contact his Advocate for want of intimation.
5. As the petitioner/defendant remained absent and as
there was no cross-examination of the plaintiff, the
trial Court at Bombay, based upon the
examination-in-chief on affidavit and documents
produced on record by the plaintiff, proceeded under
( 3 )
Order XVII, Rule 2 of C.P.C. and passed exparte
decree of eviction of the premises.
6. On 24.06.2004 the bailiff tried to serve the
execution notice which was refused by the wife as she
was not aware of any proceeding. The petitioner,
therefore, as instructed orally, visited the court at
Bandra on 30.06.2004 and waived the service of the
notice and appeared through his Advocate. As the next
date was 13.07.2004 and as the petitioner had
misplaced the paper of Suit, on his request, made an
application for certified copy of the proceeding
through Advocate’s clerk on 2.7.2004.
7. The exparte decree was passed by the Small Causes
Court, Bombay wherein the notice of execution was made
returnable in Small Causes Court at Bandra. The
petitioner appeared at Small Causes Court at Bandra
and applied for certified copy as referred above. A
copy of exparte judgment and decree was annexed with
the said notice and, therefore, came to know about the
date of exparte decree. Page Nos. 4 and 5 of the
said judgment were missing. In the meantime, the
application for notice before execution was heard on
5.02.2005 and dismissed on merits on 22.2.2005.
( 4 )
8. The petitioner and respondents 2 and 3 on
21.02.2005 awaiting for certified copy of the exparte
decree