SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(Online)(CAT) 10986

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCH: MUMBAI
M.G. Sewlikar, J, Sangam Narain Srivastava, A
Girish Bhikaji Tilve – Appellant
Versus
Central Excise And Customs – Respondent
OA No. 284/2023



Important Points

Mere negligence, carelessness, or error of judgment in the performance of official duties does not amount to misconduct unless the employee is charged with an improper motive, malafides, or moral turpitude.

Subject

Service Law - Disciplinary Proceedings

Act Referred

Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1964: R.3(1)(ii)
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965: R.16
Courier Import & Export (Clearance) Regulation 1998: Reg.13(b), Reg.13(c)

Headnote

(A) Misconduct - Definition - Mere negligence, carelessness, or error of judgment in the performance of official duties does not constitute misconduct unless it is accompanied by an improper motive, malafides, or moral turpitude. (Para 14, 17)

(B) Judicial Review - Scope of Interference - The Tribunal may interfere with a disciplinary order if a bare reading of the chargesheet reveals that no charge of misconduct is made out, even if the procedural requirements of the inquiry were met. (Para 18)

Issues: Whether mere negligence in conducting an investigation, without any imputed motive, amounts to misconduct under the Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules, 1964.

Advocates:
For the Appellants/Petitioners: S.D. Deshpande
For the Respondents: Sachin Patil

ORDER

Per: Justice M.G. Sewlikar, Member (J)

The applicant has filed this application challenging the Order dated 22nd September, 2022 of Disciplinary Authority imposing punishment of reduction to a lower stage in the time scale of pay by (01) one stage for a period of one (01) year, without cumulative effect and not adversely affecting his pension.

The applicant on the day of the incident was working as Superintendent (Preventive), (now Assistant Commissioner), was posted in Head Quarter Intelligence unit (HQIU) of R&I Division of Customs Preventive Commissionerate from February, 2011 till April, 2013 as Superintendent of Customs (Preventive) and he was holding additional charge as Superintendent (Preventive) in Airport Preventive Unit (APU) of the same Commissionerate, during the period from November, 2012 (approx.) till April, 2013 along with his regular charge of HQIU.

The applicant contends that he was investigating a case wherein 35 consignments were booked through courier mode containing goods which were in trade quantity and the description and value were mis-declared.

It is further alleged that on 31st August, 2018, the applicant was Served with the chargesheet levelling following charges:-

ARTICLE OF CHARGE I:

Shri Girish Bhikaji Tilve, the then Superintendent (Prev.) (now Asst. Commissioner). was posted in Head Quarter Intelligence unit (HQIU) of R & I Division of Customs Preventive Commissionerate from Feb 2011 till April 2013 as Superintendent of Customs (Preventive) and he was holding additional charge as Superintendent (Preventive) in Airport Preventive Unit (APU) of the same Commissionerate, during the period from Nov 2012 (approx.) till April 2013 along with his regular charge of HQIU. In the Air Port Preventive Unit (APU) he was assigned the job of gathering intelligence, detection of custom duty evasion cases, preliminary investigation and other case file related work. He was investigating a case covered under F.NO.SD/INT/APU/MISC/14/2013 and F.NO.SD/INT/APU/13/2013, wherein 35 consignments were booked through courier mode containing goods which were in trade quantity and the description and value were misdeclared, and were consigned to people all over India, the address of whom were suspected to be fictitious/non-existent.

Shri Girish Bhikaji Tilve, the then SUPERINTENDENT (Prev.) (now Asstt.Commissioner) who was investigating the said case failed to report in writing in the file to his Deputy Commissioner about the progress of the investigation case. He also failed to suggest the course of investigation and to seek direction for the furtherance of investigation as and when required. He also failed to put up evidences that came up during the investigation on record and to ensure that the data was called for as required for the investigation was received, placed on record and scrutinized in a manner that would help the investigation to arrive at a conclusion. As a case of attempted smuggling was being investigated he failed to focus on exposing the modus operandi of the case, to pin down the master mind and bring the perpetrator to book so that the presence of the APU served as a deterring force to acts of smuggling. As the investigation did not reach a logical conclusion, and as relevant lines of inquiry with regard to the role of the courier M/s Trade Star Experss and it’s Proprietor Shri Fohad Latiwala, were not followed, no penalty was levied by the Adjudicating authority on the said courier and it’s proprietor. Shri Girish Bhikaji Tilve, the then Superintendent (Prev.) (now Asstt.Commissioner), as such failed to maintain devotion to duty and thereby violated Rule 3 (1) (ii) of the Central Civil Service (conduct) Rules, 1964.

Inquiry was conducted. The Inquiry Officer exonerated the applicant of the aforesaid charge. The Disciplinary Authority disagreed with the report of the inquiry officer and served disagreement note on the applicant. The applicant replied to it. The Disciplinary Aut

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top