##PAGE1##

के (cid:574)ीय सूचना आयोग

Central Information Commission

बाबा गंगनाथ माग(cid:330), मुिनरका

Baba Gangnath Marg, Munirka

नई िद(cid:671)ी, New Delhi – 110067

File No:

CIC/DODEF/A/2024/123465

CIC/DODEF/A/2024/123412

Nitin Narayan Keskar ………Appellant

VERSUS

बनाम

….(cid:366)ितवादीगण /Respondent

The CPIO Garrison

Engineer (South) No 1 Gen.

Bhagat Marg

Pune-411040

Date of Hearing : 23.02.2026

Date of Decision : 27.02.2026

INFORMATION COMMISSIONER : SANJEEV KUMAR JINDAL

Relevant facts emerging from Second Appeal:

Case No. Date of RTI CPIO Reply First appeal FAA order Compliant/Secon

d

Appeal Dated

123465 01.04.2024 19.04.2024 27.04.2024 20.05.2024 25.07.2024

123412 20.03.2024 19.04.2024 26.04.2024 20.05.2024 24.07.2024

Page 1 of 12

1 / 13

1. Second Appeal- CIC/DODEF/A/2024/123465

Information sought:

The Appellant filed an RTI application dated 01.04.2024 seeking the

following information:

“The certified true copy of the:

a) Certified Information regarding the contract wise final executed

and contract quantities for following items

i) Supply and fix three track sliding window with two or more shutter

with 4mm thick plain/tinted as approved glass, one shutter using

stainless steel wire. Cloth 0.36 MM nominal dia and 1.18 MM width

aperture for mosquito proofing with good quality bearing handle lock.

Rubber Beading and glazing Clips etc using following aluminium

powder coated sections confirming to. Catalogue of Jindal or

equivalent make complete all as specified and directed by engineer in

charge.

ii) Non skid ceramic tiles. 7to8 MM thick. (Square/rectangular). Area of

each tile, exceeding 0.06 square metre but not exceeding 0.11 square

metre in floors etc. Set and jointed in neat cement slurry, and pointed

in white or coloured cement to match.

iii)Non skid ceramic tiles 7 to 8 MM thick (square / rectangular) area of

each tile extending 0.11 square metre but not exceeding o.18 square

metre. In floors etc. Set and jointed in neat cement slurry and pointed

in white or coloured cement to match.

iv) Non skid ceramic tiles 7 to 8 MM thick (square / rectangular) area

of each tile extending 0.18 square metre but not exceeding o.38 square

metre. In floors etc. Set and jointed in neat cement slurry and pointed

in white or coloured cement to match.

v) Vitrified ceramic tiles 10MM thick(Square/rectangular) polished,

area of each tile not exceeding 0.36Sqm In floors etc. Set and jointed in

neat cement slurry and pointed in white or coloured cement to match.

List of the BoQs/Tender ids/Contract agreements against the information:

Page 2 of 12

2 / 13

Sl Name of the work Tender Id BOQ No File No

No

1. Repairs to sunken floor. RCC roof treatment. 2020_ 367575 8864

Plastering and plumbing and certain E/M works. MES._328506_1.

In MD accommodation of A&B wing of DAD

Complex. Lulla Nagar area. under AGE B/RI South

Pune

2. Repairs to compound wall. fencing. Gates and 2020._M ES._327770_1. 366713 8865

drains. Hard standing. Foot path etc in various

married and other than married accommodation

under AGE B/RI South Pune.

3. Repairs to RCC Roof treatment. WPT. In sunken. 2020_MES._379860_1. 423791 8896

Sanitary fittings. Plastering and plumbing in

married and other than merit accommodation.

At VBV. MAP PH. 1. DCA. And 10 Sikh Regiment.

under AGE B/RI South Pune.

4. Repair to joinery, roofing, AC sheet, fallse ceiling, 2020_MES_402098_1. 448941 8210

rainwater, pipe. flooring, walling, plastering and

connected items at AICTS and other than A ICTS

area under AGE B/RI South Pune.

5. Periodical/Welcome, Maintenance and certain 2020_MES_405660_1. 452998 8216

B/R. Repairs in MD accommodation at A&B wing

of DAD residential complex under AGE B/RI

South Pune.

6. Special repairs to existing fencing, wire of ASC 2021_MES_410892_1. 458851 8222

butchery and special repairs to roof treatment

and windows to block number 13. At DCA

complex and provision of central.QRT room at

main gate and provision of MT shade for vehicle

at 4/5 GRFF. under GE South Pune.

7. Repairs to RCC roof. Treatment, plastering, 2021_MES_417358_1. 466057 8229

plum