% 01.04.2024 FACILITATIVE INDEX S.No. Content Para Nos. 1 The Issue 1 - 2 2 Facts and Rival Contentions 3 Initial submissions of Mr. Kapil Wadhwa for the plaintiff 4 Registrations held by the plaintiff and defendant 3.1 – 3.4 5 User of plaintiff’s marks 4.1 – 4.2 6 Reputation of plaintiff’s marks 5.1 – 5.3 7 Plaintiff’s trade dress 6 8 Defendant’s acts and alleged infringement and passing off 7.1 – 7.11 9 Submissions of Mr. Chander M. Lall in reply 10 Monopolization of “ART” prefix 8.1 – 8.3 11 No infringement action against registered mark – Section 28(3) 9.1 – 9.2 12 Re. passing off No bad faith adoption Applying the Pianotist test – surrounding circumstances and nature of consumers 12.1 – 12.4 15 ART is common to the trade – Section 17(2)(b) 13 16 Estoppel 14 17 No likelihood of confusion 15 18 Plea of infringement not maintainable – Section 124 16 19 No trade dress copying 17.1 – 17.2 20 Re. TIARA 18 21 Rejoinder by Mr. Wadhwa 22 Re. trade dress copying 19 23 Re. monopolization of “ART” and the common to the trade defence 20.1 – 20.8 24 Likelihood of confusion 21.1 – 21.2 25 Re. TIARA 22.1 – 22.2 23 Action for infringement lies against registered trade mark 23 24 Ba