HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
GANGARAM BHAGWANDAS KAUSHALEY – Appellant
Versus
JYOTI KISHOR SHITOLE AND ANOTHER – Respondent
SA 657/2013
1 S.A. 657.2013.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
SECOND APPEAL NO. 657 OF 2013
Gangaram s/o Bhagwandas Kaushaley ..... APPELLANT
V E R S U S
Sou. Jyoti w/o Kishor Shitole & Anr. ..... RESPONDENTS
.....
Mr. V.P.Latange, Advocate for Appellant.
.....
CORAM : T.V.NALAWADE, J.
DATE : 10th MARCH, 2016
ORDER :-
.
The Appeal is filed by the defendant of R.C.S.
No. 572/2005 which was pending in the Court of Civil Judge
[Sr. Division], Aurangabad. The Suit filed by the present
respondent for relief of specific performance of contract is
decreed in her favour by the trial Court and its decision is
confirmed by the first appellate Court in the Judgment and
decree of R.C.A. No. 83/2008. Heard learned counsel for the
appellant.
2.
Suit was filed in respect of one plot which is
given No. 49 and it is part and parcel of G.No. 28 situated at
2 S.A. 657.2013.odt
Etkheda, Tahsil and district Aurangabad. Area of the plot is
279.74 Sq.Mtrs. Defendant No. 1 is the owner of the land
and he was selling the plots by making development.
Defendant No. 2 was appointed by defendant No. 1 as
General Power of Attorney in connection with this business.
3.
It is the case of the plaintiff that she knew
defendant No. 2 and defendant No. 2 advised her to invest
money by purchasing aforesaid plot. It is contended that the
irrevocable power of attorney given to defendant No. 2 by
defendant No. 1 was shown to her and due to the faith on
defendant No. 2, she agreed to purchase the plot for the
consideration of ` 60,000/-[Rupees Sixty Thousand] on
31/12/1996. It is contended that, on that day, agreement
was executed which was registered after accepting the
consideration of ` 20,000/-[Rupees Twenty Thousand]. It is
contended that it was agreed to complete the formalities and
the defendant No. 1 was to obtain N.A. permission, etc. and
then the sale deed was to be executed in favour of the
plaintiff.
4.
It is the case of the plaintiff that defendant No. 2
then accepted ` 40,000/-, the remaining amount from her
and handed over the possession of the plot to her on
08/10/2002. It is contended that Taba Pawti was executed
in her favour by defendant No. 1 through defendant No. 2. It
is her case that she has fixed name board on the said plot and
she has done wire fencing around this plot and she has made
construction of shed for residence of her watchman.
3 S.A. 657.2013.odt
5.
It is the case of the plaintiff that even when she
had paid entire amount of consideration, defendant No. 1 did
not execute sale deed and he did not inform her about
completion of the formalities like obtaining N.A. order, etc. It
is contended that ultimately she gave legal notice on
06/07/2005 and requested the defendant to perform his part
of the contract. It is contended that defendant No. 1 gave
false reply and she felt that there was collusion between
defendant Nos. 1 and 2. It is her case that defendant Nos. 1
and 2 then tried to interfere in her possession over the suit
property and so she was required to file the Suit. She had
prayed for relief of specific performance of aforesaid contract
and she had also prayed for relief of injunction to protect the
possession.
6.
Defendant No. 1 appeared in the proceeding and
filed Written Statement. Defendant No. 2 did not appear in
the proceeding. Defendant No. 1 admitted that he had
executed agreement and on the date of agreement he had
received consideration of ` 20,000/-. He contended that as
per the agreement, time was essence of contract and plaintiff
was to pay the remaining amount of `