2013 Supreme(Online)(Chh) 330
CHHATTISGARH HIGH COURT
Sanjay K. Agrawal, J
Ful Singh, Sunder Nayak, Deepak Devdas, Bhunesh Sahu – Appellant
Versus
State – Respondent
Special Case | No. 10/2007
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Smt. Indira Tripathi, Shri Tariq Haider, Shri Vivek Rathore
For the Respondents: Shri Mahesh Mishra, Shri A. K. Singh
Substantial compliance with mandatory provisions of the Narcotic Drugs Act validated the conviction despite procedural arguments by the defense.
Headnote:(A) Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 - Sections 20(b)(ii)
(C), 42, 50, 55, and 57 - Conviction for possession of ganja - Appellants argued lack of compliance with mandatory procedures and evidence contradictions - Court found substantial compliance with Sections 42, 50, 55 and 57, thus upholding conviction - Prosecution established link evidence despite delay in sending samples - Delayed compliance does not invalidate the evidence if seals remain intact. (Paras 10, 24, 31)
(B) Relevant Legal Principles - Mandatory compliance of statutory provisions during narcotics search - Reliability of police witnesses - Delay in evidence processing does not negate validity if handled accurately.
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. overview of appeals and prosecution's case. (Para 1 , 2) |
| 2. arguments on non-compliance and evidence inconsistencies. (Para 3 , 4) |
| 3. court's analysis of statutory compliance and evidence. (Para 6 , 9 , 10 , 12 , 24) |
| 4. final judgment affirming lower court's decision. (Para 32 , 33) |
1. These appeals are directed against judgment dated 4th June, 2007 passed by special Judge under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (henceforth "the Act, 1985'), Dhamtari in Special Case No. 10/2007. By the impugned judgment, accused / appellant Ful Singh, Sunder Nayak, Deepak Devdas, Bhunesh Sahu have been convicted under S.20(b)(ii)(C) of the Act, 1985 and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years and to pay fine of Rs. 1,00,000/-, in default of payment of fine, to further undergo simple imprisonment for 2 years.
2. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is as under :
Ashok Kumar Dwivedi (PW 8) was posed as Sub-Inspector in Traffic Branch, Dhamtari on 9-3-2005. On 9-3-2005, he received information from the mukhbir that appellant Fulsingh was bringing ganja in maruti van bearing registration No. C.G. 05 A 4486 along with his friends. He recorded mukbir suchana panchanama (Ext. P15) and also entered in rojnamcha sanha (Ext. P19). He transmitted the same information to Deputy Superintendent of Police, Dhamtari. Thereafter he proceeded towards old bus stand, Dhamtari and reached there that where one Sheikh Farook (PW 2) and Eliyas (PW 1) met him. He informed them regarding mukhbir suchana. Thereafter he proceeded towards village Soram along with Sheikh Farook (PW 2) and Eliyas (PW 1) and when they reached near canal (nahar), the maruti van bearing registration No. C.G. 05A 4486 came there. One of the appellants was driving the vehicle and other appellants were sitting inside the van. On being inquired, the appellants told their names. The appellants were informed about their right under S.50 of the Act, 1985 vide Ext. P / 2, Ext. P2A, Ext. P3 and Ext. P4. Consent of the appellants were recorded in Ext. P2, Ext. P2A, Ext. P3 and Ext. P4 itself. Thereafter, Sub-Inspector Ashok Dwivedi (PW 8) searched the maruti van bearing registration No. C.G. 05A 4486. In the said maruti van, 7 jute bora (bags) were found. Identification of the recovered article was conducted vide Ext. P6. After physical verification, it was found that the recovered article was Ganja. Ganja was weighed on the spot and it was found that out of 7 bags, (1) one white plastic bag had contained 11.650 kg. (2) one white colour fertilizer bag (bori) had contained 4.570 kg. (3) one white colour fertilizer bag had contained 10.260 kg. (4) one white colour plastic bag had contained 11.440 kg. (5) one white colour plastic bag had contained 17.060 kg. (6) one white colour plastic bag had contained 6.580 kg. and (7) one white colour plastic bag had contained 8.430 kg. of ganja. Total 69.990 kg. of ganja were recovered from the maruti van. 14 samples were prepared. The recovered ganja and its samples were seized vide Ext. P / 7. the appellants were arrested on the spot vide Ext. P8 to Ext. P11 and panchnama proceeding was prepared vide Ext. P13. Registration and insurance papers of maruti van bearing registration No. C.G. 05A 4486 were seized from Smt. Yashoda Malviaya vide Ext. P17. Dehati nalishi (Ext. P21) was prepared. Thereafter, Sub-Inspector Ashok Kumar Dwivedi (PW 8) came back to Police Station Kotwali, Dhamtari and to that effect rojnamcha sanha No. 806 was recorded and he handed over the property and appellants to Station House Officer, Police Station Kotwali, Dhamtari and a regular First Information Report (FIR) No. 118/2005 was recorded for offence under S.20(b) of the Act, 1985 vide Ext. P23. The seized property were handed over to Malkhana Moharrir for their safe custody. The samples were sent to Forensic Science Laboratory, Raipur. A report (Ext. P25) was received therefrom, in which, the test of ganja was found positive in all t