2025 Supreme(Online)(HP) 4597
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
G.S. Sandhawalia, CJ, Ranjan Sharma, J
The Bihar Medical Services and Infrastructure Corp. Ltd. Patna – Appellant
Versus
The Chairman, the HP Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council and Ors. – Respondent
CWP No. 6498 of 2021 | Arb. Case No. 72 of 2021
Important Points
Subject
Arbitration - Arbitral Award Challenge
Act Referred
The Himachal Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2007
Headnote
(B) Writ Jurisdiction - The High Court has the discretion to entertain writ petitions even where an alternative remedy exists, particularly in cases of violation of natural justice or where the statutory remedy is onerous. (Paras 30, 38, 44)
For the Appellants/Petitioners:Mr. Umesh Prasad Singh, Senior Advocate, Mr. Shrawan Dogra, Senior Advocate, Mr. Kumar Manish, Ms. Divya Sood, Mr. Tejasvi Dogra, Mr. Shubham Sood, Ms. Bhanvi Negi
For the Respondents: Mr. Samman Vardhan Gautam, Mr. Sahil Thakur, Mr. Yuyutsu Thakur, Mr. Priyam Tiwari, Mr. Harsh Raj, Ms. Khushi Sharma, Mr. Praphull Kumar
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. overview of the case and parties involved. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 4) |
G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Present proceedings arise out of an Arbitral Award passed by respondent No.2 against the petitioner/appellant at the instance of respondent No.3-M/s Medipole Pharmaceutical India Pvt. Ltd (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Supplier’).
2. Both the matters, i.e., Writ petition and the Arbitration case being inter connected, are being taken up together since primarily, the issue is regarding the Award passed by the Arbitrator dated 06.04.2021 in Reference Case No. 49 of 2017, filed before the respondent No.1-Council
3. It is pertinent to mentionf here that after the Arbitration Case as such was filed and notice issued on 27.07.2021, under Section 34 of The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 , (hereinafter referred to as ‘the 1996 Act’) for quashing of the Award dated 06.04.2021 the purchaser/petitioner had also preferred Writ petition whereby, at the first instance on 26.10.2021, operation and execution of the said Award had been ordered to be stayed. The Arbitration case as such was only thereafter on 10.03.2022, directed to be listed along with the Writ petition H and both were admitted on 16.06.2022 with Rule DB due to which we propose to decide both together.
4. Vide an ex parte Award in question, the Arbitrator dealt with the claim of the Supplier for recovery of Rs.29,83,80,909.00/- and allowed the Supplier as such to file a revised claim for Rs.66,50,74,160.00/- along with up to date penal interest as on 30.11.2019 since the matter had been remanded earlier by this Court. Therefore, while keeping in view the report of a Chartered Accountant, justified the up to date claim of Rs. 95,00,70,208.00/- plus up to date penal interest and GST on the interest as on 01.04.2021 till its final realization under Section 16 of The Micro, Small and Medium Enterprisefs Development Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the MSMED Act, 2006’) and awarded the same. The Arbitrator thereafter directed that the original of the Award be sent to the Buyer and Supplier and third Award and stamp papers be sent along with the relevant record to the Chairman of respondent No. -1- Himachal Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council, Shimla (hereinafter referred to as ‘the council’) for record while answering the reference.
Argument on behalf of the Petitioner/Buyer.
5. Learned Senior Counsel Mr. R.K. Bawa with other counsel Mr. Umesh Prasad Singh Senior Advocate (through V.C.) and Shri Shrawan Dogra, Senior Advocate for the Buyer as such have argued that the ex parte proceedings are liable to be set aside as the proceedings were conducted during the time of Covid-19 and therefore, the Buyer as such could not put in appearance before the Arbitrator who had proceeded to pass an ex parte Award on 19.03.2021. The Head OfÏce of the Buyer was at Patna in the State of Bihar and there were issues regarding distant travelling and transportation was not easily available at that point of time. The proceedings have been conducted in utmost haste in as much as the mattefr had been taken up on firstly 16.2.2021 and due to the reference being received from respondent No-1-Council. That the authorized representatives and the Council of the Supplier had already appeared on their own account and accepted the service. The Buyer as such was stated to have served through registered speed post but not present and therefore, on the basis of the mail track consignment, proceedings had been conducted ex parte on 19.03.2021. The Statement of Claims were also only filed then and the matter had been H fixed for 5th of April, 2021. The afÏdavit in support of the claimant’s claim had been produced on 05.04.2021 and Award had been passed on the very next day and therefore, misconduct on the part of the Arbitrator is evident and therefore, the Award is not sustainable. Accordingly, it is contended that the defence could have been struck off and liberty could h