SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(Online)(J&K) 965

HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Moksha Khajuria Kazmi, J
Union Territory of J & K – Appellant
Versus
Shabir Ahmad Dar – Respondent
RFA No. 31/2024



Important Points

In a summary suit under Order XXXVII CPC, failure to comply with a conditional order for leave to defend within the stipulated time justifies a decree; subsequent deposit of the amount after the decree does not retrospectively revive the right to defend.

Subject

Civil Law - Civil Procedure

Act Referred

Headnote

(A) Civil Procedure - Summary Suit - Conditional Leave to Defend - Non-compliance with the condition of depositing a specified amount within the stipulated time leads to the passing of a decree in favor of the plaintiff. (Para 16)

(B) Procedural Law - Retrospective Compliance - Deposit of the balance amount after the passing of the judgment and decree cannot be construed as compliance to retrospectively revive the right to defend the suit. (Para 16)

Issues: Whether the failure to comply with the condition for grant of leave to defend in a summary suit justifies the decreeing of the suit, and whether subsequent deposit of the amount can revive the right to defend.

Result: Appeal dismissed.

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • practice and procedure
    • civil procedure
    • appeals (Para 07, 09, 17)
  • contract law
    • recovery of money (Para 03, 11)

Advocates:
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Illyas Nazir Laway
For the Respondents: Manzoor Ahmad Dar, Javaid

Table of Contents

1. Suit for recovery filed under Order XXXVII CPC by plaintiffs seeking payment for electrical works, where conditional leave to defend was granted subject to depositing specific funds. (Para 01 , 02 , 03 )

2. Appellants contend delay in depositing funds occurred due to administrative reasons, while respondents argue failure to comply with conditional leave requires decreeing the suit. (Para 09 , 14 , 15 )

3. The court found appellants failed to fulfill the pre-condition for leave to defend within the stipulated time, and late deposit cannot retrospectively revive the right to defend. (Para 08 , 13 , 16 )

4. Non-compliance with a condition precedent imposed for grant of leave to defend entitles the plaintiff to an immediate summary judgment under Order XXXVII CPC. (Para 08 , 16 )

5. Civil First Appeal dismissed, and the trial court judgment and decree for recovery are upheld due to failure to meet the conditional leave requirements. (Para 17 )

6. Does subsequent compliance with a condition precedent for leave to defend, after the suit has been decreed, invalidate the decree?

No. Compliance with the condition must occur within the stipulated time. Attempting to satisfy the condition after the suit has been decreed does not cure the default or revive the right to defend. (Para 13 , 16 )

7. What is the consequence of failing to deposit the amount required by a court as a condition for granting leave to defend in a summary suit?

When a defendant fails to deposit the amount specified as a condition for leave to defend within the time granted, the court is entitled to pass a judgment and decree in favor of the plaintiff under Order XXXVII CPC. (Para 08 , 16 )

JUDGMENT

01. The instant Civil First Appeal has been preferred by the appellants against the judgment and decree dated 12.08.2023 passed by the learned Additional District Judge (Bank Cases), Srinagar, in a summary suit titled Shabir Ahmad Dar and others vs. Commissioner-cum-Secretary and others, under and in terms of Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, decreeing in favour of the respondents for an amount of Rs. 57.23 lacs, along with interest and costs.

Factual Matrix:

02. The respondents/plaintiffs are claimed to have executed electrical works at the MLA Hostel, Srinagar, to the tune of Rs. 37.82 lacs. The funds in this regard were stated to have been contributed by the Legislative Assembly Secretariat, J&K, and released in favour of the Directorate of Estates, Civil Secretariat, J&K, to be placed at the disposal of the Executive Engineer, Estates Division, Srinagar, for meeting the expenditure incurred in this behalf. It is, however, stated that no public tenders were invited for execution of the aforesaid works.

03. The respondents/plaintiffs instituted a suit before the Court of learned Additional District Judge (Bank Cases), Srinagar, under Order XXXVII CPC against the appellants/defendants, seeking recovery of an amount of Rs. 57.32 lacs on account of the aforesaid works allegedly executed by them at the behest and under the directions of the appellants. The reliefs claimed in the suit were as follows:

(i) A decree for recovery of an amount of Rs. 57.32 lacs on account of the works executed by the plaintiffs at the behest and under the directions of the defendants;

(ii) A decree for payment of interest on account of alleged illegal retention of the amount from the date the same became due until its final realization; and

(iii) Any other relief or decree which the Court may deem just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case, including costs of the suit.

05. The Estates Department filed an application before the learned trial Court seeking leave to defend the suit.

06. Upon consideration of the rival submissions, the learned trial Court, vide order dated 21.12.2022, allowed the application seeking leave to defend, subject to the appellants depositing an amount of Rs. 37.82 lacs before the Court. The relevant portion of the order is reproduced hereunder:

“For the reasons discussed hereinabove and taking strength from the case law referred, with all humility, Court having been satisfied that the defendants have a substantial defence to raise and the defence intended to be put up by the defendants is not frivolous or vexatious, the application of defendant Nos. 2, 3 and 4 for leave to defend are allowed subject to depositing amount of Rs. 37.82 lacs before this Court, which stands released by Legislative Assembly, Secretariat in favour of Estate Department as alleged by the defendants. The defendants shall file written statement within 30 days of this order.”

07. The appellants, being aggrieved of the order dated 21.12.2022 passed by the learned Additional District Judge (Bank Cases), Srinagar, challenged the same before this Court by way of a petition registered as CM(M) No. 39/2023, which came to be dismissed vide order dated 11.05.2023. Following dismissal of the aforesaid petition, the Executive Engineer, Estates Division, Srinagar, vide communication dated 14.06.2023, sought to deposit an amount of Rs. 37.82 lacs, stated to have been released by the Legislative Assembly Secretariat in favour of the Estates Department, so as to enable the appellants to defend the suit in terms of the conditional leave granted by the learned trial Court.

08. Since against the total allotment of Rs. 37.82 lacs, only an amount of Rs. 19.01 lacs was made available under MH- 8743 (DCW) in the Sadder Treasury, Srinagar, accordingly, an amount of Rs. 19.01 lacs was deposited before the learned trial Court through Cheque No. 893458 dated 26.03.2023. In respect of the remaining amount, the erstwhile Estates Departmen

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top