Back
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PATNA BENCH PATNA O.A. 050/00898/2016 Reserved on : 14.01.2026 Pronounced on : 03.02.2026 Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Narendra Kumar Johari, Judicial Member Hon’ble Mr. Kumar Rajesh Chandra, Administrative Member In the matter of :
Rajnee Kant Pandey, Son of Sri Badri Nath Pandey, resident of Village- Kaithee, Post- Tetradh, PS- Akodhigola, District- Rohtas at Sasaram, Bihar. At present 1st Floor, Bank of India, Main Road, Patratu, PS- Patratu, District- Hazaribagh, (Jharkhand).
………….Applicant VS.
11. The Union of India through the Chairman, Railway Board, Ministry of Railways, Rail Bhawan, New Delhi.
22. The General Manager, E. C. Railway, Hajipur (Bihar).
33. The General Manager (P), E. C. Railway, Hajipur (Bihar).
44. The Chief Personnel Officer, E. C. Railway, Hajipur (Bihar). 5. The Divisional Railway Manager, E. C. Railway, Dhanbad Railway Division, Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
66. The Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, E. C. Railway, Dhanbad Railway Division, Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
77. The Senior Divisional Mechanical Engineer, (Power), E. C.
Railway, Dhanbad Railway Division, Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
88. The Senior Divisional Electrical Engineer (OP), E. C.
Railway, Dhanbad Railway Division, Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
99. Ravi Kumar (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
1010. Prem Prakash (SC) Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
SONALI D D i N g : it a C l = y I N si , g O ne = d P e b r y s o S n O a N l, A T L = I 0 L 5 A 7 L 2, OID.2.5.4.65=
1335963617493834803xeKNGD5eN7bXL, Phone=
d55227c56413c0574ef7e92b84fad3fa8644c2a67fb01f9970 cce81465079777, PostalCode=800009, S=Bihar, SERIALNUMBER=
b85cadb360af4981732c949bc31df6d98e2c92428456adc53 L AL 3 R a e d a e s 9 o e n 3 : 8 I d a 5 tt a e e s d t 9 to 6 , t h C e N a = c S c O ur N ac A y L I a L n A d
11. Rajesh Pratap Ranjan (SC), Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu (Jharkhand).
12. Sanjay Kumar Rajak (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
13. Amit Kumar (SC), Sr. ALP/E/ PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
14. Aniket Shanti Toppo (ST), Sr. ALP/E/ KLRE, Khelari under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Khelari, (Jharkhand).
15. Vikas Kumar Chaudhary (SC), Sr. ALP/E/DHN, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Bawadih, (Jharkhand).
16. Rakesh Kumar (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
17. Uday Pratap Toppo (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRKA, Barkakana under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barkakana, (Jharkhand).
18. Sanjay Lakra (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRKA, Barkakana under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barkakana, (Jharkhand).
19. Anmol Ekka (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRKA, Barkakana under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barkakana, (Jharkhand).
20. Vincent Dong (ST), Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
21. Jansay Toppo (ST), Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
22. Marcus Tirkey (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRWD, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
23. Dinesh Chandra Das (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
24. Krishna Kumar Das (SC), Sr. ALP/E/BRKA, Barkakana under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barkakana, (Jharkhand).
25. Anup Tirkey (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRWD, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
26. Nixon Bara (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRWD, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
SONALI D D i N g : it a C l = y I N si , g O ne = d P e b r y s o S n O a N l, A T L = I 0 L 5 A 7 L 2, OID.2.5.4.65=
1335963617493834803xeKNGD5eN7bXL, Phone=
d55227c56413c0574ef7e92b84fad3fa8644c2a67fb01f9970 cce81465079777, PostalCode=800009, S=Bihar, SERIALNUMBER=
b85cadb360af4981732c949bc31df6d98e2c92428456adc53 L AL 3 R a e d a e s 9 o e n 3 : 8 I d a 5 tt a e e s d t 9 to 6 , t h C e N a = c S c O ur N ac A y L I a L n A d
27. Shiv Kumar Lakra (ST), Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
28. Rajadhan Kumar Ram (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
29. Anup Kujur (SC), Sr. ALP/E/BRWD, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
30. Virendra Pratap Sonkar (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
........ Respondents For The Applicant(s): Mr. Nityanand Mishra, Counsel For The Respondent(s): Mr. Sujeet Kumar Sinha, ASC Mr. M. P. Dixit, Private Respondents
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PATNA BENCH PATNA O.A. 050/00898/2016 Reserved on : 14.01.2026 Pronounced on : 03.02.2026 Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Narendra Kumar Johari, Judicial Member Hon’ble Mr. Kumar Rajesh Chandra, Administrative Member In the matter of :
Rajnee Kant Pandey, Son of Sri Badri Nath Pandey, resident of Village- Kaithee, Post- Tetradh, PS- Akodhigola, District- Rohtas at Sasaram, Bihar. At present 1st Floor, Bank of India, Main Road, Patratu, PS- Patratu, District- Hazaribagh, (Jharkhand).
………….Applicant VS.
11. The Union of India through the Chairman, Railway Board, Ministry of Railways, Rail Bhawan, New Delhi.
22. The General Manager, E. C. Railway, Hajipur (Bihar).
33. The General Manager (P), E. C. Railway, Hajipur (Bihar).
44. The Chief Personnel Officer, E. C. Railway, Hajipur (Bihar). 5. The Divisional Railway Manager, E. C. Railway, Dhanbad Railway Division, Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
66. The Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, E. C. Railway, Dhanbad Railway Division, Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
77. The Senior Divisional Mechanical Engineer, (Power), E. C.
Railway, Dhanbad Railway Division, Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
88. The Senior Divisional Electrical Engineer (OP), E. C.
Railway, Dhanbad Railway Division, Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
99. Ravi Kumar (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
1010. Prem Prakash (SC) Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
11. Rajesh Pratap Ranjan (SC), Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu (Jharkhand).
12. Sanjay Kumar Rajak (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
13. Amit Kumar (SC), Sr. ALP/E/ PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
14. Aniket Shanti Toppo (ST), Sr. ALP/E/ KLRE, Khelari under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Khelari, (Jharkhand).
15. Vikas Kumar Chaudhary (SC), Sr. ALP/E/DHN, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Bawadih, (Jharkhand).
16. Rakesh Kumar (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
17. Uday Pratap Toppo (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRKA, Barkakana under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barkakana, (Jharkhand).
18. Sanjay Lakra (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRKA, Barkakana under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barkakana, (Jharkhand).
19. Anmol Ekka (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRKA, Barkakana under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barkakana, (Jharkhand).
20. Vincent Dong (ST), Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
21. Jansay Toppo (ST), Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
22. Marcus Tirkey (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRWD, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
23. Dinesh Chandra Das (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
24. Krishna Kumar Das (SC), Sr. ALP/E/BRKA, Barkakana under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Barkakana, (Jharkhand).
25. Anup Tirkey (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRWD, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
26. Nixon Bara (ST), Sr. ALP/E/BRWD, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
27. Shiv Kumar Lakra (ST), Sr. ALP/E/PTRU, Patratu under Chief Crew Controller, E. C. Railway, Patratu, (Jharkhand).
28. Rajadhan Kumar Ram (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
29. Anup Kujur (SC), Sr. ALP/E/BRWD, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
30. Virendra Pratap Sonkar (SC), Sr. ALP/E/GMO, Barwadih under Chief Crew Controller, East Central Railway, Barwadih, (Jharkhand).
........ Respondents For The Applicant(s): Mr. Nityanand Mishra, Counsel For The Respondent(s): Mr. Sujeet Kumar Sinha, ASC Mr. M. P. Dixit, Private Respondents
O R D E R
Per : Kumar Rajesh Chandra, Administrative Member
1.The Applicant has approached this Tribunal under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 praying for the following relief:
“8.1 For setting aside the order dated 17.11.2016 so far respondent no. 9 to 30 is concerned, issued vide Docket No. 7/EL/ELP/Goods/Arrgt. Dhanbad, by the Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, E. C. Railway Division, Dhanbad, they are junior to the applicant were/ are promoted to the post of ELP(Goods) in the P.B. Rs. 9300-34800+ GP 4200/- applying the principle of Reservation.
8.2 For further direction to the respondents to the restrain them from applying the principle of reservation while making the proposed promotions to the posts of Loco Pilot (Goods) in PB 9300-34800 in GP4200/- in Dhanbad Division of East Central Railway as notified vide Notification dated 17.11.2016.
8.3 For further direction to the respondents to make the proposed promotions, strictly on the basis of seniority-cum-suitability, as per the common cadre seniority of the candidates, as reflected in the seniority list of the Assistant Loco Pilot/ Goods and Senior Assistant Loco Pilot/ Diesel, in the Mechanical Department of the Dhanbad Division of East Central Railway, irrespective of their caste or tribe status and, last, but not the least to make the proposed promotions.
8.4 For any other relief/ reliefs for which the applicant is entitled to.”
2. For the sake of clarity, facts in the case as stated by the applicant in his OA, are delineated and discussed herein under :-
The applicant initially joined the Railway service as Assistant Loco Pilot (Electrical) on 12.10.2009 under the Chief Crew Controller, Patratu, Dhanbad Division.
A Provisional Seniority List of Assistant Loco Pilot (E) was issued vide letter dated 28.10.2011. In the said seniority list, the applicant’s name appeared at Serial No. 464. In the same seniority list, Private Respondent Nos. 9 to 12 appeared at Serial Nos. 493, 494, 500 and 503 respectively, i.e., much below the applicant, thereby making them admittedly junior to the applicant. Consequently, Private Respondent Nos. 9 to 30 are junior to the applicant in the feeder cadre.
In the year 2012, a cadre restructuring of Assistant Loco Pilot (Electrical) was undertaken, pursuant to which Private Respondent Nos. 9 to 30, though junior to the applicant, were promoted to the post of Senior Assistant Loco Pilot (Electrical). Subsequently, the applicant and other unreserved category candidates were also promoted to the post of Senior Assistant Loco Pilot (Electrical) on 18.01.2013. A fresh seniority list of Senior Assistant Loco Pilot (E) was prepared, wherein the applicant was placed at Serial No. 255, while Private Respondent Nos. 9 to 30 were placed below him at Serial No. 256 onwards. Despite the above settled seniority position, the official respondents issued an eligibility list dated 17.11.2016, proposing promotions to the post of Electric Loco Pilot (Goods) in Pay Band Rs. 9300–34800 with Grade Pay Rs. 4200. In the said eligibility list, SC/ST candidates junior to the applicant (Private Respondent Nos. 9 to 30) were included for promotion by applying the principle of reservation in promotion, whereas the applicant, though senior and eligible, was excluded.
The applicant immediately submitted representations dated 12.09.2016, 20.09.2016 and 26.09.2016, but no corrective action was taken by the respondents. Although no final select panel has yet been issued and no promotions have been effected, the official respondents are proceeding to send junior SC/ST candidates for pre-promotional training, which would culminate in their promotion, thereby presenting the applicant with a fait accompli.
3. Learned Counsel for the applicant submits that promotion to the post of ELP (Goods) is governed by the principle of seniority-cum- suitability, i.e., a non-selection method, where merit plays no role beyond fitness. The last published and undisputed seniority lists
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
