SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2023 Supreme(Online)(Chh) 14390

CHHATTISGARH HIGH COURT
R. K. K. Verma, J
Arvind Kumar Verma v. State
Criminal Appeal No. 1262 of 2014



Advocates:
For the Appellant: Mr. B. P. Singh
For the Respondent: Mr. Ashish Tiwari

The integrity of dying declarations is affirmed where corroborative medical evidence reinforces their reliability, despite procedural irregularities, leading to conviction.

Headnote:(A) Indian Penal Code, 1860 - Section 302 - Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 - Section 374(2) - Conviction and sentence appeal - Appellant convicted for murdering Vinay Kumar Yadav and sentenced to life imprisonment. Dying declaration recorded in absence of a doctor raises doubts regarding its reliability - Minor inconsistencies do not negate its credibility; corroborative medical evidence supports prosecution's case. (Paras 6, 10, 23, 24)

(B) Evidence - Dying Declaration - Weight and reliability of dying declarations depend on circumstances; should ideally be recorded by a doctor to authenticate sufficiency of declarant's mental state.

Facts of the case:
On 23.09.2012, the appellant attacked Vinay Kumar Yadav causing severe injuries, leading to his death. Dying declaration pivotal for conviction, although recorded under contentious circumstances without a doctor's endorsement. The case hinges on the reliability of testimony and forensic evidence corroborating prosecution claims.

Findings of Court:
Trial Court justified in accepting dying declaration as credible evidence supporting conviction. Minor infirmities in procedure do not undermine the substantive evidence.

Issues: Whether the dying declaration was voluntary and reliable amidst procedural lapses. How compelling is the medical evidence provided vis-à-vis the dying declaration?

Ratio Decidendi: The court establishes that while the reliability of dying declarations is paramount, corroborative evidence and witness testimonies underpinning them serve to affirm the prosecution's narrative despite minor procedural discrepancies. The conviction stands as substantiated by comprehensive evidence.

Result: Appeal dismissed.

Table of Content
1. facts establishing the attack leading to murder are outlined. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5)
2. arguments regarding the reliability of the dying declaration are presented. (Para 6 , 7 , 8)
3. dying declarations, while needing scrutiny, can support conviction if corroborated by medical evidence. (Para 10 , 23)
4. court observations addressing doubts around the dying declaration and their conclusion. (Para 12 , 14 , 22)
5. final ruling that the appeal lacks merit and is dismissed. (Para 24)

1. This criminal appeal preferred by the Appellant herein under S.374 (2) of Cr.P.C. is directed against the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 19.11.2014 passed by the II Additional Sessions Judge, Durg, District Durg (C.G.), in S.T. No.213/2012 by which the Appellant has been convicted for the offence punishable under S.302 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life with fine of Rs.5000/-, and on failure to pay the fine amount, additional sentence of R.I. for one year has been imposed against the appellant herein.

2. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that on 23.09.2012 at around 22.45 hours, the appellant herein attacked and caused injury to Vinay Kumar Yadav by knife over his left ear, jaw, cheek and eye - brow. Looking to the injuries sustained, injured Vinay Kumar Yadav was taken by Ramesh Chandra Beldar (PW / 4) to the room of Raja Ram Dhurv and information was given to the police control room. During that time, injured Vinay Kumar Yadav, with the help of nearby people, was taken to J.L.N. Hospital & Research Center, Bhilai, where Dr. Meenakshi Dave (PW / 1) examined injured and gave her report Ex.P / 1 in which it has also been recorded that injured Vinay Kumar Yadav was assaulted by appellant herein namely Arvind Kumar Verma. M.L.C. report of injured was also prepared vide Ex.P / 2 in which as many as five incised wounds on abdomen, eye - brow, left side of face were noticed.

3. It is the case of the prosecution that deceased Vinay Kumar Yadav had told complainant Ramesh Chandra Beldar (PW / 4) that appellant Arvind Kumar Verma, with an intention to kill him attacked him by knife and caused injury to him. Upon information of complainant (PW / 4), Head Constable Kamlesh Kumar Sahu (PW / 10) registered dehati nalishi (Ex.P / 5) at Sector - 9 Hospital and in order to determine whether the injured Vinay Kumar Yadav, who was alive, was in condition to give statement, wrote a letter (Ex.P / 18) to Assistant Surgeon of Sector - 9 Hospital, upon which, Kamlesh Kumar Sahu (PW / 10) was informed that Vinay Kumar Yadav is in a condition to give statement and accordingly, the statement of injured Vinay Kumar Yadav was recorded in presence of two witnesses namely Shyamendra Kumar Yadav (PW / 9) and Deepak (not examined). Thereafter, Shyamendra Kumar Yadav (PW / 10) came to the police station and lodged FIR under S.307 of IPC , however, due to the fatal injury, Vinay Kumar Yadav died on 24.09.2012 at early in the morning, which has been informed by the Sector - 9 Hospital vide Ex.P / 15 to police station Sector - 6. Thereafter, Merg intimation (Ex.P / 16) was recorded, inquest was conducted vide Ex.P / 7 & dead body of Vinay Kumar Yadav was subjected to postmortem examination, which was conducted by Dr. R.K. Nayak (PW / 3) who gave his report Ex.P / 4, according to which, Vinay Kumar Yadav died of shock due to extensive visceral injuries and hemorrhage. Thereafter, the Appellant was arrested and his memorandum statement was recorded vide Ex.P / 20, pursuant to which, bloodstained clothes of appellant and knife were recovered at his instance vide Ex.P / 21 and Ex.P / 22 respectively.
Bloodstained bed sheet, on which the deceased was lying, was seized from the house of Rajaram Dhruv and clothes of injured / deceased Vinay Kumar Yadav were also seized vide Ex.P / 8. The seized articles were sent for chemical examination to F.S.L., Raipur, vide Ex.P / 2 9, and as per FSL report (Ex.P /









































Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top