ORDER

0- 06.01.2012 /0 For orders see LA.App.No. 1195/2008, titled as ’Ranbir Sharma vs. Union of India & A nr.’.

JUDGE JANUARY 06, 2012 pkb • IN THE fiG!! COURT OF, IELffl AT MjJ DHH •

Reserved on: November i 2011 Pi"onounced (m:]anu(vv0(2O12 (GRID-A)

LA.APP. 1195/2008 (VILLAGE- BHARTHAL)

RANBIR SHAR .1.A . Appellant I’hrough: Mr. B.S.}\4aan1 .Mr..Aniit .Maari, Mr.Jai Prakash, Ms. Sni ita Maan, Mr. k.S.Verina, MrJitin Tewaihia, Advocates Mr.Anand Yadav and 1\’Is.Anita Tomar,.A.dvocates.

Mr.Rohias, j\doc.ate.

Mr. RagIiuvi ndr (iodara, Advocate Mr.N.S.Negi and iVhJI.S.Rau.teia, Advocate •

N4r.S. K.Rout and 1\4r.B . K. koutray, Mr.M .Azarn Ansaii Advocates.

•

Mr,Panka Vivek, Advocate Mr.Rajcsh Yadav, Mr.Deepak Khosla, Mr.Samit Khosla and Mr.])hanania Mehiawat. Advocates y Mr.H .S.1 aneL, Ad,;ocate Mr.!.S.Dahiya. Ad,’eca.:

IVIr. Sandeep I hakhnr. dvcate A Mr.Atul I ’ripath, Adv OCale.

.Mr.N.S.Negi and Mr.II.S.Raiuela., (Ad\’neaes Jr • •.

• respondem in appa is. tiled b U Cl)

y versus t.JNION OF’ INDIA & AN ft. :.... .Respodeni;

] hruu.h. Mr.Sanjav Podclur, en or A rii,oeate, wii ;V(r :S ... a Iathah, Mr.’.lo. itrac..idha’

I\4s K Kaumud Ic ’ r ’d (O( t kC ’Jul Mr.Ajav Vern-, N43ecnasha\ .v Soiii. MrMu.ke ;h Kumar, Mr . K. etiii, i\!Ir.Pa\vnfl Mathw-, Mr. K unal Shai-m a. A dvoeaie id1’ DD/\

•A.A PP 1 22008 &.. CM.No409/200S (Uioss-ObjCctiofls), i•.’VAPI.152/;2oc: )(i8 LA. \PP ,Jfl ’1 N c 5’ 00’ /91 9 (!,’Toss- C"bie( i A.APP.G9 7,2008 &. CM .No.4.3:/2uoo r;sOhjcet(ons): 1,;,\.,A ’P.701/2098 • CM No.51 0/2009 (Cross-Oh c1i’ i’ A I’P 7Od’20A I \ , 77(I2(fl9

w . 11 /03 coi’nccted i’ppeiIs of VilOgo BhrU,;I

•".Arj&. No. ?94/201C & lorIil(o:Ied Appojis hf VIIso 3sssjri

I i: !:rnQ & or,non. Appo& ol ViUsgo ocrsnu,ir

’-

[ A APP 771 "2008 & CM No 425/2009 (Cross-Objections) I A APP 77/2008 LA.APP.77312008 & CMNo.3835/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.774/2008 & CM.No.6 11/2009 (Cross-Objections); . LA.APP.775/200 LA.APP.776/2008; L.A.AP11.777/2008; LA.APP.782/2008 & C11A.No.940/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.783/2008; 1A.APP.784/2008; LA.APP.785/2008; LA.API, 798/2008 & CM No 615/2009 (Cross-Objections);. ,LA APP 799/2008 & CMNo 931/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.80512008; LA.APP.806/2008; 1,A.APP.8 13/2008 & CM.No. 1795/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.8 14/2008 & CM.No.806/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.8 18/200.8; LA.APP.8 19/2008; LA.APP. 820/2008; LA.AP]PS829/2008; LA.APP.830/2008; LA.APP.832/2008; 1A.APP.833/2008; LA.APP.844/2008; LA.APP.845/2008: .LA.APP.873/2008 & CM.No.779/2011 (Cross-Objections); LA. APP.892/2008 & CM.No.799/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP.899/2008; 1,A.APP.901/2008; LA.APP.91 5/2008; LA.APP.95 1/2008 & CM.No709/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA. APP.959/2008; LA.APP.973/2008; L.A.APP.974/2008 & CM.No.5 19/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.AP.975/2008; LA.APP.976/2008; LA.APP.978/2008; LA.APP.986i’2008 & CM.No.572!2009. (Cross-Objections);LA.APP.993/2008;LA.APP. 1029/2008& CM.No. 1 ’7340/2008 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP. 103 1 !2(.)08 &- CM.No. 17335/2008 (Cross-01ections); 1 ;A.APP. 1032/2008 & CM.No.599/2009 ((..’ross--Objections); LA.APP. 1046/2008; 1..,’\.APP. 1 04712008;LA.APP.1 048/2008& CM.No.785 1./2009 (Cross-Objections);

a LA.APP. 1049/2008 & CM.No.420;2009 (Cross.-Objections); LA.APP. 1050/2008; LA.APP. 1 031/2008 & CM.No. 1 7262/2008 (Cros-Objectiohs; LA. APP. .1 052/2008; lA.AP]. 1053/2008 & CM.No.41 6/2009 (Cross-Objections);LA.APF. 1054/2008 & CM No.1766/2009 . (Cross-Objections); LA.APP. 1055/2008;LA.APP. 1057/200S & (TM .No.752/2Q 11 - (Cross-Objections); LA.APP. I 058/2008& CM.No. 1557/2011 (Cros-Objections); LA.APP. 1059/2006 & CM.No. 1 7259/2008(Cross-Ohjetion.$); -

LA.AP1. I 060/2008;LA.APP. 1062/2008 & CM.No.546/2009 (Cross-Objections); LA.APP. 1073/2008; LA.A,PP. 1074/2008 & CM.No.62312009 (Cross-Objections); 1..A.APP. 1075/2008; LA.APP. 1081/2008 & -CM.No.462/2009(Cross-Objections); LA.APP. 1084/2008& CM.No. 17302,12(’108’ (Cross-Objections); LA.APP. I 086/2008 & CM.No.2448/2008 (Cross-Objections); 1.A.-APP. 10 8’17/2008& CM