SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(Online)(Del) 48849

$~24


IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI


CS(COMM) 1094/2025, I.A. 25318/2025, I.A. 25319/2025 & I.A. 25320/2025


BIGNET SOLUTIONS LLP .....Plaintiff


Through: Mr. Jai Sai Deepak, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Surabh Balwani & Mr. Chirag Rathore, Advs.


versus


NOVEX COMMUNICATION PVT. LTD. .....Defendant


Through: Mr C.M. Lall, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Jasdeep Dhillon, Mr. Anirudh Jamwal, Mr. Aditya Bajaj, Ms. Annanya Mehan, Ms. Kenisha Salva, Advs.


CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA

O R D E R

21.11.2025

1. The present suit has been filed by the plaintiff inter alia seeking a declaration that its use of certain sound recordings (enlisted at paragraph 15 of the plaint), stated to be pre-1965 works and now in the public domain for a private event scheduled on 12.10.2025, does not cause any infringement of the defendant’s copyright. The plaintiff also seeks a permanent injunction restraining the defendant from demanding any license fee qua the use of the recordings mentioned in paragraph ‘15’ of the plaint in respect thereof for the event scheduled on 12.10.2025.

2. The grievance of the plaintiff, as pleaded, arose when the venue, hosting the plaintiff’s event scheduled on 12.10.2025, directed the plaintiff to obtain an NOC/license from the defendant. It is stated that the plaintiff approached the defendant for a license and was duly quoted the fee. It is the plaintiff’s case that however, upon verification, it found that the copyright in the specific 15 songs proposed to be played on 12.10.2025, as also set out at paragraph 15 of the plaint, had expired under Section 27 of the Copyright Act, 1957, and therefore no NOC/license is legally required. It is stated that plaintiff only intended to play sound recording, which form part of pre-1965 sound repository.

3. The plaintiff filed the suit on an apprehension that if it did not obtain a licence from the defendant, there would be possible interference in the conduct of the event on 12.10.2025.

4. On 10.10.2025, when the matter was first listed, this Court issued interim directions for holding of the event on 12.10.2025 and recorded the statements of both sides. On 10.10.2025, the defendant asserted that it does not enforce rights in works not owned/managed by it or in works already in the public domain and asserted that the suit was misconceived. The plaintiff, in turn, undertook that it would play only the 15 songs enlisted at paragraph 15 of the plaint as they are for the period pre-1965 and would file, after the event, a certified recording along with a letter undersigned by the venue confirming the same. Based on these statements, interim directions were issued permitting the plaintiff to proceed with the event as scheduled on 12.10.2025.

5. The plaintiff has now placed on record documents to show that the event dated 12.10.2025 has since concluded and that only the songs enlisted

in paragraph 15 of the plaint were played. Learned senior counsel for the plaintiff submits that this is in compliance of the directions at para 11.1 of the order dated 10.10.2025.

5.1 He states that when the plaintiff emailed the defendant on 01.10.2025 seeking a license quotation, the list of 15 songs enlisted in the plaint was enclosed with that communication and defendant ought to have clarified that no licence is required as the songs are pre-1965.

6. Learned senior counsel for the defendant, on instructions, states that the songs enlisted by the plaintiff at paragraph ‘15’ of the plaint do not form part of the defendant’s repertoire and that the defendant has never asserted copyright over these particular recordings since the copyright for the said songs had expired.

6.1 He submits that in the e-mail issued by the plaintiff on 01.10.2025 only the names of the songs were given; however, their release date was not mentioned. He states that for instance, one of the songs has been recreated in a recent movie and the copyright in the new recording subsist in favour of the defendant.

6.2 He submits that had the plaintiff communicated this specific list as enlisted in paragraph ‘15’ at the time of applying for a license, the defendant would have not quoted any fee. He states that in any event the plaintiff could have clarified this concern with the defendant and the issue could have been resolved amicably. He states that the defendant does not demand license fees for works in the public domain and thus the cause of action is misconceived.

6.3 He also states that the recording of the event held

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top