SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(Online)(GSTARA) 26

GOODS AND SERVICES TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL THIRUVANANTHAPURAM BENCH


Division Bench : Court No I


APPEAL NO : APL/28/TVP/2026


(arising out of the OIA No. GSTA 4/2022 dated 20-9-2022 issued by the Joint Commissioner (Appeals), SGST, Kottayam)


KURIAN ABRAHAM PVT LTD ….………..…….Appellant Vs THE COMMISSIONER OF KERALAM STATE GST ….…………Respondent


THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
for Appellant: Iype John, Advocate
for Respondent: Mansur MI, AR


CORAM : Hon’ble Shri Subramanya Rayaprol, Vice-President
Hon’ble Shri Ramamoorthi Sriram, Member (Technical)


FINAL ORDER NO : 17/TVP/KERALAM/2026
Date of Hearing: 25-9-2026
Date of Order: 30-10-2026
Order Per: Subramanya Rayaprol, Vice President


(Order pronounced in open court)


S R S V u u a is y b w b a r r a a p a n m ro a m a l t n h a y a n a ya DRVD15 ai i as gy :tw R 5 i e at 2 ap : a :2n 1 lr a lo 0a y 2 l 2t s + hS y 6 ig 0 au .1 5 nb a 0' er 3. a 3 d 0 p m 0 ' b ay r n o ya l
Subramanya Rayaprol
Vice-President


R Sr a i m ra a m moorthi DSDri aigrtai e tm: a 2 l 0 y 2 s 6 ig .1 n 0 e .3 d 0 b 1 y 7 R :2 a 7 m :5 a 4 m + 0 0 5 r ' t 3 h 0 i '
Ramamoorthi Sriram
Member (Technical)


Date : 30-10-2026







1.0 Mr Iype John, Ld Advocate appeared for the appellant. Mr Mansur MI, Joint Commissioner appeared as AR for the respondents.

2.0 Ld Advocate for the appellants submits that the appellant had received 7560 kgs of rubber latex vide delivery challan no. 01/2021-22 dated 4-1-2022 from their supplier Arun Scaria, but the GSTIN no was wrongly mentioned in the delivery challan. He also submits that their consignor namely Arun Scaria, Koothattukalam Rubber House, Karikayam, Chittar, Kerala, is an agriculturist and preparation of e- way bill is exempted for Rubber Latex, which is an agricultural product, and only delivery challan is sufficient in terms of the Notification No. 3/2018-State Tax dated 14-5-2018 issued by the SGST Department of Kerala State. An inadvertent error occurred in the Delivery Challan, which was prepared by the consignee (appellant) on behalf of the consignor, wherein a GSTIN Number of another dealer was mentioned. It is pertinent to note that the Provisional Receipt did not mention any such GST Number. The transport was intercepted on 4-1-2022 and on the ground of non-possession of E-way Bill, Forms GST MOV-02, Forms GST MOV-04, Forms GST MOV-06, Forms GST MOV-07 and Forms GST MOV-09 were issued. As an agriculturist and the goods transported being Rubber Latex, and that the transaction is not one of a dealer to dealer, requirement of e-way bill is exempted as per section 23 (1)(b) of the KGST Act. He submits that the supplier being an agriculturist, is exempted from preparation of e-way bill and that their supplier had already transported the goods, i.e. Rubber Latex directly from their Rubber Estate, directly to the appellant along with a delivery challan. As per the notification no 3/2018-State Tax, for transportation of Rubber Latex, the generation of e-way bill is exempted, subject to the condition that the Rubber Latex, irrespective of the value should be accompanied with a delivery challan issued under KVAT Act or Tax invoice issued under GST Act. In the present case, the Rubber Latex was transported by their supplier under a delivery challan. Therefore, the allegation that there was no e-way bill and consequent detention of goods, and imposition of penalty is illegal and is liable to be set aside. He prays that their appeals be allowed and penalties be set aside.

3.0 Ld AR appearing for the Revenue (State), reiterates the contents of the MOV- 07 and MOV-09 and also the facts leading to the detention of the goods i.e. rubber latex. He submits that the appellant was caught unawares without e-way bill on 4-1- 2022 and the submissions made by them is only an afterthought. He further made a detailed written submission as below:

3.1 The facts leading to the present appeal, in brief, are as follows. On 04/01/2022, the 1st respondent intercepted vehicle No. KL 38 E 4416 at Pizhaku. On verification, it was found that the vehicle was carrying 36 drums (7,560 kg) of natural rubber latex falling under HSN 40011020, valued at ₹3,85,560/-, consigned to the appellant.

3.2 The only document produced by the person in charge was Delivery Challan No. 001/2021-22, which showed M/s. Anku Rubbers, a dealer registered under the GST Acts, as the consignor. The transaction was thus, on the face of the document, one between two registered dealers, and the value exceeded ₹50,000/-. No e-way bill had been generated or accompanied the goods, in clear violation of Rule 138 of the CGST/SGST Rules, 2017.

3.3 Accordingly, the goods and conveyance were detained and notice in Form GST MOV-07 was issued. The appellant, without raising any objection whatsoever, came forward on the same day and remitted the proposed penalty, and the goods were released. It is pertinent to note that the plea that the consignor was an agriculturist, and that the GSTIN was printed by mistake, was raised for the first time only at the appellate stage, as an afterthought.

3.4 The appeal does not merit admission under Section 112(2). The amount of penalty involve

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top