CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAI.

ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.598/2024 th Date of Decision:4 September,2024 CORAM: Justice M.G. Sewlikar, Member (J)

Shri Santosh Mehra, Member (A)

1.Abdul Rashid M. Naik Office Superintendent (Retired).

D.O.B.: 25.06.1953 (70 years)

Retired from the Office of:

Executive Engineer, Mumbai Central Divn. VIII, CPWD, Nirman Sadan, CGS Colony, Sector-1

3rd floor, Kane Nagar, Mumbai-400 037.

Residing at: B-305, Aysha Apartment, Plot Y 1A, Sector 19, Shahabaj Belapur, Navi Mumbai-400 614.

2.Satish Ramchandra Remulkar, Office Superintendent Gr. II. (Retd.)

D.O.B.: 20.06.1951 (72 years)

Retired from the Office of:

Superintending Engineer (P), WZ-I, C.P.W.D., 16th Floor, Pratistha Bhavan, Mumbai-400 020.

Residing at: JN 4, Bldg. No. 4, Room No. 3, Opp: Sainath High School, Sector-9, Vashi, Navi Mumbai-400 703.

3.Rakesh Kumar Sharma, Assistant Engineer Electrical) (Retd.)

D.O.B.: 05.06.1961 (63 years)

Retired from the Office of:

Executive Engineer (Electrical)

Mumbai-IV, C.P.W.D., Nirman Sadan, 4th floor, Sector-1, C.G.S. Colony, Kane Nagar, Mumbai-400 037.

Residing at: House No. 157, S.No. 5/1, Thorat Niwas, Near Protek Computer, Keshavnagar, Mundhwa, Pune 411 036.

4.Arvind Vasudeo Wani, Deputy Director (Horticulture) (Retd.)

D.O.B.: 07.06.1958 (66 years)

Retired from the Office of:

The Director (Horticulture) (WR)

C.P.W.D., Mumbai 400 037 now Merged with Chief Engineer (Mumbai-1), 14th floor, Pratishta Bhavan

101, M. K. Road, Mumbai 400 020.

Residing at: H-302, Ruturang Society, Phase II, Behind Lokesh Hotel, Sahakar Nagar, Pune 411 009.

5.T. Manoharan, Assistant Engineer (C) (Retired), D.O.B.: 05.06.1954 (70 years)

Retired from the office of The Executive Engineer, Pune Central Division II, C.P.W.D., Mukund Nagar, Pune 411 037.

R/at: C-403, Vastu River Nest, Ravel Village, Near Bondve Lawns, Pune-412 101.

6.Tulshidas P. Gaonkar, M.T.S. (Retired)

D.O.B.: 28.06.1958 (65 years)

Retired from the office of:

The Executive Engineer, Goa Central Division, C.P.W.D., Bambolin-Goa. R/at: Vainginim, Mayem, H. No. 1383, Bicholim-Goa 403 504.

7.Smt. Shali Ramdas Naik Mali Grade III (Retired)

D.O.B.: 02.06.1958 (65 years)

Retired from the office of Dy. Director (Horticulture), Antop Hill, Mumbai-400037 Now merged with Chief Engineer (Mumbai-I)

14th Floor, Pratishta Bhavan, 101, M. K. Road, Mumbai 400 020.

R/at: House No. 361, Near Dabolim Airport, Assoi Dongri, A.P. Dabolim, S.O. South Goa, Goa-403 801.

8.Karunakaran P. Nair, D.O.B.: 15.06.1952 (72 years)

Assistant Engineer (E)(Retired)

Retired from the office of:

The Executive Engineer (E)

Bombay Central Electrical Divn.II, C.P.W.D., Kane Nagar, Mumbai-400 037.

R/at: A-502, Goodwill Paradise, Sector 15, Kharghar, Navi Mumbai - 410 210.

-APPLICANTS (By Advocate Ms.Annie Nadar)

VERSUS

1.

The Union of India through The Secretary, Ministry of Housing &

Urban Affairs, Nirman Bhavan, New Delhi 110 011.

2.

The Special Director

General (W.R.)

C.P.W.D.,16th floor, Pratishtha Bhavan, 101, Maharshi Karve Road, New Marine Lines, Mumbai - 400 020.

3.

The Chief Engineer (Mumbai - 1)

14th Floor, Pratishta Bhavan, 101, M. K. Road, Mumbai 400 020.

4.

The Chief Engineer (Mumbai-2), 4th Floor, New CGO Building, Nishtha Bhavan), New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400 020.

5.

The Executive Engineer (Electrical)

Mumbai IV, C.P.W.D.,4th floor, Nirman Sadan, Sector-1, CGS Colony, Kane Nagar, Mumbai - 400 037.

6.

The Executive Engineer (Electrical), Bombay Central Electrical Division-II, C.P.W.D., Kane Nagar, Mumbai-400 037.

7.

The Executive Engineer, Mumbai Central Division VIII, C.P.W.D. Nirman Sadan, Kane Nagar, Mumbai - 400 037.

8.

The Executive Engineer, Goa Central Division, Central P.W.D., Bambolim - Goa.

9.

The Pay & Accounts Officer, Central P.W.D., (WZ), Ministry of Housing &

Urban Affairs, 18th floor, CGO Annex, 101 M.K. Road, New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400 020.

Respondents ...

( By Advocate Mr. N.K.Rajpurohit)

ORDER (Oral)

Per: Justice M.G. Sewlikar, Member (J)

We have heard learned counsel for the applicants and learned counsel for the respondents.