##PAGE1##

1 O.A. No. 350/1272/2024

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

KOLKATA BENCH, KOLKATA

O.A. No. 350/1272/2024

M.A. No. 350/493/2025

Date of Hearing: 11.11.2025

Date of Order : 23.12.2025

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Anindo Majumdar, Administrative Member

Hon’ble Mr. Diwakar Singh, Judicial Member

In the matter of :

1. Shri Kowshik Chatterjee, Son of Shibom

Chatterjee, working as Tax Assistant in the

office of the Chief Commissioner of Income

Tax-6, Kolkata Aayakar Bhawan, Kolkata-

700069, residing at Village : Apurbapur,

PO: Singur, Dist: Hooghly, PIN: 712409.

2. Smt. Rajashree Chakraborty, daughter

of Pradyumna Chakraborty working as Tax

Assistant under the Principle Chief

Commissioner of Income Tax, West

Bengal & Sikkim, Aayakar Bhavan, VU-1,

Kolkata 3, Government Place West,

Kolkata 700001, residing at 423, Bonamali

Banerjee Road, Kolkata-700082.

3. Shri Saranya Ray, son of Late Aloke

Kumar Ray working as Tax Assistant under

the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax

(AU)-6, Kolkata, Station Midnapore at

Tamluk, Purba Mednipur, residing at

Village: Irhpala,, Police Station -Ghatal,

Dist: Paschim Medinipur, PIN-721222.

......... Applicants

-Versus-

1). The Union of India, service through

the Secretary Department of Revenue,

Ministry of Finance, North Block, New

Delhi 110070. E-mail: secy-fs@nic.in

2). The Chairman, Central Board of

Direct Tax, North Block, New Delhi -

110070.

3). The Principal Chief Commissioner of

Income Tax, West Bengal & Sikkim,

Aaykar Bhawan, P-7 Chowringhee

Square, Kolkata - 700069.

U HT K JA HR ASDD1d0S8aRLDF395 70 o oEiN e ag 3b8 7d c xa tR:i ea i53b 0ct s taC I : 7 t972 2A o Pil o2= e4dc d ny L Dn08 7I41 8 : NN s :2F0 172 9 I i U , 51 d 36 5g a RO .6 dM10 fn m 18 e9 724e= 2Bf ab d6e 8dP t .E h d36 062 d eb e e1R5 a82 9ry r d ,s74 e= a 0 o Ve CU 19 5 u 0n ,51 4 etNT : h 0a P46 f rK =6 so 0lp1o, 7UA ir :oy6sT 4bR oTS nte 8= a 1 fK :4S d +5 l d tC 2b3 AH h 01 9 0eT o iR 56 f s 24J d5 '5 c S 3H 43 de4 3, 0H .7 o=8A 6O 3'4 c h 8 8 .JI 0u5J 1D bHm4k 2 b. AY42 0 1 e3.S 0 b n5 c1, a t. e4 ,P c b. S 7h6 9 1=o5 d 7Bn= c 2e i6h b=ba 76r b,c 88 89 67 4b 19 db

2 O.A. No. 350/1272/2024

4). The Commissioner of Income Tax

(Admn & TPS), Kolkata, Aaykar

Bhawan, P-7 Chowringhee Square,

Kolkata - 700069.

5). The Additional Commissioner of

Income Tax, Hqrs. (Pers & Estt)

Kolkata, Aaykar Bhawan, P-7

Chowringhee Square, Kolkata -700069.

6). The Deputy Commissioner of

Income Tax, Hqrs. (Pers & Estt)

Kolkata/Joint Commissioner of Income

Tax, Hqrs. (Pers & Estt) Kolkata,

Aaykar Bhawan, P-7 Chowringhee

Square, Kolkata 700069.

….Respondents

7). Sri Arindam Bhadra working for gain

to the post of Tax Assistant in the office

of the Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-

9, Kolkata/Aayakar Seva Kendra,

Aayakar Bhawan Dakshin, 2, Gariahat

Road, Jodpur Park, Kolkata 700031.

Email-arindam.bhadra@incomefax.go

v.in

8). Priyadarshaini Mazumder working

for gain to the post of Tax Assistant in

the office of CIT(Audit)-1, Kolkata,

Aayakar Bhawan, P-7, Chowringhee

Square, Kolkata-700069.

....Private Respondents

For The Applicant(s): Mr. B. P. Manna, Ms. G. Roy,

Mr. R. Kundu; Counsel

For The Applicant(s) in the M.A. : Mr. P. C. Das; Counsel

For The Respondent(s): Mr. P. Bajpayee, Mr. C. Sinha; Counsel

U HT K JA HR ASDD1d0S8aRLDF395 70 o oEiN e ag 3b8 7d c xa tR:i ea i53b 0ct s taC I : 7 t972 2A o Pil o2= e4dc d ny L Dn08 7I41 8 : NN s :2F0 172 9 I i U , 51 d 36 5g a RO .6 dM10 fn m 18 e9 724e= 2Bf ab d6e 8dP t .E h d36 062 d eb e e1R5 a82 9ry r d ,s74 e= a 0 o Ve CU 19 5 u 0n ,51 4 etNT : h 0a P46 f rK =6 so 0lp1o, 7UA ir :oy6sT 4bR oTS nte 8= a 1 fK :4S d +5 l d tC 2b3 AH h 01 9 0eT o iR 56 f s 24J d5 '5 c S 3H 43 de4 3, 0H .7 o=8A 6O 3'4 c h 8 8 .JI 0u5J 1D bHm4k 2 b. AY42 0 1 e3.S 0 b n5 c1, a t. e4 ,P c b. S 7h6 9 1=o5 d 7Bn= c 2e i6h b=ba 76r b,c 88 89 67 4b 19 db

3 O.A. No. 350/1272/2024

O R D E R

Per: Mr. Diwakar Singh, Member (J)

The applicants have filed this original application under

Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunal Act, 1985 seeking the

following relief(s):

“a). An order to quash, cancel and withdraw