SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1989 Supreme(Online)(Cal) 8

CALCUTTA HIGH COURT
Pratibha Bonnerjea, J.
G. S. Atwal and Co. Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd. (M/s.) v. Hindustan Steel works Construction Ltd.
Matter No. 1268 of 1984



Strict compliance with contractual terms is required for bank guarantees to be enforceable, safeguarding against unauthorized liabilities.

Headnote:(A) Arbitration Act - Section 41 - The dispute pertains to bank guarantees related to mobilisation advance and retention money clauses in construction contracts - The petitioner asserts that the bank guarantees issued were mischaracterized, affecting enforceability - The court highlighted that guarantees must comply strictly with contractual provisions, underscoring that banks must follow client instructions rigorously. (Paras 1-11)

(B) Enforceability of Bank Guarantees - A bank is not obligated to pay if invocation does not conform to the terms of the guarantee, thus safeguarding the principles of formal compliance. (Paras 12-13)

Facts of the case:
The petitioner and respondent entered into contracts for school construction in Libya, involving mobilisation advances and retention money guarantees. Issues arose regarding the interpretation and enforcement of these guarantees under the contract terms.

Findings of Court:
The court determined that the respondent cannot invoke guarantees for purposes other than those explicitly stated, and the interim order to continue until arbitration proceedings are solved.

Issues: Whether the guarantees issued were in line with contractual obligations and if the respondent could lawfully invoke them under the circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi: The court ruled that bank guarantees must strictly adhere to the terms set forth in the contract to be enforceable, protecting the interests of the parties involved.

Result: The interim order made in this application is to continue until disposal of the pending arbitration proceeding.

Table of Content
1. application of arbitration act for dispute on contracts. (Para 1)
2. disputation over the nature of bank guarantees. (Para 2 , 3 , 6)
3. clarification on recovery from guarantees. (Para 4 , 5 , 8)
4. court's determination on strict compliance and enforcement of agreements. (Para 9 , 10 , 11)

1. This is an application under S.41 of the Arbitration Act . The facts of the case are shortly as follows : -
The petitioner and the respondent admittedly entered into eleven contracts whereby the petitioner was to construct eleven schools in Nalut, Libya at the cost of LD. 2,437,525,000. All the contracts were written contracts and all dt. 21-08-79. The contracts contain inter alia two clauses with which this Court is concerned in disposing of the application.
Clause 25.1. - Retention money
a) The Associate shall within the time specified in the Letter of Intent / Letter of acceptance deposit with the principal a further sum in addition to the earnest money paid with the offer to work up to a rate of 1% of the value as initial retention money in cash or Government securities, performance bond by a Bank acceptable to the principal.
b) To this sum shall be added the deductions from the Associates' interim bills for work done as specified under Cl.2.12 hereof, so as to make a total retention of 5% of the contract value as aforesaid.
c) When the retention money reaches a limit of three thousand five hundred Libyan Denars, the Associate, if he so desires, may convert the amount into a Bank guarantee as approved by the principals
d) The retention money shall remain at the entire disposal of the principals as a security for the satisfactory execution and completion of the works in accordance with the conditions of the contract. The principals shall be at liberty to adjust and appropriate from the retention money such penalties and dues as may be payable by the Associate under the contract and the amount by which retention money is reduced by such appropriation will be made good by further deduction from the Associate's subsequent bill's in the manner as aforesaid until the retention money is restored to the full limit mentioned above.
e) On due satisfactory performance and completion of the contract in all respects the retention money will be refunded to the Associate without any interest after passing of the final bill on presentation of an absolute no demand certificate from the Engineer in the prescribed form and up to return in good condition of any specification, drawings, samples or other property belonging to principals which may have been issued to the Associate.
Clause 3.11 - Advance
The Associate shall be paid a mobilisation advance up to a maximum of 5% of the value of the contract after signing of the contract against a bank guarantee in favour of the principal from an approved nationalised bank in India. The advance will be paid in two stages as follows: -
a) A maximum of 20% of the mobilisation advance or 1% of the value of the contract shall be paid in Indian rupees before departure of the Associates and his labourers to Libya. This advance shall be in Indian rupee.
b) The balance 4% of the contract value will be paid in Libya in Libyan Denars after deducting the cost of air - ticket, if any, purchased by the principals for the journey from India to Libya in respect of the Associate, his employees and labour.
c) The recovery of the mobilisation advance paid shall be made in Libyan Denars on pro rata basis increased by 10% from running bills till full amount is recovered so that the recovery of mobilisation advance is recovered by the time 90% of the work is completed.












2. Pursuant to the above terms of the agreement, the respondent paid to the petitioner Rs. 32.50 lakhs by way of mobilisation advance and, as against that the petitioner instructed the United Commercial Bank, No.10, Brabourne Road Branch to issue a Bank guarantee securing repayment of Rs. 32.50 lakhs in favour of the respondent beneficiary, it evident from


















Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top