Central Administrative Tribunal Mumbai Bench, camp at Nagpur Contempt Petition No. 138/2024, Contempt Petition No. 139/2024 &

Contempt Petition No. 193/2024 Order reserved on :13/01/2026 Order dated : 16/01/2026 Coram :

Hon’ble Mr. Shri Krishna, Member (A)

Hon’ble Mr. Umesh Gajankush, Member (J)

C.P.No. 138/2024

1. Shri Mukunda Budharam Shiwarkar, Desig.: Highly Skilled Grade-II (Retired), Age: 69 yrs., R/o Rajiv Gandhi Nagar, Ward No. 4, Wadala (Paiku) Taluka & Post: Chimur, Distt.: Chandrapur - 442 501.

2. Shri Dadaji Shankar Bawane, Desig.: Highly Skilled Grade-II (Retired), Age: 70 yrs., R/o Shrikrishna Nagar, Sumthana, Ward No. 10, Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur - 442 501.

3. Shri Nathhuji Baburao Dhengle, Desig.: Highly Skilled Gr.-II (Retired), Age: 69 yrs., R/o Killaward, Near Bagdewadi, Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur-442 501.

4. Shri Arun Mahadeorao Nagpure, H. S. Gr.-II (Retired), Age: 65 yrs., R/o Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur-

442 501.

5. Shri Pandurang Jairam Navghare, H. S. Gr.-II (Retired),

Age: 65 yrs., R/o Near Ali Petrol Pump, Kunbi Society,

Chichordi, Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur - 442 501.

6. Shri Motiram Ramchandra Navghare (Deceased), Age: 68 yrs., Design.: Highly Skilled Grade-II (Retired), Through: L.R.: Smt. Latabai Wd./o Motiram Navghare, R/o Ahilyyadevi Nagar, Chichordi, Taluka: Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur - 442 902.

7. Shri M. B. Tathe, Desig.: H. S. Grade-II (Retired), Age: 62 yrs., R/o Bhoj Ward, Taluka: Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur - 442 501.

…..Applicant (By Adv: Shri M.G. Burde)

Versus

1. Shri Sudhir Srivastava, The Director General of Ordnance (Coordination & Services), Ayudh Bhawan, 10-A, S. K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700 001 (W.B.).

2. Shri Bijoy Kumar, The General Manger, Ordnance Factory Chanda, a Unit of Munitions India Ltd., Taluka: Tah.:

Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur - 442 501.

.... Respondents (By Adv: Shri Bhaskar D. Pandit )

C.P.No. 139/2024 Shri Deorao Maroti Datarkar, Desig.: Skilled (Retired), Age: 70 yrs., R/o Gautam Nagar, Near Z. P. School, Chandrapur -442 501.

…..Applicant

(By Adv: Shri M.G. Burde)

Versus

1. Shri Sudhir Srivastava, The Director General of Ordnance (Coordination & Services), Ayudh Bhawan, 10-A, S. K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700 001 (W.B.).

2. Shri Bijoy Kumar, The General Manger, Ordnance Factory Chanda, a Unit of Munitions India Ltd., Taluka: Tah.:

Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur - 442 501.

.... Respondents (By Adv: Shri Bhaskar D. Pandit )

C.P. No. 193/2024 Shri C. P. Idnur.

Desig.: Master craftsman (Retired), Age: 64 yrs., R/o New Piperbodi, Tahsil: Bhadrawati, Post: O. F. Estate Bhadrawati, Chandrapur - 442 501. Mobile No.:

7823019686. …..Applicant (By Adv: Shri M.G. Burde)

Versus

1. Shri Sudhir Srivastava, The Director General of Ordnance (Coordination & Services), Ayudh Bhawan, 10-A, S. K. Bose Road, 2. Shri Bijoy Kumar, The General Manger, Ordnance Factory Chanda, a Unit of Munitions India Ltd., Taluka: Tah.:

Bhadrawati, Distt.: Chandrapur - 442 501.

.... Respondents (By Adv: Shri Bhaskar D. Pandit )

ORDER

Per : Umesh Gajankush, Member (J)

This order shall govern disposal of CP No. 138/2024, CP No. 139/2024 and CP No. 193/2024 as non-compliance is alleged in respect of common order dated 20.07.2010 in O.A. No. 2199/2009 and learned counsel for the parties have argued on CP No. 139/2024, therefore, facts of said case are taken into consideration while passing this order.

2. The present C.P. has been filed by the applicant alleging non-compliance of the of prayer at para 8(A1) in O.A. No. 2199/2009 inter-alia by this Tribunal by which this Tribunal, in its common order dated 20.07.2010, has granted the following relief in favour of the applicant, relevant extract is as under:

“(1A) That the impugned order of the Respondent No. 3, which

granted ACP-II w.e.f. 05.03.2008 vide F.O. Part-2 No. 1269

dated 18.03.2008 in the Pay Scale of Skilled Grade i.e. Rs. 3050-4590 (Annex. A8a) also be set aside and ACP-II be granted w.e.f. 05.03.2008 in the Pay Scale of Highly Skilled Grade i.e.

Rs. 4000-6000"

3.