IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION

APPELLATE SIDE

Before:

The Hon’ble Justice Om Narayan Rai

WPA 11601 of 2025

Ashok Kumar Gorain

-vs.-

The State of West Bengal & Ors.

For the Petitioner : Mr. Sattwik Bhattacharyya, Adv.

Mr. Titas Niyogi, Adv.

Ms. Reshma Sharma, Adv.

Mr. Aritra Ray, Adv.

For the State Respondent : Mr. Amal Kumar Sen, Ld. AGP

Mr. Lal Mohan Basu, Adv.

For the Respondent No. 4 : Ms. Aishwarya Rajyashree, Adv.

Hearing Concluded on : 16.07.2025 Judgment on : 08.08.2025

Om Narayan Rai, J.:-

1. This writ petition assails the refusal on the part of the State Transport

Authority, West Bengal to countersign the renewal of the petitioner’s permit bearing no. PSTS - 14/09 (WB) for his Vehicle No. JH-09AR-0684 in respect of the route Ranchi to Chirkunda (extended up to Asansol) despite the same being forwarded to it by the State Transport Authority, Jharkhand as far

back as on January 21, 2025.

2. Briefly summed up, the case run in the writ petition is as follows: -

a) The petitioner owns a vehicle bearing no. JH-09AR-0684 in respect

whereof he had obtained a Permanent Stage Carriage Permit bearing

no. P.S.TS.No.14/09(WB) from the State Transport Authority, Jharkhand.

b) Such permit was lastly renewed by the said State Transport Authority, Jharkhand on January 16, 2025 for a period of 5 years till January 19, 2029 with effect from January 20, 2024.

c) Having thus renewed the permanent stage carriage permit of the petitioner, the Secretary, State Transport Authority, Jharkhand issued a Memo being Pari-Ayu-1462/2008/STA dated January 16, 2025 to the Secretary State Transport Authority, West Bengal thereby indicating that the permanent stage carriage permit in respect of the petitioner’s vehicle was initially valid till January 19, 2024 and that upon renewal its validity had been extended up to January 19, 2029. By the said letter the Secretary, State Transport Authority, West Bengal was also requested to countersign the said renewed permit.

d) Thereafter on January 21, 2025, the petitioner made an application before the State Transport Authority, West Bengal for countersigning the renewed permit along with the approved time table issued by the State Transport Authority, Jharkhand. The petitioner’s application requesting for such countersignature has been refused by the respondent no. 2 i.e. the Regional Transport Authority and Ex-officio Assistant Director, State Transport Authority, West Bengal by a Memo bearing no. I/610950/2025 dated February 25, 2025 observing as follows: -

“I am directed to request you to collect Additional Tax and M.V. Tax in connection with the subject as mentioned above with effect from 20/01/2024 to 19/01/2029 with fine (Quarterly/Yearly basis), to Tax and Addl. Tax may be paid 01/04/2024 onwards.”

e) Feeling aggrieved by such refusal, the writ petitioner has approached this Court by filing the instant writ petition.

3. The respondent no.3 has filed a Report in the form of an Affidavit whereby the said respondent has sought to justify the demand of tax. In the said report it has been contended that when the permit had originally been issued in the year 2009 by the State Transport Authority, Jharkhand, the same had been duly countersigned by the State Transport Authority, West Bengal and that since the said permit has been renewed on January 16, 2025 for five years with effect from January 20, 2024 till January 19, 2029, therefore, in terms of the proviso to Section 81(1) of the said Act of 1988, the countersignature that was done prior to the date of renewal thereof (i.e. January 16, 2025) would remain effective for the renewed validity period “so as to synchronise with the validity of the primary permit”. Provisions of Sections 6 and 7 of the West Bengal Additional Tax and One Time Tax on Motor Vehicles Act, 1989 (hereafter “the said Additional Tax Act of 1989”)

have also been quoted and relied on in the said report.

4. Mr. Bhattacharya, learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner submitted that the