SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(Online)(CAT) 14464

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
Neeha Falak – Appellant
Versus
Health And Medical Education Department – Respondent
O.A./500/2024



CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL SRINAGAR BENCH, SRINAGAR th (Srinagar, 18 of December 2025)

C O R A M HON’BLE MR. M.S. LATIF, MEMBER (JUDL.)

HON’BLE MR. PRASANT KUMAR, MEMBER (ADMN.)

............

1. Neeha Falak, Aged about 24 years, D/o Farooq Ahmad Shergojorey, R/o Aglar Chirat, Shopian, Pin Code 192305.

............. Applicant.

By Advocate Mr. Suhaib F. Bandey.

AB P H U IS N H IA EK DDDebb7RLDF 5295 o o iNe e a g d596 c x p a t :i ea i 2aee t a s t aC : t 32abo r P i l o2 =tc,1,n y m D n0 2 I P8C: N s :2 e F 3 e I o N i , 5 n6 4 g a s R = O . ta 8 n t m 1 a A e oe 3 e= 2 l a B f6C5 dC t . h d2 Pd 1H o eb e e2 c b e d I ny r 4 S5 r a e 1 ts3 V Ar 2Hu = 3 aof 3 e B t 6 : E 1 ln h 4 a r c9 HA K n s o 5 3 90 i e Id r :o b S d P 1 0 lm o n 7 e 1 0 H U A f : c i 9 + 1 nE n Nt 0 2 5 h , 0 id K 1 s 0 I 9 i S 5 A s t b 2 Tf ' r = P 3 2 8 a 5 d r J 0 d U a 8 t . o i 2 a ' 4 vi 5 N c n . me e 6 0 u i I n1 A 1 m m Tg4 5 r e u ,1 e i b n Pd 1A u t 6h 4n n ao 7d a 4n 0 l K4 e 1 S 3= a0 r bsa in ehe a 8md g b 9i a r0 2, r 8 b S B 6 aE3 e 1R0 n b 3 c dIA h b 9 , L9 7 O N9 8 2 9U U d 8M = 6 a 4Bd 0 7Ee fR8 7 b= Versus

1. Union Territory of J&K Through Commissioner/ Secretary Health and Medical Education Department, Civil Secretariat, Srinagar/ Jammu, Pin Code 190001.

2. J&K Services Selection Board, Srinagar. Through its Secretary, Zam-Zam Complex, Rambagh Srinagar. Pin Code:

190001

3. Suraya Maqbool Ahanger D/o Mohd Maqbool Ahanger Through Respondent No. 1 ........... Respondents.

By Advocate Mr. Syed Musaib, DAG.

ORDER (Oral)

Per Hon’ble Mr. Prasant Kumar, Member (Admn.) The instant O.A. is filed by the applicant before this Tribunal by way of which she has sought for the following reliefs:

a. Issue an appropriate order or direction setting aside the impugned order bearing No. 93-SSB of 2023, dated 04.05.2023, issued by Respondent Services Selection Board, in terms of which the candidature of the Applicant for consideration against the post of Junior Staff Nurse/Junior Grade Nurse, under OSC category, has illegally and arbitrarily been rejected b. Issue an appropriate order or direction setting aside the impugned selection list bearing No. SSB/Sel/Secy/2022- 23/283-92 22.02.2023, to the extent it excludes the name of Applicant from being considered for selection against the post of Junior Staff Nurse/Junior Grade Nurse in the Respondent Department.

c. Issue an appropriate order or direction commanding the respondent Board to forward the recommendation of the AB P H U IS N H IA EK DDDebb7RLDF 5295 o o iNe e a g d596 c x p a t :i ea i 2aee t a s t aC : t 32abo r P i l o2 =tc,1,n y m D n0 2 I P8C: N s :2 e F 3 e I o N i , 5 n6 4 g a s R = O . ta 8 n t m 1 a A e oe 3 e= 2 l a B f6C5 dC t . h d2 Pd 1H o eb e e2 c b e d I ny r 4 S5 r a e 1 ts3 V Ar 2Hu = 3 aof 3 e B t 6 : E 1 ln h 4 a r c9 HA K n s o 5 3 90 i e Id r :o b S d P 1 0 lm o n 7 e 1 0 H U A f : c i 9 + 1 nE n Nt 0 2 5 h , 0 id K 1 s 0 I 9 i S 5 A s t b 2 Tf ' r = P 3 2 8 a 5 d r J 0 d U a 8 t . o i 2 a ' 4 vi 5 N c n . me e 6 0 u i I n1 A 1 m m Tg4 5 r e u ,1 e i b n Pd 1A u t 6h 4n n ao 7d a 4n 0 l K4 e 1 S 3= a0 r bsa in ehe a 8md g b 9i a r0 2, r 8 b S B 6 aE3 e 1R0 n b 3 c dIA h b 9 , L9 7 O N9 8 2 9U U d 8M = 6 a 4Bd 0 7Ee fR8 7 b= A N p u p rs li e c a g n iv t e f n o r t h t e h e f a p c o t s t t h a o t f t J h u e n i a o p r p S li t c a a f n f t N i u s r f s u e l / ly Ju e n n io ti r t le G d ra f d o e r the same having figured in the provisional selection list and also having in her possession a valid OSC category certificate.

d. In the alternative, appropriate order or direction be issued to the Respondents to forward the recommendation of the Applicant for the post of Junior Staff Nurse/Junior Grade Nurse, under Open Merit category, on the basis of her merit and suitability, coupled with the fact that the Respondent Board had already considered her candidature under the said category vide the impugned order bearing No. 93-SSB of 2023, dated 04.05.2023.

e. Consequently, direct the

Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top