SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(Online)(GSTARA) 30

GSTAT State Bench Agra


Division Bench Court No. Court I


APL/86/AGR/2026


SHAILENDRA KUMAR SINGH .............Appellant
Versus
KAMLESH TRADING CO., PROPRIETOR, W/O AKHIESH KUMAR RAILWAY ROAD NEAR KOTWALI KAIMGANJ UPFAR 209502 .............Respondent


Hon’ble Ajeet Singh, Member(Judicial)
Hon’ble Vivek Kumar, Member (Technical)


Counsel for Appellant: MUKESH KUMAR
Counsel for Respondent: SH. SAURABH AGRAWAL, ADVOCATE


Dated: 19.11.2026


A Si j n e g e h t ( Ajee DAD1t2 ji aeg : t3 ei e S t 3 t: a :2S 5 lli0 y 1i n2 sg n+6 ihg 0.1 5 n g 1' e 3.2 d 0h 0 ' b y )


V Ku iv m ek a r DbD12 yi a g : t3 Vi e t 0 i: av :24 lel 0 y 3 k2 s + K6 iug 0.1m 5 n 1' e 3 a.2 d 0 r0 '


(Vivek Kumar)





Form GST APL-04A [See rules 113(1) & 115]

Summary of the order and demand after issue of order by the GST Appellate Tribunal whether remand order : No Order reference no. : ZA090401126000119H Date of order : 19/11/2026

1. GSTIN/Temporary ID/UIN - 09AAMPA3291P1Z7

2. Appeal Case Reference no. - APL/86/AGR/2026 Date - 18/04/2026

3. N 72 a 3 m 5 e 0 0 o 1 f 5th 2 e 2 appellant - SHAILENDRA KUMAR SINGH , singhparisha2007@gmail.com , 4. N 1. a K m A e M of L t E he S H re s T p R on A d D an IN t - G CO. , AKHILESH.AGRAWAL24@GMAIL.COM , 7887063227

5. Order appealed against - AD090625027697K (5.1) Order Type - Demand Order (5.2) Ref Number - ZD090925134963U Date - 12/09/2025

6. Personal Hearing - 19/11/2026 28/10/2026 03/09/2026 19/08/2026 06/08/2026 7. Status of Order under Appeal - Confirmed – Order under Appeal is confirmed

8. Order in brief - As per detailed order.

Summary of Order

9. If demand order then whether demand quantified: No

10. For Other orders and Demand orders which are not quantified:
Issues as raised by proper officer Issues as determined by Appellate/Revisional authority Order by GST Appellate Tribunal
Levy of Penalty The order passed by the First Appellate Authority under Section 130 read with Section 122 has been set aside. AGRA BENCH

Place :AGRA
Signature Date : 19.11.2026
AGRA Sandeep Yadav
Designation : Stenographer/Law researcher
Jurisdiction :Agra

ORDER

Per. Ajeet Singh (Judicial Member)

Commissioner State Tax, U.P (Through- Shailendra Kumar, Assistant Commissioner)

Vs Kamlesh Trading Company, Kaimganj, Farrukhabad.

APL/86/AGR/2026 (Passed on 19th day of November, 2026)

1. Under section 112(1) Central Goods and Services Tax, Act/ Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax, Act (for short CGST/UPGST, Act), this appeal has been preferred by department of State tax, Uttar Pradesh, against order dated- 12.09.2025 passed by First appellate authority, Division- Etawah, in appeal no. AD090625027697K, whereby by allowing the appeal of respondent taxpayer first appellate authority has set aside the order in original and consequential demand of penalty and fine of Rs. 1,45,055/-. For convenience appellant and respondent will be addressed as department and taxpayer, respectively.

2. Facts giving rise to the present appeal are in brief that special investigation branch unit Etawah headed by Additional commissioner Grade-II had inspected the business premises of taxpayer on 30.11.2024, owner of taxpayer firm Sh. Akhilesh Agrawal, was present at that time who told that his firm is engaged in the trade of tobacco leaves and its processed items. On verifying the records and goods kept in business premises, it was found that 15,441 kg tobacco stem powder was found unaccounted searching officer issued I.N.S no. 0583 dated 30.11.2024, and seized the stock found so unaccounted. Thereafter, a SCN u/s 130 read with section 122 was issued by proper officer. Though, SCN was replied by taxpayer but not accepted by proper officer and by determination of value of goods found unaccounted of Rs. 3,39,442/-, penalty and fine of Rs. 1,45,055/- were imposed by order in original dated 17.03.2025.

3. Feeling aggrieved by that order in original, taxpayer firm had preferred appeal before first appellate authority u/s 107 of CGST/UPGST, Act which was allowed and amount of penalty and fine was set aside, hence this second appeal by department u/s 112(1) of CGST/UPGST, Act.

4. Learned departmental representative has assailed the order under appeal as not sustainable in law and submitted for allowing the appeal.

5. Per contra, learned counsel appeared for taxpayer has supported the findings recorded by first appellate authority and submitted to dismiss the appeal. We have heard both the learned representatives of parties and perused the record available digitally on GSTAT portal. The question for determination may be formulated as under-

Whether in a survey/search carried out under section 67 of CGST/UPGST, Act, proceedings u/s 130 read with se

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top