Central Administrative Tribunal

Principal Bench, New Delhi

O.A.No.3738/2016

Thursday, this the 20^th day of December 2018

Hon’ble Mr. Justice L. Narasimha Reddy, Chairman

Hon’ble Mr. K.N. Shrivastava, Member (A)

1. Balraj Singh Jaswal s/o late K R S Jaswal

Age 54 years

r/o C-4-G, Flat No.81-B

Janakpuri, New Delhi – 110 058

2. Chandra Pal Singh s/o late Devi Singh

Aged 57 years

r/o B/203, Lotus Apartment

Street No.3, Mahaveer Enclave

Palam, Dabri Road

New Delhi – 110 045

3. Surendra Singh Yadav s/o late Awadh Ram

Age 59 years

r/o 11-A, Nilgiri-III

Sector 34, NOIDA, UP

4. Kanwar Pal Singh s/o late Shyam Sunder

Age 56 years

r/o 11-B, Nilgiri-III

Sector 34, Noida 201301 (UP)\

5. Govind Kumar Gupta s/o Shri Laxman Prasad Gutpa

Age 56 years

r/o flat No.D-2002

Sethi Max Royal

Sector 76, Noida 201301

6. Chandra Bhushan Shrivastava

s/o late Ramesh Prasad

age 59 years

r/o Flat No.2A, Block 2

Southern Breeze

1266, Upen Banerjee Road

Kolkata – 700 060

7. Ashok Kumar Singh s/o Shri Prithvi Pal Singh

Age 56 years

c/o Mrs. Bharti Ghosh

48, DPP Road (Flat No.F/1, 1^st Floor)

Kolkata – 700047

8. Rajendra Maganlal Patel s/o late Maganlal Patel

Age 55 years

r/o Type-V/31, Harbour Park Extension

Port Conoly, Near Rama Krishna Mission

2

Beach Road,

Vishakhapatnam 535005

9. D. Venkata Raman

s/o Shri V Dorairaj

age 52 years

r/o E 4 Chennai Port Officers Quarters

Near Nappiar Bridge, Kamarajar Salai

Chennai – 600009

10. Y Umakanth Reddy

s/o Y. Venkata Ramana

age 56 years

r/o C-5 Samiyani Block

Deep Bhawan Residential Complex

8/1, Patel Colony

Jamnagar – 361108 (Gujarat)

11. Madhukar G Gudadhe

s/o Shri Gopalrao Sampatrao Gudadhe

age 47 years

r/o Kuzhikambil House

38/2474, Elamkulam

Kochi – 682 017

..Applicants

(Ms. P K Gupta, Advocate)

Versus

1. Union of India through Secretary

Ministry of Shipping

Transport Bhawan

Parliament Street

New Delhi – 110 001

2. The Director General

Department of Light Houses & Light Ships

Ministry of Shipping

Deep Bhavan

Sector 24, Noida

Uttar Pradesh 201301

..Respondents

(Mr. Gyanendra Singh and Mr. Satish Kumar, Advocates)

O R D E R (ORAL)

Justice L. Narasimha Reddy:

Learned counsel for respondents submits that the subject

matter of this O.A. is the same as in O.A. No.1984/2017.

Through an order dated 05.07.2018, this Tribunal allowed the

said O.A. directing that the applicants therein are entitled to be

3

extended the benefit of revised pay scale for the posts of

Director and Deputy Director, as recommended by the 5^th

Central Pay Commission, but without any arrears.

2. During the pendency of this O.A., the respondents have

passed order dated 14.09.2018 extending the benefit of pay

scale for the posts of Director and Deputy Director. The arrears

were denied to the applicants therein. The result is that the

applicants herein got the same relief as those in O.A.

No.1984/2017. Since we denied the arrears to the applicants in

the said O.A., we direct that the applicants herein also are also

not entitled for arrears.

3. Since nothing needs to be further adjudicated in the O.A.,

it is disposed of as infructuous.

There shall be no order as to costs.

( K.N. Shrivastava ) ( Justice L. Narasimha Reddy )

Member (A)

Chairman

December 20, 2018

/sunil/